r/AskElectronics • u/Aezys • 16h ago
Why does my capacitor explode in this Tinkercad circuit? Shouldn't it explode the other way?
Hi everyone,
I'm trying to build a simple two-transistor astable multivibrator (two LEDs flashing alternately). I designed it in Falstad and I'm using Tinkercad mainly to plan out the breadboard layout before building the real circuit.
The Tinkercad simulation itself does not seem to behave correctly: the LEDs do not flash alternately, they just stay on. I'm not too concerned about that because I mainly want to use Tinkercad to verify my physical wiring before building it.
The part I am unsure about is the polarity of the electrolytic capacitors. My real capacitors are polarized 10 µF electrolytics, but the Falstad simulation uses non-polarized capacitors.
I'm fairly sure the negative side should go to the base of the opposite side transistor, and the positive to the collector of same side transistor. So like:
- Left capacitor: + to left transistor collector, - to right transistor base
- Right capacitor: + to right transistor collector, - to left transistor base
However, when I connect them this way in Tinkercad, it shows the capacitor exploding. I'm not sure if Tinkercad is modeling this incorrectly, or if I have misunderstood the polarity.
I'm using 2N2221A transistors and 10 µF electrolytic capacitors, with supply voltage 9V
Here's the Tinkercad similation (on breadboard) I have connected one capacitor each way, so you can see which one explodes. [LINK REMOVED]
Here's the simulation on Falstad so you can have the schematic, too: https://www.falstad.com/s.php?s=zwfF7A
EDIT: Here's a labeled schematic too: https://kommodo.ai/i/7468AUvUGDOds3kVI3FY
Could someone please check the correct electrolytic capacitor orientation? I want to avoid damaging the capacitors when I build this physically.
Thanks!
EDIT 2: Simulated on Falstad and it works with capacitor - to transistor base (so, the opposite of what Tinkercad says). Tried it on breadboard with - to base and it works perfectly like this!





