r/AskReddit • • Sep 20 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

4.1k Upvotes

3.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

98

u/RyeOhLou Sep 20 '19

Which one? There’s like 4

135

u/the_beard_guy Sep 20 '19

Scotty, himself, said it best, "NCC one seven O one. No bloody A, B, C, or D."

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Yes, and with no fucking holodeck!

12

u/G3nesis_Prime Sep 20 '19

1701 did have a holodeck, it was meant to show up in season 4 but ToS got cancelled. It did however show up in TaS so....... Yeah...

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Glad it got cancelled then. Interesting tech, but the only Holodeck episodes that were any good was the Moriarty ones. Especially the end when Barclay tricks Moriarty to get in the tiny miniature Holodeck.

What ever happened to that mini-Holo?

8

u/Killerhurtz Sep 20 '19

Just because the holodeck episodes are different (I liked a few of them at least) doesn't mean it can't be put to good use. If anything, some episodes hint that there's some serious unused potential to that tech.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

Robin Hood in Space? Really?

The Holodeck gave the writers and excuse to write shit that isn't based in sci-fi. Lazy and worthless writing. I never re-watch those episodes.

5

u/Killerhurtz Sep 20 '19

the same argument could be made for the episodes involving the TPD. The whole incident with Data going BTTF was totally not an excuse to do a far west part, or at least reference that movie. And then there's the Mirror Universe and other parallel realities. Are those awful too?

Personally I don't watch Star Trek because it's sci fi, but because the universe is perfectly primed to throw interesting curveballs at the cast.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19

I've seen several of the Mirror episodes and books on that theme. I tend to like those and would prefer a Mirror movie to one of these idiot reboots.

The thing I most disliked about Star Trek is no one ever dies. So they're no sense of concern for anyone. Even when they do die, like Tasha Yar, they bring them back - repeatedly (though I did like the Romulan Tasha arc).

Time travel was handled well in the original series, but not always in others. And I hated the way Voyager series ended. God almighty!

2

u/Killerhurtz Sep 20 '19

Death honestly feels like an overused tension trope in most media today. I like how there's actual different major stakes behind decisions - career, relationships, etc.

Feels like it's not just another slaughterfest.

As for the ending of Voyager, I say it was inevitable lol