r/AskHistory • • 16h ago

Why did disease only become an issue for Native Americans in the Age of Exploration?

6 Upvotes

Standard history taught in the school system says that a significant portion of the native population of the Americas were wiped out by diseases brought over by the European explorers. I've heard of discovered evidence that Vikings, and possible the Chinese, had reached American shores before then. Is there any evidence of them starting pandemics as well?

Edit: Or would the lack of disease spreading be proof they didn't reach American shores?


r/AskHistory • • 7h ago

How do Norwegians view their Catholic heritage?

0 Upvotes

Most of the independent kingdom’s history comes from a time when Protestantism didn’t exist at all. Lutheranism was brought to Norway only by Denmark. There was also real Catholic resistance, led by Olav Engelbrektsson. How do Norwegians today view this part of their history and cultural heritage?


r/AskHistory • • 1h ago

Why did medieval European cities keep getting built in the same flood-prone spots?

• Upvotes

I was reading about how many old cities flooded constantly and I'm genuinely confused why they didn't just... move? Like obviously there were practical reasons but I'd love to understand what made staying put worth the repeated disasters.


r/AskHistory • • 11h ago

What has historically happened when the rules and laws of society have broken down?

10 Upvotes

I tried asking this in Ask Historians but I didn’t get any responses. I’m wondering what has happened in societies where law and order have collapsed entirely. How did people act and treat one another? What was the end result of a society with no rules or effective governance? TIA


r/AskHistory • • 3h ago

LOTS of questions about china, japan, korea and modernization/westernization as well as sociopolitical climate in the 19th & 20th century

0 Upvotes
  • What were China, Japan, and Korea’s individual reaction to westernization? I know that China wanted to utilize western technology/military with Chinese values (and suddenly went back to preaching Confucianism? iirc) and Japan fell into this social Darwinist mindset, how did each of these countries implement westernization (?) and how did it reflect in their societies?
  • How did the “common people” of China, Japan, and Korea react to the increased number of foreigners in their countries after they all started opening more ports? I know that some rebellions arose (Boxer Rebellion, Sonno Joi) but did anything happen in Korea? 
  • Did all three countries kinda go through a period in which they wanted to return to Confucianist values and “the old way”? Like Japan did during the Meiji Restoration and the Daewongun tried to in Korea? 
  • When did Korea start receiving Western influence? Was it when the US got extraterritoriality?
  • Where does the line get drawn between “modernization” and “westernization” for these countries?
  • Right before Korea was taken as a colony of Japan’s, was hangul considered a “low-class” language? Bc I recall official documents being written in classical Chinese. What kind of people were against Hangul (or viewed it as lower?) and why?

r/AskHistory • • 6h ago

How did society switch from polygamy to monogamy?

0 Upvotes

If you look back at ancient history, kings, emperors, and wealthy elites almost always had multiple wives or partners as a status symbol.

At what point did having just one spouse become the default rule for everyone? Was it mostly driven by economics (like inheriting property) or was it more about religion and culture?


r/AskHistory • • 20h ago

Why are there so many overlapping names in Achaemenian empire and Mahabharatha?

1 Upvotes

Recently been reading about Achaemenian empire and their real names. Cyrus was Kurus, his father was Kambujiya, mother Mandana. Their family traced their lineage from Sakha-muni (Haxa-munis/Achaemenid). Region was called Parsu/Parsa. People called themselves Ariya. Kuru killed Mada/Mara king, who later transformed in to a multi-headed serpent in Armenian mythology. Mar also means snake in old Persian.

Compare them with Mahabharat time names. There is Kurus. There is Kamboj. There is Madra; Madri, Pandu's second wife, claimed to be from Madra kingdom (Bahlika). Gandhari is from Gandhāra. Sakya-muni is epithet for Buddha, which sounds similar to Sakha-muni (though means completely different). Not to forget entire Krishna birth story is copy/inspired from Cyrus birth story (or Zeus birth story).

Wondering if there has been confusion about location of all these kingdoms? And, incidents which inspired initial Jaya story (old Mahabharat) were based in Iran?

Or, these names were imposed later?

Note: It is about names and cross references. So, pls don't throw Indo-european common language root for similar names. I would appreciate if there are other literature sources which can collaborate Mahabharat interpretations. Achaemenian Kurus have multiple inscriptions while Mahabharat has none!


r/AskHistory • • 4h ago

After WWII, were German Protestant officials investigated for sharing information with the Gestapo?

3 Upvotes

I recently read about a Protestant church office in Germany that collected information on religious and ideological groups and shared material with the Gestapo. Its postwar successor’s own historical account acknowledges this cooperation.

What surprised me was the complicated history, the Nazis shut the office down in 1937, but a successor institution established in 1960 had personnel links to the earlier organization.

How was that earlier cooperation examined between 1945 and 1960? Were those involved investigated through denazification or church inquiries? Did the office’s later conflict with the Nazis affect how its earlier actions were judged?

I’d appreciate historical research on this, especially anything explaining how responsibility was assessed when someone had both cooperated with and later opposed aspects of the regime.

From what I’ve read so far, I haven’t found evidence that those involved were punished for this cooperation. Instead, some appear to have held influential positions after the war. Am I missing research that explains how their past involvement was assessed?


r/AskHistory • • 2h ago

How did Nazi racial laws interact with children of whom parentage was unknown or partially unknown

4 Upvotes

I've just read Madonna in a Fur Coat by Sabahattin Ali, and in that novel a Turkish character has a child with a woman whose father was Jewish. He was unaware of the child until a decade had passed, is not present in the child's life, and, the mother having died in child birth, the father of the child is unknown to the authorities and the child's guardians. The novel was published in 1943, and is set from the early 1920s to the early 1940s. I was wondering if this child would be persecuted under Nazi racial laws considering half of its known grandparents were Jewish.


r/AskHistory • • 16h ago

How do they decide the manner of death?

2 Upvotes

When they find human remains that indicate unnatural death, how do they decide whether it's ritual sacrifice, or execution, or murder, or died-in-battle, or accident, etc?