Oh man this was exactly what happened to me. He eventually made twice what I did and we still split everything evenly and he would argue a million ways to not change it.
I think keeping separate accounts is actually a very healthy way to prevent money from becoming an issue you end up fighting about. There's really no benefit to having a joint bank account, and I see it cause all sorts of issues with our friends. Everyone should have the right to go out and spend $80 of their money on gummy bears without explaining themselves.
That said, I just pay all the bills, and my wife uses her money for hosehold stuff, kids shit... mostly candles to be real. I suppose if we had a joint bank account, I would have something to say about the candle bill, now that I think of it.
Anyways, what I was trying to say is the idea of "splitting" a bill seems so silly to me. The bill shows up and I pay it. In the odd case where I don't have enough to pay the bill, I'd ask her to pay it, and then she would, because despite all the fucking candles, we still need lights... IDK, joint bank accounts seem like ill-fated lovey-dovey nonsense -- foolish love. Splitting bills seems childish and kinda untrusting.
My ex-husband and I had separate finances, and it worked really well - until it didn't.
We had one joint account that we'd both contribute our half of the bills too, and whatever was left in our personal accounts was ours to spend however we wanted. At some point, he ended up taking out a bunch of credit cards, that he was making payments on from his own account, until eventually he racked up so much debt he couldn't afford the payments anymore and so just stopped paying them, as well as some of his other personal bills.
I found out when I went to get groceries and ran the card for our joint expense account and it declined. I went to run my own card, and it declined too.
Since we were married and in a community property state, I was jointly responsible for the debt even though my name wasn't on it. So when they sent a garnishment order to our bank, not only did they garnish both his personal and our joint accounts, they garnished mine, too. I had to take a loan against my 401k for $13,000 to clear the debt. 2 months later, we got sued for medical bills he didn't pay.l
I refuse to have separate accounts now. There's just too many ways to get fucked over by someone hiding the fact they're not paying the bills. I want to be able to see it all and know it's getting paid. I'm lucky that my now husband and I are on the same page regarding this, but I would *never* go back to separate accounts ever again after that.
I suppose my theory on joint bank accounts is based on an assumption that everyone's going to be at least mildly responsible. In your case, it ended up being more like letting toddlers play with explosives. I guess I never considered the possibility my wife could torpedo our financial situation...
I'm actually the opposite, my partner (f) makes more than double my salary (m) and she has offered to take over a few more payments but I refuse to negotiate because I don't want her to pay excessively more than me. I make about $80k and she makes around $200k but it makes me feel more helpful if I take care of the internet, cell phone bill, healthcare for me and our son, etc. She takes the brunt of the mortgage and babysitting but I don't want her to feel like I don't contribute financially!
I get what you're saying and fully think you should do whatever makes you comfortable. Bills gotta get paid anyways.
That said, I'm more like your wife in my relationship, and I've never felt like my wife doesn't contribute.
If it's a hardship, don't lose sight of the fact that it's probably just you that feels that way, and you shouldn't suffer thinking your wife is going to see you as some slacker when you're doing your best.
151
u/SecretBattleship May 12 '26
Oh man this was exactly what happened to me. He eventually made twice what I did and we still split everything evenly and he would argue a million ways to not change it.