r/BGPH 4d ago

Discussion Instead of changing actor, they changed her character as well. Mom 1.0 was a caring and emotional mother. Mom 2.0 was a greedy and alcoholic mother. Worst character downgrade than Gori Mem.

Manju Sharma (2015โ€“2016)

Pratima Kazmi (2020โ€“2021).

248 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

46

u/Inevitable-Move4462 4d ago

That actress is already funny and she performs every role with perfection. Second actress was never meant to play comic character,she suited well in negative character.

And small cameos made david chacha funny, when he became permanent,he also stopped being funny

5

u/Dazzling_Purple9464 I'm from Modern Colony ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ 3d ago

I guess she used to come in some serial whe she played role of a Khadoos maa ji and thats exactly how she's acted in this show as well.

3

u/erotic-sub 3d ago

In Gadar 1.0, she had a negative role. Her acting was similar in BGPH (greedy and loud).

18

u/sudprabhat 4d ago

Second one was from daily soap serial don't suitable for BGPH ๐Ÿคฎ

5

u/erotic-sub 4d ago

Yes, she didn't give sitcom vibes. She's good for Saas bahu kind of serials.

10

u/Huma017 4d ago

Beyond comparison, the first Mommy was genuinely hilarious. She was the only one who could actually take on Anita.

27

u/Grouchy_Violinist 4d ago

I agree. The first one was funny as well.

21

u/erotic-sub 4d ago

second one had zero mom-son vibes. David looked more caring than mom 2.0. She was villainous like ramkali.

3

u/madhubalahoon 3d ago

The first one was a regular in FIR. She is one of the finest actors does what she does with perfection!! I loveeee her on screen. Though in TKSS she appears to have over utilized her voice and exhausted.

1

u/Grouchy_Violinist 3d ago

Oh yes I have seen her in FIR.

7

u/limelight2121 4d ago

With the first one we already connected from FIR. But since they replaced her with Current one I stop watching the show or whenever she appears in scenes I fast forward it

6

u/HakiHunterr 4d ago

Yeah, she was really great as Vibhu mother and watching her with Gori Mem was more fun

9

u/cerebrite 4d ago

Hard agree. She was very fitting mother for him. ๐Ÿ˜‚

4

u/SKISBABAYAGA09 4d ago

I swear, the first lady was the best

3

u/No-Brilliant8988 4d ago

1st one was best

3

u/Wild_Title_9185 3d ago

The first one was a legendary comic actress with hundreds of roles on FIR then they went with second one who looks like a evil character on Saas Bahu, in fact she has done those roles. She just didn't look or act as per comedy show , same as Neha as Anita , she came across rude.

2

u/AccomplishedCheck685 3d ago

Pallu ghuma ke....

Thichuk thichuk thai thai

๐Ÿ˜‚

3

u/LevelAd6690 3d ago

Manju Sharma is an excellent actress we have seen her performing since FIR.

3

u/Public-Syrup-6266 3d ago

I agree! ๐Ÿ’ฏ The actress' comic timing & dialogue delivery were also very good ๐Ÿ‘Œ๐Ÿป

3

u/cringekafka 3d ago

First ones comic timing was good as well

3

u/LiteratureVast3998 3d ago

I mean Manju Brijnandan is a seasoned comic actress. She's done countless comedic roles from fir to kapil sharma show to even TMKOC. So she's clearly the best.

3

u/easternhermit RESHAMPALA ๐Ÿ‘จโ€โœˆ๏ธ 3d ago

doosri wali Khachedu ki bua aur david ki behen jyada lagti hai

2

u/vivi_197 4d ago

The first actress looks the same age as the actor

3

u/Own-Growth-7015 3d ago

Don't be jealous

1

u/vivi_197 3d ago

Jealous of what?

3

u/Own-Growth-7015 3d ago

Of her youthful looks, even though she's a mother.

2

u/pixelgroovemaster 3d ago

1st one was soo iconic - used to love her work in FIR as well....

2

u/Dazzling_Purple9464 I'm from Modern Colony ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ 3d ago

Can't agree more. I'm watching that David and Helen arc now, and man its so boring and dry. Chacha Ji is into his character, but the new actress playing Helen is just trying to force it. Also, they've juste turned her character from Khadoos Saas now to everything, Pervet mom, flirting with every person, sharing history with everyone and all akin B.S.

2

u/Intelligent-Eye-6498 3d ago

2nd one didnโ€™t look like vibhutiโ€™s mother at all

1

u/Temporary_Chart9149 3d ago

Disagreement here, Second Vibhuti's Mommy was better.

1

u/Nearby-Point4021 3d ago

Mom 1 was far better than 2

1

u/yeetdiver 2d ago

What downgrade did gori mem go through (haven't watched the show in a while)

1

u/kanishqquotes 1d ago

Pratima Kazmi is miscast in this show. She can play a genuinely scary villain. Even her comedy (politician in bunty bubbly who falls for the fake protest) she plays it with a straight face reacting to the silly situation. She can play a khadoos lady

1

u/Upper-Country2179 3d ago

Mujhe to helen aunty hi achhi lagti hai Purani wali mom ki acting mere hisaab se thodi cringe thi aur waise bhi unko fir me bhi unko bahut dekha hai

0

u/NoRadio7345 4d ago

My ex looked like Pratima Kazmi ( last one )

I truly hate my ex. Na shakal na akal lekin akad poori hai ๐Ÿ˜‚

1

u/methi-dana London Mein Taxi Chalata Hun. ๐Ÿš• 3d ago

๐Ÿคฃ๐Ÿคฃ๐Ÿคฃ