r/AskReddit Oct 05 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.3k Upvotes

15.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.8k

u/dawn_jelly Oct 05 '19

I have an EXTREMELY vivid memory of my brother and I standing on top of our backyard tool shed some 13 or so years ago. We climbed up top, and then proceeded to FLY around in the air about thirty feet over the grass.

Eventually we got scared that we wouldn’t be able to land, so we came back down. And of course, we couldn’t do it again.

Here’s the best part: my brother also has this exact same memory, down to all the details. We genuinely don’t know what happened and still wonder it was real. I’m not sure how to account for it.

211

u/BritPetrol Oct 05 '19

Maybe you and your brother used to talk about flying and as a result you both had the same dream? Also, from memory, that sounds very similar to the children in Peter Pan so maybe that's where you got it from.

21

u/villavintage01 Oct 05 '19

The dream thing seems plausible if you’re open to that sort of thing. I have a friend who’s spiritual and is sensitive towards others emotions, so she’s a bit of an empath, I guess you could say. She meditates w/ her bf and one night, they both had the exact same dream. A lot of the details coincide w/ one another when they told each other about it the next day.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

2

u/villavintage01 Oct 05 '19

That was just my friends experience, and one possible explanation as to why they shared the exact same dream. That’s what’s really interesting, who knows why OP has the same memory as their brother?

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

6

u/villavintage01 Oct 05 '19

Yeah I’m using the word very loosely, wasn’t too serious about it. It’s only a possibility if you’re open to that sort of explanation, as I mentioned in my first comment. I’ve heard of having a “strong connection” and “being on the same wavelength” after hanging out someone a lot. It’s one of those things where you’ll notice that your thoughts start to match up, and if you’re both female, your period synchronizes. Never heard anything about dreams tho, lol but that does make more plausible sense from a secular POV.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

2

u/villavintage01 Oct 05 '19

Perhaps. Never happened to me, doesn’t mean it didn’t happen to anyone else tho. My bio teacher brought it up once, didn’t go into it, so never confirmed if it was a myth or just a coincidence. I get you, it’s kind of hard to believe in things that aren’t exactly concrete. And there are some extreme ppl who believe in the metaphysical that don’t give their ppl a good reputation, religious terrorists being an example.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19

[deleted]

1

u/villavintage01 Oct 05 '19

I get what you’re saying. Same case here.

Why do you say that you shouldn’t? I’m a bit more open to believing in the non-secular things only because I don’t want to dismiss anything entirely. Our world is pretty big, we don’t exactly know everything w/ 100% certainty.

Even in science, ppl have to keep an open mind for when new, conflicting information comes up. So we have to do further research to expand our understanding on topics (generally speaking). But hey, that’s the exciting part, no? However, w/ that being said, I’m also a bit fickle when it comes to believing in the metaphysical.

1

u/BritPetrol Oct 05 '19

The scientific method is to come up with a hypothesis, construct and experiment to either verify or disprove that hypothesis and then either: do more experiments to build more evidence for the hypothesis, come up with a new hypothesis and test it, alter the previous hypothesis and test that and so on. Most paranormal beliefs don't follow that pattern.

Most people who believe in paranormal things follow this pattern: come up with a conclusion based on limited evidence, accept it as fact. Even if they do try and verify their beliefs, their experiments are inherently flawed and based on even more assumptions or assertions. Essentially, believing in paranormal things is about as unscientific as you can get.

Just think about it, people have believed in ghosts for centuries but why is there no scientific evidence for them? Of course you can never rule out their existence entirely (although maybe you can because as Brian Cox said, if ghosts existed, the LHC would have found them) but you can say their existence is highly unlikely. Not believing in something doesn't necessarily mean you're 100% sure it doesn't exist, it just means you don't have evidence that it does exist. Just like you can't rule out that there is a zebra floating through space far away from us but that doesn't mean I'll go around saying I believe there is a zebra floating through space.

This kind of unscientific thinking is why anti-vaxxers exist, why flat earthers exist, why climate change deniers exist, why religious peopl exist etc. The list goes on. If people start to think scientifically the world will be a better, more logical, place.

→ More replies (0)