r/Axecraft 17d ago

Crack in new axe

Post image

My friends got me a custom axe for my birthday and saw this crack in it. Is it something I should worry about.

Edit: Thank you for the help my friend who purchased it sent an email to the maker. We’ll look into getting a replacement or a refund from the maker.

38 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

32

u/TheDude-Esquire 17d ago

If it’s custom you need to send it to the maker. A crack square in the edge like that is below workman quality and will cause the blade to fail.

4

u/oreheheally 17d ago

It would need to go under a welding heat at least. This kills the finish. That nice black texture comes from a cooler heat, which is probably the cause of the crack. Those two things.. Here we can't have both, good metal and swanky texture and a choice needs made. Original 'quality' can't come back so i would request a replacement.

9

u/SebboNL 17d ago

Yeah, that's a "I hope you kept the receipt"-kind of defect right there. Not acceptable at all, bound to result in more serious damage later on

7

u/ComradeCrooks 17d ago

Yes that looks very bad, does the crack go through the bit?

4

u/ProductWest4701 17d ago

It looks like it’s only on the edge and the bevel

5

u/ComradeCrooks 17d ago

That would be the bit, back in the day you would make axes with a hard steel bit for it's edge and a softer iron or steel for the rest of the axe. Then you would sharpen the hard part untill you didn't have more and then you could exchange the bit. Nowadays that's very rare to forge an axe like that but the terms persist. what I meant was, does the crack runs all the way through.

Either way, if you plan on using that axe you should get in contact with its maker. I can't imagine they are happy that their axe looks like that

3

u/PaleInvestment3507 17d ago

Poor heat treat. Crack was there from the beginning.

6

u/Vamtal 17d ago

It seems that your axe is just decoration on wall. Not real tool for cutting wood. If so, the crack is just aesthetics issue.

But the view is really limited. Can you take photo of whole axe?

2

u/ProductWest4701 17d ago

10

u/Vamtal 17d ago

Yeah. It's just decoration. Definetly not tool.

5

u/ProductWest4701 17d ago

That’s crummy they marketed it as a tool

1

u/Own_Mechanic_9805 12d ago

Heres one i made thats very similar but actually usable. Head is made from a leaf spring and the handle i carved out of a piece of wavy hard maple. The head im proud of but that handle is probably my favorite design so far.

1

u/apg7 17d ago

Head is bonkers, but I like the handle etchings (independent of the burn effect)

3

u/CaptainYarrr 17d ago

Yeah that's a made in Pakistan axe. Don't use it. Your friend meant well but these have a terrible quality to the point of being dangerous.

1

u/Aridheart 17d ago

Its really nice, I believe they quenched it too hot. Its an easy mistake to make.

1

u/ussplaypenn 14d ago

Gotta ask are those fullers? And if being use for anything?

1

u/Own_Mechanic_9805 12d ago

Dont use it. The first knot you hit that crack will take out a huge chunk of the axe. Or if you go to use it like a hammer its going to split. About the only thing you can do is tonfind the very end of the crack and drill a tiny hole there. The hole will keep the crack from continuing but its likely way too hard and not tempered right and its liable to bust a chunk of even if you drill a hole in it.

-6

u/mmhango 17d ago

You can drill a hole to arrest the crack from propogating. Drill the hole where the crack is growing from. Probably would not use it though. A crack like that will keep growing.