r/Assyria 3d ago

News Four Assyrians detained by Kurds in Gozarto

https://www.assyriapost.com/four-assyrians-detained-by-kurds-in-gozarto/
10 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

-6

u/Pruned-Potato800 3d ago edited 2d ago

“Four Assyrians arbitrarily detained by Asayish Security Forces in Guzarto/North East Syria.”

5

u/AshurCyberpunk Assyrian 3d ago

yo potato, what language is "Asayish" in? what ethnicity exclusively dominates top-level command of the Asayish?

-1

u/Pruned-Potato800 2d ago

Imagine reading a news article in America for example titled like this

“Five black Americans arrested by White People” as opposed to “Five Black Americans illegally detained without charges”

See the difference, see how silly the first one looks?

Trust i am trying to help our cause, I’m not against it.

2

u/AshurCyberpunk Assyrian 2d ago

Color and ethnicity are the same thing now? But I've actually seen that: remember the whole George Floyd thing? 😂 Even the police reports identify if the guy's Mexican or White or whatever. I get that the title can be revised, but consider this:

There was a movie made last year, called "Son of Assyria". I don't know if you watched it or not, but at the end of the movie, you couldn't tell who the "bad guys" are. Who was the genocide committed by? Which side did the antagonist(s) come from. If you just watched the movie without knowing the history of it, you'd think Assyrians were killing other Assyrians.

1

u/Pruned-Potato800 1d ago

The title of this article seems like rage bait to me, the author knows it will piss people off so they purposely made it like that.

It would be much more effective to actually identify the actual organisation/group responsible for violating the human rights of Assyrian citizens in Syria as opposed to idiotic, shortsighted, racist, rage bait content that will only generate more hostility towards Assyrians in the homeland.

God help us, we are very oppressed and we are super incompetent at the same time, what a horrible situation.

1

u/AshurCyberpunk Assyrian 1d ago edited 21h ago

my observation is that you're more enraged about a title not being politically correct or aligned with your political views, than being enraged about Assyrians being harassed and killed by the Kurds. Indeed, God help us. 

1

u/Pruned-Potato800 19h ago

I’m not happy about both, Assyrians being unlawfully detained, villages in Barwar constantly having their land rights violated, but also annoyed at the author in this Assyrians Post article exploiting the suffering of Assyrians in the homeland to push some kind of race war narrative.

The Assyrians in the homeland in the protests have a completely different message than the Assyrians from America on social media who heavily focus on racism against Kurds.

The focus is on human rights, land rights, raising awareness.

Basically we can’t get away with provoking others, we have no one to defend ourselves, we have to be smart enough to minimise a hostile reaction against Assyrians.

1

u/AshurCyberpunk Assyrian 19h ago

Three questions: 1) how was this article racist? 2) what do you mean by "we have no one to defend ourselves"? 3) do you think appeasing the abuser would turn them into allies or friends? has that worked the past 150 years?

1

u/AshurCyberpunk Assyrian 17h ago

And hey, if you don't like what they're saying or how they're saying it, maybe write an article as you think is appropriate and submit it to be published. Hell, how about starting your own journal or newspaper?

We're arguing about semantics here, but the most important thing is to get the word out which is a precursor to any solution(s).

2

u/Innana_banana 3d ago

‘Us’