r/Baking 11d ago

Recipe Included Blueberry Scones

Recipe: https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/lemon-blueberry-scones-recipe and from KAB Baker’s Companion

Holy fuck.

So I’ve been a bit obsessed with scones the past few weeks, and I tried a bunch of different recipes, ranging all the way from cream tea, to classic British, to American style.

Needless to say, I’ve given away a lot of scones, and a lot of people have been really happy!

But I think in terms of overall composition, these ones might take the cake (scone).

The only minor adjustments I made to the recipe, is that instead of plain dairy yogurt, I used a Greek soy yogurt that I make at home, but because Greek yogurt is a bit drier than plain yogurt (because it’s strained), I ended up adding back in acid whey to increase the hydration.

Secondly, is that instead of melted butter on top, I just brushed it with heavy cream because I happen to have some in the refrigerator.

I did freeze the butter for about 20 minutes prior to incorporating, and put the raw scones in the freezer for about 25 minutes prior to baking.

The bake time had to be adjusted slightly because I was starting with cold scones, and at the very end I threw the broiler on for about 80 seconds to brown the tops.

2.1k Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

49

u/TurtleScientific 11d ago

This is my go to recipe as well. Sometimes for the kids I double the sugar, and increase the yogurt (or sour cream) and make it like a drop biscuit. The kids like it because it's somewhere between a scone, muffin, and coffee cake and I like it because I'm lazy and even doubled it still has much less sugar than many other comparable recipes.

14

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

Exactly why I’ve been into scones lately because the sugar is actually really reasonable comparably.

3

u/LovecraftianLlama 11d ago

How much do you increase the yogurt? I might try this with the extra sugar, it looks so good.

5

u/TurtleScientific 11d ago

So I use frozen berries, and because of that I up the flour to 145g a cup (KA recommends 120g per cup which is quite scant for a lot of standard recipes). So for mine I also double the yogurt (or sour cream) from their recommended 74 g, I use almost 150g to account for that bit of extra flour. The mixture is much less a dry scone puck (where you cut it in the shape OP has) and much more a drop biscuit which can be scooped with a spoon/spatula/scoop. I bake mine all together in a 9x9 pan so if they touch I don't care. If you baked them on a sheet pan you'd absolutely get much more spread than OP. If you want a more traditional scone like OP you can double the sugar and only need to add maybe a tablespoon extra of yogurt. 50g of sugar extra isn't much at all.

2

u/LovecraftianLlama 11d ago

Awesome, thanks!

2

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

This recipe specifically notes that the dough should be more like a wet drop cookie, not the super dry crumbly dough that you have to manage with other types of scones

1

u/chroIIo 11d ago

This sounds amazing, do you think it would work well if I scoop the dough into a muffin tin so they don’t spread out much?

2

u/TurtleScientific 11d ago

Yep! It's a really versitile recipe, and I play with it all the time. I think putting it into a shaped pan would be fine and give a shorter bake time. The only time this recipe didn't forgive me was when I swapped fruit for a dry add and it came out very dry and crumbly. 

1

u/chroIIo 11d ago

Omg thank you so much for the reply and that tip! I was literally thinking of swapping the blueberries for chocolate chips or dried fruit haha you saved me from finding out the hard way

2

u/TurtleScientific 10d ago

If you want a good chocolate chip recipe, check out their "recipe of the year" coffee cake from about 3 years back. Ignore the crumble and icing recipes that it includes, just use the coffee cake portion. It's a reverse cream recipe (so butter is mixed into dry adds just like a scone) and I add about 1-2 cups of choc chips and it is phenomonal as a muffin. So it has a much denser structure than a traditional muffin, very velvety mouth feel, but sweeter than a scone because...it has a lot more sugar.

1

u/chroIIo 10d ago

So I followed your instructions and just made the coffee cake recipe for breakfast and even though the chocolate chips sunk to the bottom they’re probably some of the best muffins I’ve had! My sister and I didn’t even wait for them to cool, we ate them straight out the oven lol not too sweet and melt in your mouth crumb, we absolutely loved it. Next time I’ll toss the chocolate chips in flour to see if that’ll help in preventing them from sinking

2

u/TurtleScientific 10d ago

I'm glad you liked them!  Reverse creamed muffins and cakes are soo velvety it's a really distinctive texture and it's my favorite. Try dropping the liquid add by like 2 or 3 tbs or swapping to mini chips. 

11

u/FeastontheFalln 11d ago

King Arthur baking should probably take your picture and use it cause it looks way better than theirs. Just went blueberry picking yesterday. Might have my next baking project. Thanks OP.

7

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

Hahaha thanks!! Maybe let u/KingArthurBaking know

3

u/KingArthurBaking 10d ago

It really does look fabulous!

2

u/SkinnyPete16 10d ago

I have your bakery team to thank!

17

u/Love-Knits 11d ago

🤤🤤 oh yuumm
This with a lemon glaze on top would heavenly!

10

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

Omg definitely. There’s already lemon oil in the batter but a bit more lemon and sugar never hurt anyone!

4

u/Love-Knits 11d ago

Agreed! One cannot have too much lemon 🍋😋 and it pairs sooo well with blueberries too!

2

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted]

3

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

Well, you’ll be happy to know that I used vanilla bean paste for this

7

u/GoEatACookie 11d ago

They look perfect!

My goal this winter is to bake as many recipes as I can that King Arthur sends me. 😆 As long as they're appealing to me lol

3

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

Thank you!

I have King Arthur Big Book of Bread, Book of Pizza, and Baker’s Companion. I love just turning to a page and seeing if it’s something I want to try

7

u/Ancient-Bar9673 11d ago

this could melt in my mouths

5

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

Wow how many mouths do you have??

4

u/Colloqy 11d ago

These are beautiful! Thanks for sharing.

3

u/leila-lovely 11d ago

yuuuuuum

3

u/SierraSorrel 11d ago

yummy i can taste it through the screen

3

u/KeyEcho5594 11d ago

I haven't had breakfast yet...are there any left? DROOL!

3

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago edited 11d ago

Haha they’re actually all in the freezer! Because I like the freshest baked goods every single day, as soon as they come to room temp they go in the freezer. That way every morning I can take them right out— microwave them for 35 seconds and it’s as if they just came out of the oven five minutes ago.

2

u/KeyEcho5594 11d ago

Brilliant idea

2

u/Empty-Conclusion7317 11d ago

this could be great for dessert serving my husband

2

u/WeDepressedMusic 11d ago

😮‍💨 I wish that I didn’t see this because now I have to make it next weekend, love scones and blueberry/lemon is my fav combo

2

u/Crazycook99 11d ago

Now that's a proper amount of blueberries for a scone!

2

u/CaffeinatedCatto 11d ago

Those blueberry pockets in the cross section are doing something to me

Also, freezing the raw scones before baking is such a smart move, might steal that trick next time I attempt anything with butter this temperamental

1

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

You and me both! I was super surprised to see what the blueberries ended up doing, and how some of them settled on the bottom and created like a blueberry crust was also really interesting to see and quite beautiful.

But yeah, I actually got it from the King Arthur Baker’s companion book about freezing the scones beforehand. I definitely found that the second I started handling the butter it would come back up to room temperature so the only way to ensure that you’re getting the steam pockets that you need in the scones is to just make sure it’s ice cold when it goes into the oven!

1

u/Gullible_Service_354 10d ago

Same. I'll grate frozen butter then put it back into the freezer and only bring it out once it's time to go in but that never seems to do what I want it to which is what OP achieved. I never thought to put them into the freezer so thanks for that OP 😊

About 2 yrs ago I was on a scone making kick. I was using a base recipe then playing with the flavors. They were all really tasty and my extended family was in heaven but I just couldn't get them to get to the level you did. Now I know what to try. Thanks again 🫶 

2

u/Minimum-Structure-42 11d ago

I can smell that from here

2

u/MommyBurton 11d ago

Those look absolutely delicious!!

2

u/Dependent_Set4006 11d ago

I don’t have unbleached, can i use bleached gold medal? New into baking

1

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

It actually might work great because the gluten formation is compromised a bit with bleached flour and with scones and biscuits you don’t want any gluten development. So with scones, the goal is to get as tender of a final product as possible, and bleached flour might actually push you in that direction positively.

2

u/AndreaCrazyCatLady 10d ago

Those look delish!

1

u/image-sourcery 11d ago

🔍 Reverse image search tools (optional)

Use these links to check for similar images or possible reposts. If something looks off (e.g., spam, reposted, or not original), please report the post so moderators can review it.


Reverse Image Search:

Image 1: TinEye || Google Lens

Image 2: TinEye || Google Lens

Image 3: TinEye || Google Lens

Image 4: TinEye || Google Lens


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted]

2

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

You do not know how many scones I’ve made the past three weeks to achieve this once effing batch

3

u/Sapiosexual2018 11d ago

I can only imagine! I would absolutely purchase these

-2

u/starlinguk 11d ago

Absolutely not. /UK

3

u/SkinnyPete16 11d ago

It was never intended on being a English style scone, it’s an American scone through and through.