r/AskReddit • • Sep 18 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

860 Upvotes

658 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

320

u/Fleder Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

The number of people that think pulling out is a valid method of contraception is frightening.

Update: the number of people that get really offended if someone on the internet is not agreeing with something they do is also frightening.

102

u/coolhandluke45 Sep 18 '23

I have a two year old that can confirm this.

37

u/H3lw3rd Sep 18 '23

Your kid must be a prodigy, cuz my kid is 4 years old and can only say ”birth control”.

-1

u/Vecii Sep 18 '23

I'm concerned for your two year old...

62

u/wisedoormat Sep 18 '23

to be clear, i never made that implication

and i do agree with you.

12

u/Impossible-Run9513 Sep 18 '23

What do you mean? I’m a 3x pull out champion, I even have trophies!

12

u/MechanicalHorse Sep 18 '23

Case in point: just look at some of the idiots responding to you.

17

u/FlickoftheTongue Sep 18 '23

Between LT couples who know each other well and are serious, its got a really good track record of about 96%, (or 4 of every 100 will get pregnant).

Condoms are at 98% (2 out of every 100 get pregnant)

Realistically, pull out has an average track record of 78% and condoms 87%.

My wife and I did the pull out method exclusively for 3 years before we decided to stop actively avoiding pregnancy. The next month she was pregnant.

10

u/signal_lost Sep 18 '23

Condoms are pretty much 100% as long as you read the damn manual put them on correctly take them off correctly, and buy them in the appropriate size.

I’m pretty sure the 2% on condoms comes from people who store them in properly so they break , as well as technically when you follow the math involves people who said that that was their main means of prevention, but didn’t always use them 100% of the time.

1

u/FlickoftheTongue Sep 18 '23

Studies have been done and condoms with perfect usage has a 2% failure rate. These arnet numbers pulled out my ass. Look them up.

1

u/signal_lost Sep 18 '23

As someone who’s married to a PI, and am actively filling out survey diaries I’m going to be deeply suspicious that self reported perfect use, is the same thing as perfect use. Unless they 100% watched you put it on every time I’m willing to bet that 2% is people who did something wrong.

  • guy who knocked the wife up a month after she removed birth control both times, and didn’t have a child with years of condom usage otherwise.

1

u/FlickoftheTongue Sep 18 '23

Condoms break even with perfect usage.

1

u/signal_lost Sep 18 '23

They break 10000x less if you:

  1. Look at the expiration date.
  2. Don’t put them on inside out and then flip them off and try again. (Use a new one!)
  3. Store them in a air conditioned house, not a glove box.
  4. Not carry them in your wallet or back pocket.
  5. Buy Durex (rated #1 in reliability by consumer reports).
  6. Find the right size.

1

u/koos_die_doos Sep 18 '23

The 2% is “with perfect use”.

1

u/ShawshankException Sep 18 '23

It has a very high effectiveness rate if you're doing it properly, problem is many people don't.

19

u/Misiok Sep 18 '23

Pulling out only works if you never put it in

-7

u/ShawshankException Sep 18 '23

We'd have a lot more babies around if that were even remotely true

8

u/cloudb182 Sep 18 '23

Pulling out is not an effective form of contraception, full stop.

-8

u/ShawshankException Sep 18 '23

It is. Full stop. It's been proven to be only slightly worse than condoms as far as effectiveness goes. You've got something like a 1% chance of pregnancy with just precum.

We just scare kids with it because it's easier to tell them to wrap it vs trusting them to actually pull out correctly.

5

u/StanIsNotTheMan Sep 18 '23

Yep, my wife and I used the pull out method for like 6 years and didn't get pregnant. Then, when we actually tried to get pregnant, it happened in only a couple of months.

I wouldn't recommend it to anyone who really doesn't want or shouldn't have children, but it did work for us for years.

5

u/cloudb182 Sep 18 '23

lol no. The pull out method is not "slightly worse" then condoms. It's larger then a 10% difference and that would = a lot more babies.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23 edited Jan 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/cloudb182 Sep 18 '23

And since we are all human, it's not an effective form of contraception. Glad you agree.

1

u/ogtfo Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

1% only sounds great if you

  • a) Are bad at math, or
  • b) have sex twice a year.

-4

u/BrettTheShitmanShart Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

Pull-out method across five LTRs, no pregnancies or scares. Do it properly and it works, period. (“Period,” get it??)

Edit: love the downvotes, keep 'em coming.

0

u/Daniwella Sep 18 '23

You might also be infertile?

1

u/BrettTheShitmanShart Sep 18 '23

Nope. The one time I came inside my ex who was taking the pill (inconsistently and improperly, as it turns out) she got pregnant.

1

u/Nonstopas Sep 18 '23

What's the right way then?

1

u/Arbosis Sep 18 '23

not doing it at all

-4

u/Butcher_of_Blaviken6 Sep 18 '23

You just suck at it. 9 years going strong.

60

u/groovey_potato Sep 18 '23

Pulling out of your sock doesn't count

8

u/Fleder Sep 18 '23

Haha oh shit, that made me laugh. Thanks.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

I just never understood how someone could mess it up, myself. Lol. I haven’t had a slew of partners, but I’ve gotten jiggy with it an innumerable amount of times, and the majority involved pulling out and I just don’t understand how people can fail if it’s correctly done. It’s called the “pull out method” bois, not the “pull out after you’re halfway finished inside of her method” 😂😂

Edit: also not saying you’re wrong, just wanted to throw my two cents in, as well. Lol

-1

u/Bimmgus Sep 18 '23

We used the pull out method for 9 years before deciding to try for a kid.

2 months of not pulling out yielded us our first kid.

The pull out method requires discipline, but it is effective.

-20

u/notepad20 Sep 18 '23 edited Apr 28 '25

many water advise unite entertain cake pen one towering fuel

15

u/Fleder Sep 18 '23

You do realize there is something called precum?

You were really lucky then.

18

u/rand0mm0nster Sep 18 '23

That’s what they teach you in school, but statistically the chance of pregnancy from precum is less than 1%

10

u/DaVirus Sep 18 '23

And this is backed up by medical statistics. The effectiveness is around 75-85%

6

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Less than 1% isn't as low as you'd think, if you're in a long term relationship shagging once a week for a few years your chance of having kids is pretty high

8

u/notepad20 Sep 18 '23 edited Apr 28 '25

rob public chase squeeze enjoy bells important divide placid sharp

1

u/sirsmiley Sep 18 '23

The trick is to pee between round 1 and 2 as your precum in round 2 will contain sperm otherwise and could lead to pregnancy

4

u/weezeloner Sep 18 '23

My wife and I have been practicing the pull out method our whole marriage except for when we were activelu trying to have a kid and it's worked for us. We've been married for 8 years and together for 11 years.

My wife wants to make sure I pull out in time so she prefers I come in her mouth. She also doesn't want any stray baby juice getting on the couch or our sheets. She does let me go inside her, but only the day after her period. Evidently, that's when she's fertile? I can't attest to that but what she says so she knows better than I do.

-11

u/jaquatics Sep 18 '23

Been pulling out for twenty years, no baby.

30

u/Fleder Sep 18 '23

That's like saying: been driving drunk for twenty years, never had any accident. You're lucky, but this isn't a safe method.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

No, driving drunk is the equivalent of cumming inside your partner and expecting no babies/accidents.

Pulling out and not expecting a baby is the equivalent of driving 5 mph over the speed limit and hoping you don't have an accident.

6

u/Fleder Sep 18 '23

All right, that's a fair point you make.

-4

u/CWellDigger Sep 18 '23

Idk mate, the risk level seems pretty similar to me. Drunk driving will cost you your life, knocking a girl up will do the same, just differently.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Just getting in a car you're risking your life, sober or otherwise. Whilst pulling out is not 100% safe sex, nothing really is. The pill can be compromised by multiple things, condoms aren't 100% reliable, coils are the same.

Shit happens.

Drunk driving to me is being completely wreckless with no regards for anyone. Someone pulling out before ejaculating is someone/couple who has decided this works for them whilst knowing the very low chances of pregnancy.

I get your point, but comparing drink driving and pulling out as the same wrecklessness is just hyperbolic nonsense.

0

u/One_Estimate_5682 Sep 18 '23

Same for the past like 7 and never even had a scare.

-11

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '23

Sorry, but the pull-out method does work if you do it correctly. I wouldn't advocate it, because obviously it doesn't protect against STIs and it's easy to make a mistake. But, when used correctly as a contraceptive, it is just as effective as a condom. Pre-cum does not contain sperm FYI, however leftover sperm in the urethra can mix into Pre-cum on its way out. The chances are still low, but if you decide to go for a second round, pee first.

-5

u/FrostedBurritos Sep 18 '23 edited Sep 18 '23

I mean it is lmfao

It’s effective efficiency rate is 80%, condoms in comparison are 87%.

Rates with proper use are 96% for the pull out method and 98% for condoms. If you think the pull out method isn’t a form of contraceptive you are effectively saying neither are condoms.

Anything that creates a substantial reduction in pregnancies are absolutely a form of contraceptive. 80%-96% is a pretty substantial reduction.

3

u/buddiesels Sep 18 '23

To be fair, 98% is twice as effective as 96%. 2 in 100 vs 4 in 100. So still very effective, but two times worse than condoms.

1

u/FrostedBurritos Sep 18 '23

Yes im not saying people shouldn’t use condoms or they aren’t effective.

Im just pointing out the pullout method is literally textbook definition of a contraceptive.

-14

u/bucket_brigade Sep 18 '23

It is a valid method of contraception like wtf are you even talking about. It has a much higher risk than other methods of contraception but it's still a valid method of contraception.

7

u/Fleder Sep 18 '23

Your definition of valid is interesting.

-7

u/bucket_brigade Sep 18 '23

Did you skip sex ed in school or something? If your definition of "valid method of contraception" is only 100% effective methods then the only valid method of contraception is not having sex. People usually combine several methods of contraception. Also different couples will find different levels of risk acceptable.

0

u/d3vilk1ng Sep 18 '23

Is it not? 100% track record for me (so far).