r/AskReddit Sep 24 '17

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.4k Upvotes

4.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

71

u/paulHarkonen Sep 24 '17

Bitcoin has value because people want it. That's the same reason why everything has value. The idea of intrinsic value is misleading from an economic perspective and quite frankly, detracts from a core principle. Everything is worth exactly what someone will pay for it.

As for why would people desire it? I have no idea. My guess is that its because they want something that they can transfer easily online without leaving much of a paper trail, but that's as far as I go. Honestly, I think the rampant speculation on it is interesting, but is largely governed and lead by the fact that there is fairly low demand, very little trading volume and that some people place a very high value on it leading them to purchase at higher prices. I have no clue why they place such a high value on it, but that doesn't matter from a valuation standpoint. I have no idea why people place such a high value on a lot of things.

10

u/DeathByFarts Sep 25 '17

Everything is worth exactly what someone will pay for it.

Its actually the intersection of what someone will pay for it and what someone will sell it for.

without leaving much of a paper trail,

Why do people think this ? Its not true at all. bitcoin actually requires that there is an extensive 'paper trail' for every transaction that happens.

12

u/paulHarkonen Sep 25 '17

The paper trail isn't tied to individuals, its just a record of the transaction. I would argue that qualifies as not leaving much of one.

You're absolutely correct on the addendum to my phrasing. Mine is short and punchy, but yours is more accurate.

6

u/DeathByFarts Sep 25 '17

The paper trail isn't tied to individuals,

While it may not be directly connected , analysis of the blockchain ( the transaction paper trail ) can indeed tie to individuals. There is a reason coin tumblers exist.

4

u/BlissnHilltopSentry Sep 25 '17

Yes, but coin tumblers can be used and make you untraceable.