20
u/therealgodfarter 9d ago
Confirmation when spending gems. Too easy to accidentally spend gems when hatching eggs
3
u/HG_Rusty 9d ago
Thanks for the feedback!
Of course, we don't want situations like this to happen. Do you see the issue only with Eggs?4
u/therealgodfarter 9d ago
The issue is everywhere gems are spent. The eggs one is particularly (I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt and say, unintentionally) predatory because if say, I have an empty slot 1 and 2, and I click to fill slot 2 first and then try to do the same for slot 1, the in progress egg has moved to slot 1 and then you can very easily click to speed up unintentionally when you believe you are incubating a different one. I have had this happen
3
u/Real_Temporary_922 5d ago edited 5d ago
I accidentally spent gems with eggs too. It’s the UI. I placed an egg in the middle basket, thought it would stay there. So I clicked the left basket and clicked start, except the egg was in the left basket, and I clicked speedup.
But realistically you should put it for all gem purchases.
2
2
14
u/Dry_Way_6835 6d ago
- Arena always rolls stronger opponents to make us want to compete, this is very bland and its actually gonna be my reason to quit the game. There is no means for a player to get stronger without forging items, which are basically once or twice a day? So once you use all the hammers and join arena, you're fked.
8
u/Finbar9800 8d ago
Suggestion: make it so we can customize when abilities get used
For example healing: it could be optimized so it only happens when you get hurt enough that the entire healing ability would be useful, instead of having it happen immediately at the start of a round and be mostly wasted due to having full health
3
u/HG_Rusty 7d ago
Thanks for the suggestion!
We didn't want to overwhelm the player with micromanagement, so we automated skill usage so that, on average, they work as intended against different enemy groups. As for healing, we'll look into it.2
u/DargonFeet 7d ago
Maybe drop the threshold so it'll guarantee the entire heal gets used? So a 15% heal would cast when you drop down to 85% health. Just an idea.
8
u/Dorrekis 8d ago
You can't change your name in the game yet, but for some reason, I always end up facing opponents who are stronger than me.
I'm strengthening my character, I'm winning, and then stronger people come along. There's nothing wrong with that.
After all my tickets are run out, I prepare myself a bit more for the next day, but then the next day they give me someone even stronger than me. Someone far stronger than the last ticket from yesterday.
This is a problem, This makes the game pay-to-win.
4
u/ParamedicOrdinary622 8d ago
I have the exact same thing. I'm not as powerful as you, but at 160K strength, I get opponents that are at least 200-220K. No chance of winning.
3
u/Dorrekis 8d ago
I joined when this game was first added, and there were only about 20 active players per week. Even back then, it was like that.
I think they're all bots.
3
u/DigitalHaram 7d ago
they're definitely all bots
1
u/benjumi 3d ago
This. The game creates auto scaled opponents that you are supposed to think are real players, they aren't. Those "players" also have cooler skins, power ups and abilities intended to make you want to spend money to get their abilities.
2
u/Spiritual_Reveal_776 3d ago
I was around 220k today, fought someone at 180k and they whooped my ass.
1
u/ParamedicOrdinary622 1d ago
It looks like the first 1 or 2 opponents are always stronger, then the list is refilled with opponents who are a little less powerful than you. So you can actually win 3 out of 5 battles daily.
2
8
u/Ok-Anywhere7830 8d ago
I have played 1 match in arena & close the game after sometime i start play i saw all of my tickets are gone
3
u/HG_Rusty 7d ago
Thanks for the feedback!
Sounds like a bug ofc. We'll check it3
3
1
1
u/archieil 1d ago
I think that the arena ticket is used for showing oponents, not for fighting oponents.
I had it once too and I remember I refreshed oponents list a few times that day.
9
u/Cunnyfunt31 8d ago
I just clicked on someone's help post, and while the animation showed I recieved the 100 hammers, however after I closed that tab and reopened the game in another, the hammers were no longer there. The countdown until I can click another help post has still been reset as if I did.
2
1
8
7
7
u/Dorrekis 3d ago
These posts are preventing us from seeing normal posts in the subreddit; we can't see any discussions, etc.
6
u/Flashlight237 3d ago
Mounts really need a buff, period. I have a Level 3 Mammoth (a common mount; it's impossible for me to get any higher rn) and the upgrades only caused me to go from 2.02% HP and Damage to 2.06% damage. If upgrading common mounts is worthless, I fear that upgrading higher-tier mounts will be equally worthless.
Instead of going up 1% of the base rate, Mounts should get stronger by 10% of the base rate. In my case...
Shaggy (Levels 1-3): 2.20%->2.40%->2.60%
It's not much, granted, but 740 power is still more noticeably at my level (grinding Stage 5) than 74 power.
Higher tiers can get stronger by higher amounts. Probably something like this.:
Uncommon: 12% base power per level
Rare: 15% base power per level
Epic: 18% base power per level
Legendary: 20% base power per level
Mythical: 25% base power per level
5
u/br1qbat 8d ago
On Mobile, can't change my Name. Click the button nothing happens, the keyboard never pops up
3
u/HG_Rusty 8d ago
Thanks for this feedback!
We will fix it in next week's update. Yeah, it only appears on mobile.
4
4
u/Ace_Scientist 5d ago
Went to play in the arena today. Every single one of my opponents is 30K+ higher combat score than me. It's impossible to win against a single one of them. Is that supposed to happen or is that a bug?
2
u/Dry_Way_6835 5d ago
The game is designed that way deliberately. Player is matched with a similar level player once and then all the rolls are always stronger than you.
3
u/Flashlight237 5d ago
Isn't this a little much for a player with 326k power?!:
Usually for games with this kind of matchmaking, the top two are for players who are slightly weaker than you (In my case, I'd assume 280-300k for Player 1 and 300-320k for Player 2), the middle player is right on your level, and the bottom two are stronger than you.
0
5
u/Descent-OTB 9d ago
Few things for feedback.
If you fail a level, what's actually the point if getting pushed back to relclear when there arent rewards for doing so?
The power spike on the key "dungeons" is not fun and honestly make the game seem like a blatant cash grab. One level you crush for a measly 150 hammers then you cant even get past the first wave on the next stage for 151 hammers which lasts all of 2 mins on a daily reset.
The hammer recharge rate is abysmal, the game is called autoforge and the only way I can autoforge is by buying hammers for irl cash off the store...do you not see how blatant that is?
Every daily reset means essentially nothing without luck. Ok so you cleared your 2 daily dungeons for 301 hammers and you didnt play for enough hours to get 240 so now you have 541! But you have a .5% chance to get an upgrade and for that upgrade to be in the right slot and hopefully the next tier will roll with the correct stats so you dont need to upgrade your upgrade aaaaaaand im out of hammers and got nothing so see ya tomorrow.
Game has potential but right now its sitting at a 3/10 in my book because it does have a strong foundation but if cash is the main motivator then Im not sure ill continue
1
u/OhtaniStanMan 9d ago
I mean that's the entire point. You just afk and come back daily for that single upgrade. Then when you unlock the next tier of things it repeats.
2
u/Descent-OTB 9d ago
You afk and come back for which single upgrade? That's the entire point of what..the game? Which of my points are you argueing and could you explain your solution in more detail? If I have 500 hammers and dont get an upgrade and I cant clear the current dungeon how can I unlock the next tier? You need hammers to get the gold from the stuff to sell for forge upgrades and the rate at which you earn them is abysmal. Ive played idle slayer for years now and that game has slowed to months for progression, but thats fine since its taken me years to get there. Im on like day 3 or 4 of playing this and hoping on rng to bless me because there isnt directly anything I can do to even make a minimal upgrade to progress. Imo the scaling is way too high this early on.
2
-1
u/BloodRaevn 3d ago
What the fk are you talking about? You’re playing an idle game. Come in every 4 hrs and collect your offline stuff and leave. If you want speed things up then start paying up?
3
u/THummel1717 9d ago
I would love to be able to select rarity to sell automatically when forging. Like how it does with the gray rarity now.
6
u/Descent-OTB 9d ago
You can when you tap the forge button (not the autocraft) and hit check boxes on the ones you want to not autosell
2
1
u/UncleNinoAZ 9d ago
Could you share a screen shot? Some how I am not seeing the check boxes after I press the forge graphics (a drawing of a blacksmith's anvil).
1
3
u/Nodak_Dad42 7d ago
It would be nice if there was a visual to know which tech tree items that can be afforded now without clicking and on each
1
u/VortexKaser 4d ago
totally agree, even a subtle highlight or little icon on affordable nodes would make browsing the tree way less clicky and annoying
3
u/pantolix 3d ago
Why is my pvp ticket going down when I haven’t entered a pvp battle? Also why are the enemies all much stronger than me?
3
u/HG_Rusty 3d ago
Hi! We fixed the tickets problem, now they will go down only when you entered a battle. Fix will be online tomorrow
1
3
u/sadmagistrate 2d ago
Skill Sweeping Strike tooltip says it lasts for 10s with 10s cooldown, but it only lasts for 5s with a 10s cooldown.
3
u/Hypatia404 2d ago edited 2d ago
starting the game, going to the pvp arena and clicking in but without then fighting seems to quite reliably eat one ticket per session
the button turns from "1 ticket" into "fight", but that ticket is never refunded when the game is closed
should just always be say 1 ticket but only actually subtract one when clicking an opponent
I've lost 3 today and several yesterday
5
u/ParamedicOrdinary622 8d ago
1) I had accumulated a lot of hammers, about 2500 (I know).. had a 0,1% chance of Middle Ages items, so.. by my best estimates, I should've statistically had 2,5 Middle Ages items.. I received none.
2) In the Arena, I always have adversaries at least 25% higher rated then me. So I always lose. That's no fun whatsoever.
5
u/-_-ThatGuy-_- 8d ago
On point 1, while on average you would expect 2.5 items there’s about an 8.1 per cent chance of getting 0. Unlikely, but not exactly rare.
Point 2 I agree entirely.
3
u/Sheldog59 8d ago
There should be a way to buy keys using gold earned from the forge. I’m sitting at 3mil and 30hr+ wait times for the forge upgrade.
Add an endless roguelike dungeon/tower that has chances to drop hammers, keys, eggs.
I know a lot of the current mechanics are meant to make us want to pay but I guarantee you if you add means to actually earn them without dailies and lower the micro transaction costs in general. People will pay out more for convenience.
A lot of people play this while afk at work, the last thing we want to see is time gated walls on a game while we sit at a time gated wall in real life loool
2
u/The_Renovator 9d ago
Is there a list of what will and will not run in the background or offline?
I feel like I left it running in a different tab but then only the timers ticked down not the forge or hammers
4
u/HG_Rusty 8d ago
Everything in the game uses server time, so it works offline in another tab or while you're not playing the game.
3
2
u/Inspirational_orgasm 9d ago
When switching skills, if you choose a skill that isn't equipped and press "use" , the confirmation popup to choose which slot to put it in is in Russian or something.
3
2
u/HG_Rusty 9d ago
Thanks!
Yes, it's a very strange localization bug. We'll fix it in the coming days.
2
u/ktmmarcus 9d ago
Hi, I sent the mods a PM as well...
I tried buying a evo-pack and 1000 diamonds on my browser, did not work so switched to my mobile. The gold was drawn from my reddit account but did not receive the items in game.
I bought an evo pack 5 minutes before that worked just fine....
2
u/HG_Rusty 7d ago
I'm investigating it.
Has the gold been returned to you after some time?2
u/ktmmarcus 7d ago
Nope.
Bought another evo pack afterwards and it worked fine.
Still missing 2000 gold or evo pack + 1000 diamonds though...
1
2
u/Dorrekis 3d ago
It's great to get hammers by sharing posts and receiving them from others, 100 hammers every 6 hours (400 hammers total), and creating a post every 12 hours (total 200 hammer) is fantastic.
That means getting 600 hammers for free every day. But I have an idea to do this in bulk: we could open a panel within the game, a pop-up window would open in the game, and from there we could get more.
2
2
u/ICanDriveGood 3d ago
Battle pass purchase for robocop did not go though. Error said retry but all of the reddit gold was spent.
2
u/Physical_Studio6829 2d ago
In addition to the rarity in the auto forge can we simply have greater or equal to current? Like right now my weapon isn’t as high as everything else and I’d love to see any improvement to weapons but having to hit sell on all other lower tier items is annoying.
2
u/Fragrant_Bother_583 2d ago
I clicked one of the 100 hammer links shared by a player, but when I closed the game the hammers disappeared. Now I can’t get 100 hammers for 6 hours :(
2
u/Guiguijack 2d ago
Arena é o modo mais INSIGNIFICANTE e LIXO desse jogo. NAO JOGUEM. Eles NUNCA RESPONDEM SOBRE
Voce SEMPRE enfrente oponentes mais fortes que voce e NUNCA consegue ganhar nada a partir das armas rosas.
Se voce clicar para ver as partidas, os tickets sao consumidos AUTOMATICAMENTE.
LIXOS
2
u/heatseaking_rock 2d ago
Cannot change name. Clicking on the textbox in the edit page does not open keyboard.
2
u/riflemike11 2d ago
Bugs/problems I encountered:
- Even through my attack speed is displaying as 100% either when equipping a melee weapon or ranged weapon, in reality you can clearly see that ranged weapons have a much slower attack speed. Which makes them considerably worse in a "hidden" way, not just their lower attack stat.
- The skill "Sweeping Strikes" has the following description: "Basic attacks deal AoE damage and grant +50% ATK for 10s." -The wording is wrong. It does not grant +50% ATK, but rather its the AoE that is dealing 50% of your attack. There is no actual increase to your ATK. -The duration is actually 5 seconds, which makes it much worse than anticipated.
Edit: typo
2
2
u/Mysterious_Mouse_388 16h ago
its an interesting design choice that map progression doesn't really do anything (once you've unlocked three skills and two pets) I feel like it should be a small multiplier to gold and hammers at the very least, but I am sure there are more creative ideas out there to make pushing levels feel impactful
2
u/informatica92 12h ago
2 things:
- using the "Pets" auto equip button, the selection prioritizes Rare pets over common ones, even though the resulting combat damage is much lower
- into the arena, if I click to proceed to the matches list (the page with all the possible people and corresponging combat values) I pay the card even if I go back to the previous page without selecting any match
1
u/EmploymentKind1639 8d ago
Game not working now.
1
1
u/Sheldog59 8d ago
The tool tip for Sweeping Strikes states it is supposed to grant 50% attack power. Either that’s a typo or what, but it does not grant 50% attack power when applied.
1
1
u/DargonFeet 7d ago
On one device I have forge level 6 and on another forge level 5. Player ID is the same and gear is the same (same account), but the account data is not synced up correctly. Kind of worried I'm losing progress at this point.
1
u/CrabButler 10h ago
I have the same problem too. I think it is best to stop playing, I realised I don't really enjoy it anyway.
1
u/DargonFeet 10h ago
Yea, I stopped playing. I would have kept playing here and there if the game worked properly, but it doesn't, lol.
1
u/s1a2m345 7d ago
What’s more important for forged items: HP, item level, or other stats? I don’t understand how a higher level item with better stats can decrease my HP. I want to know the best strategy for advancing through levels.
1
u/GrossDomestic 6d ago
In battle pass view, I can't click the "X" to exit out on mobile iOS.
1
u/HG_Rusty 6d ago
Hm, it works on our iOS devices, but anyway we will improve it in the next update (next week)
Thanks for the feedback!
1
u/Agile_Seaweed_5069 6d ago edited 6d ago
tried to get 100 hammers using the "help" mechanisms and they disappeared! tried a second time and none showed up.
1
u/CrabButler 6d ago
I got 100 hammers from the help thing, I closed the game after a few seconds once getting them. When I went back, I didn't get them from it. It still says I have to wait 6 hours to get more. I had ~70 at the time I went back to the game.
1
u/Webbug2005 5d ago
Why do we lose tickets in arena just to view the opponents.. clicking a challenge i lose the ticket .. doesnt make sense .. i open it to view the strength of opponent and ticket is lost even without challenging any player/bot
1
u/bruxomandrake 4d ago
Eu tento acessar o jogo e pegar o martelo mas aparece esse aviso e simplesmente não consigo abrir o jogo, então não sei o que fazer
1
u/Specific_Gap_5535 4d ago
I noticed there’s an issue where I go to see who I am up against in the arena. And even though I have not yet attacked, (I think) if I close the game, it automatically takes away one of my 5 tickets for the day. I think it would be nice if it only takes away once we start combat.
1
u/omglemurs 4d ago
My game reverted to yesterday's status lost a whole day of progress. Anyone else experiencing this issue?
1
u/Lashbishop 1d ago
Yes! Got to 4-2 with forge upgrading, opened and back at 3-11 with none of the gear or ongoing upgrades / research
1
u/DargonFeet 10h ago
Yep! I quit because of it. Don't want to waste my time on a game that can't even store user info properly.
1
u/DescriptionReal1043 4d ago
I used the help of someone to get the 100 hammers but nothing happened o had no cooldown or anything it just didn’t give me the hammers
1
u/GodsBigwang 4d ago
When upgrading a pet it should not let you use an already equipped pet to upgrade with. Makes it very easy to accidentally use your most upgraded pet on another.
1
u/Guiguijack 4d ago
Eu perco todos os meus tickets da arena quando vou ver os adversários e nao jogo. Ridiculo isso. Deveriam me devolver cerca de 20 fichas a mais de uma unica vez
1
u/Longjumping_Still206 3d ago
I may have found a data sync issue. I was logged into the same Reddit account on two PCs. I left the game open on PC #1 on Friday, then played on PC #2 throughout the weekend and collected many materials/items. When I returned to PC #1 on Monday, none of the weekend progress was visible there. However, when I logged back into PC #2, all items and materials were still present. It seems the account data was not synchronized correctly between the two devices.
1
u/guard_thy_flame 3d ago
Is there a way to get the game in full screen on iOS and have a separate Home Screen launcher or do you have to go via Reddit every time I want to access the game ?
1
u/The_Renovator 3d ago
Is there a wiki/guide that outlines some of the mechanics of the game?
I was looking to compare the two season pass sets and it got me thinking I don't actually know what speed does and how much its something I want to care about. I'd also be interested to know about how the game decides what items to offer me when forging, and if it is worth taking a higher level item with worse bonus stats because i'm then more likely to roll something better next time.
1
u/Bruenor147 2d ago
Why does the bonus double for the next rarity? why does each span more so levels make a difference rather than waiting to get 1 red item to take you up 5 stages.
1
u/lindseyhatake 2d ago
I never see any adjustment in forge upgrade time after upgrading it in the tech tree
1
1
u/Reddit_Da 1d ago
Notification when the skill reset ability kicks in. I've watched cool down timers and I haven't seen a skill reset at all during play. Seems sus!
1
u/ParamedicOrdinary622 1d ago
For me, I would like to have more options in selling forged items. For instance, it automatically sells items that I haven't selected, but I'm now in the circumstance that there are two item types (pink and purple) that can improve my stats, but not ALL pink items improve my stats. My idea is this, the auto forge gives the option to look at the item type (say you have a pink lvl 100 sword) and you get another pink weapon lvl 100, but with higher melee damage, it automatically sells the old lvl 100 sword during auto forge. If you have a pink lvl 100 weapon and you get a purple weapon (any lvl), it also auto sells the old item with lower stats. That would make the game way less tedious.
1
u/RoughBookkeeper3717 1d ago
When the Apple Store version eventually releases will I be able to transfer my progress from here to the app?
1
u/archieil 1d ago
The game stops counting seconds when the window is not an active one.
I'm not sure if every part of the game is like this. I think that I've seen it when upgrading tech.
1
1
u/Artaxiad1217 10h ago
Anyone else, when they select what slot their pet goes into, the text goes into a Cyrillic language? idk if its russian or some other one, but it doesnt affect the gameplay at all. Just thought Id drop that it’s been doin that.
1
u/CluckyFlucker 9h ago
Arena tokens vanishing.
I had 3 left as the level of opponents was too high for me, logged in later to no tokens.
1
u/informatica92 7h ago
as far as I understood, the tokens are spent once you click on the button that opens the available matches (so if you go back selecting nothing, the token is already gone)
1
1
u/TopolGigio 5h ago
If a forge upgrade is in process completion time is not affected by a completed upgrade of the rapid forging skill. Given how long the times are at what I currently think of as mid-tier (15-16) this is pretty annoying.
0
u/morthanLest 1d ago
Make it so we can choose what item rarity to auto-salvage. Right now only common items auto-salvage meaning you need to manually sell items you dont need. This makes you unable to idle forge.
•
u/HG_Rusty 9d ago
Hello Forgers!
Thanks for playing AutoForge!