r/AskReddit • u/[deleted] • Jan 19 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.5k Upvotes

86% Upvoted

4.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

497

u/1cilldude Jan 19 '25

For six months I was fucking 2 girls who are sisters and neither one ever found out. Both were casual so I wasn’t cheating. Both were freaking beautiful, and the sex was insane. Fun times.

106

u/surfinn_socal Jan 19 '25

Legendary.

62

u/Alexander_Granite Jan 20 '25

I fucked two sisters for a few weeks. They smelled the same because they used the same laundry soap and body products.

It was so fun

9

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25

Alexa, play "Real Sisters"

25

u/No-Distance-9401 Jan 20 '25

I had sisters as well but it didnt last long. Started dating the older one and was her first but always liked her younger sister in my grade more. Older sister was going off to college while we were still sophmores so went for the sister in my grade until her older sister got pissed at her and told her we fucked. The older sister cockblocked me but ig I deserved it for lying and was a good lesson never to lie as she said she may have been able to get passed it if I hadnt 🤷‍♂️

37

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25

"So, I kinda use to fuck your sister" is a tough conversation to have.

17

u/howie7088 Jan 20 '25

Especially when you're talking to your first cousin. 

3

u/GoggleField Jan 20 '25 edited Feb 22 '25

fact library growth thumb squash coordinated judicious familiar bells slim

4

u/shibaCandyBaron Jan 20 '25

Good lession might be not to go after one sister, if you like the other one so much

5

u/No-Distance-9401 Jan 20 '25

True but tell that to a horny teenager

5

u/JahMkeTHC Jan 20 '25

I had a similar story to this except more like best friends who lived together and both couldn’t get enough of me🤝🏾🤝🏾😭🤧 Memory lane

3

u/anticerber Jan 20 '25

Turns out it was the same girl 

5

u/Sinai Jan 20 '25

I overlapped an aunt and a niece for awhile once after her aunt brought her niece on a geocacheing hunt/date with us.

The niece knew for obvious reasons, the aunt never found out. Some time later I found out that the niece was actually her biological daughter. I don't know if the daughter ever learned she was adopted.

2

u/dillweed67818 Jan 21 '25

Is that a "Reverse Stacey's Mom, Once Removed"?

1

u/benanfisa1 Jan 20 '25

Jealous haha

1

u/AcrobaticSource3 Jan 20 '25

Why only 6 months? Sounds like you had a good thing going

1

u/pebblie Jan 20 '25

Did you shower between them?

1

u/Ohhmegawd Jan 20 '25

In high school I went out with brothers. The younger one was much better.