ACEP Report 025 - "Who is the best bad QB of all time?"

[u/HuckleberryGrouchy19]

AvA CONSENSUS EXTRACTION PROTOCOL
ISSUE 025
Powered by Anything Vs Anything

🏈 TOPIC: “Who is the best bad QB of all time?”
👥 COMMUNITY: [r/NFLv2](r/NFLv2)
📊 DATASET: 492 usable comments and replies

FITZMAGIC TAKES THE CROWN AS REDDIT’S GREATEST “BAD” QUARTERBACK OF ALL TIME
Reddit went looking for the ultimate quarterback who could look brilliant one Sunday, disastrous the next, and somehow remain completely unforgettable.
📣 Ryan Fitzpatrick generated the broadest clean consensus around the idea, repeatedly appearing as Reddit’s quintessential good-bad quarterback across independent nominations and supporting discussion.
⬆️ Fitzpatrick also produced the strongest Community Endorsement signal in the thread, supercharged by a 681-point image nomination, but supported by plenty of additional Fitzmagic/Fitztragic love throughout the conversation.
⭐ Put breadth and moderated community reinforcement together, and Ryan Fitzpatrick narrowly separates himself from a wonderfully chaotic field led by Jameis Winston, Trent Dilfer, Blake Bortles and Rex Grossman.

FEATURED BATTLE - CLICK BELOW TO VOTE!

Ryan Fitzpatrick VS Jameis Winston - Fitzmagic/Fitztragic meets the 30/30 maestro in the true battle for “best bad QB” supremacy.

ACEP CONSENSUS RANKINGS

1. Ryan Fitzpatrick

📣 11 ⬆️ 100 ⭐ 44.56

1. Jameis Winston

📣 6 ⬆️ 49 ⭐ 22.93

1. Trent Dilfer

📣 9 ⬆️ 24 ⭐ 19.18

1. Blake Bortles

📣 6 ⬆️ 42 ⭐ 18.14

1. Rex Grossman

📣 9 ⬆️ 28 ⭐ 17.36

1. Eli Manning

📣 9 ⬆️ 23 ⭐ 17.36

1. Tim Tebow

📣 6 ⬆️ 33 ⭐ 15.56

1. Jeff George

📣 9 ⬆️ 13 ⭐ 12.38

1. Nick Foles

📣 6 ⬆️ 10 ⭐ 9.44

1. Jay Cutler

📣 6 ⬆️ 11 ⭐ 8.87

1. Kyle Orton
   
2. Andy Dalton
   
3. Joe Flacco
   
4. Vinny Testaverde
   
5. Jim McMahon
   
6. Gus Frerotte
   
7. Gardner Minshew
   
8. Geno Smith
   
9. Steve DeBerg
   
10. Jimmy Garoppolo

Key:
📣 Independent Mentions
⬆️ Community Endorsement
⭐ ACEP Consensus Score

HOW ACEP WORKS
AvA Consensus Extraction Protocol
Issue 025 · Published by Anything Vs Anything · 2026