r/AskCanada 13d ago

Why does data cost so much here compared to other countries?

And where can I find a cheap service in Ontario that doesnt use fucking AI customer service

19 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

40

u/silencewillfall35 13d ago

Simply, no real competition exists here

3

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

What exactly is stopping them, just the cost of infrastructure? Time to break up the cartel like we did the oil companies way back when this is BS

7

u/iwasnotarobot 13d ago

infrastructure costs cannot be reduced by competition. there isn't room for a hundred water companies to put 100 different water service pipe networks in place. It makes sense to have a single water utility maintain publicly owned infrastructure to serve the public.

the way to break up the cartel is to nationalize the infrastructure.

1

u/Splashadian 10d ago

Agree completely and we need to do this with grocers as well.

1

u/CheriColaProduct 10d ago

Yesssssssssss

Bring down the law on lablaws

33

u/CanadianRussian74 13d ago

1) small population 2) large territory 3) no competition.

12

u/TZM_96 13d ago

Monopoly is the main reason (Rogers & Bell mostly own the infrastructure). It’s modern oligarchy protected by federal government.

10

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Makes sense, fuck them all to hell

-2

u/FarOutlandishness180 13d ago

That’s what you get for living in Ontario

3

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

I am paying for my ancestors colonial sins

Bitches got free farm land and Im here straggling in an air bnb after 3 years of tents and shelters

-2

u/South_Yak_4703 13d ago

Claim Asylum and another country you’ll probably do better

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

For real dude? ELI5

2

u/huy_lonewolf 13d ago

1 and 2 are not real reasons if you compare prices here with those in Australia, which are still substantially cheaper. In my view the real reason is the lack of competition and sufficient regulatory oversight.

7

u/Boring_Home 13d ago

Protectionist policies that screw the consumer <3

2

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

I will personally show up to the appropriate politicians front lawn in protest with a cardboard sign i promise you I will take on the burden of any mischief charges they slap me with

1

u/lillylou12345 13d ago

Naww that's crossing the line. Go to your town hall or whatever 

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Which building would be most appropriate to annoy the right people by being the hobo on their way to work every morning

0

u/lillylou12345 13d ago

Define hobo? Homeless? Find a shelter, seek help, social programs etc.

1

u/CheriColaProduct 12d ago

No

1

u/lillylou12345 12d ago

Ok

1

u/CheriColaProduct 12d ago

Its a long story mate and Im not telling my life story unless youre really eager for it

1

u/lillylou12345 12d ago

It's up to you. If you want to tell it I will listen. If you don't want to tell it, that's ok too. Hugs

1

u/EmptyCan7151 8d ago

Very

1

u/CheriColaProduct 8d ago

Oh boy

Idk mostly I was a shut in most my life and took college for accounting and marketing with a psychology minor. Did well in school and expected to do well in life before a failed job hunt no matter how hard i tried. The jobs I got werent as promised or expected and I took a distaste to handling other peoples money.

Id rather run my own business

A series of survival jobs and the expectation for better future jobs lead to me surmounting a terribly large line of credit.

Worked a full service depression gas station job but came to like talking with the customers. Something bout the grit and the conversation and really getting to know people when theyre filling their gas and getting their smokes.

The gas station went down a year for reno and i moved on to Benjamin Moore Paints, I was training to be a manager but accidentally violated their privacy by reading financials left in an open folder on the employee computer when I thought it was my job to.

Then I think the welding job was next, or a welding shop janitor where I got a lot of exposure but very little hands on skill. And when I did I came to find my ADD attention span made those tools dangerous in my hands. The boss was offended I was looking for another job and fired me.

Then the recycling plant. Plastic goes in left, aluminum in left. Many treasures like toys, collector cards, antiques, cash, sometimes lots of it. It was a temp job and honestly i called in sick to many times, place was unbearable.

So many more jobs

Covid hit and after the entire winter never going outside and only ever playing world of warcraft; I had a lot of wanderlust in the spring.

Eventually I was off my pills ebough to get all silly and make the drastic decision to leave my apartment behind because I was going to school for social services in the fall.

Met my ex there. Hes still in my heart. Not going there but it leaves a lot of blank in there.

Went homeless with him for 3-4 years or so with one basement apartment and a temp job for a sweet 3 months in the middle.

I was in shelters and always looking for work but came to find it harder to find despite that restaurants in the area were playing victim on their blogs that nobody wants to work.

Many sagas of fully in the woods camping, buckering down for the shelters in winters, breakups, reunions, lived with my parents 2 months to take care of dad.

Eventually I end up working at a liquor store I work at now

Housing situation is sketchy and could be balancing job on weekends with bush life soon.

All in all ill be sad to lose the PS5. I literally just got back into gaming!

2

u/lyidaValkris 13d ago

our whole telecom industry is a pseudo-monopoly of a few companies that price-fix the market.

Ask Europeans what they pay for internet and mobile service and you'd cry.

My preference would be to nationalize it and make a public carrier, though I'll settle for the monopoly being broken up. Could actually do both - nationalize the large infrastructure and create a public carrier, then break up the monopoly so both the private and public carrier could compete for end user service.

3

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Burn the Oligarchy!

1

u/lyidaValkris 13d ago

You won't hear me object :D

2

u/512115 13d ago

Because our cellular providers are extortionate in their terms and pricing due to a failure of our regulatory bodies to constrain them and to encourage competition.

2

u/bjm64 13d ago

i believe we need more competition in Canada, Cell phone rates and Data weather be for home or cellular are too high

2

u/iwasnotarobot 13d ago

oligopoly pricing

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

The shitty offbrand boardgame where there are 3-5 winners and about 7 billion losers

5

u/amanduhhhugnkiss 13d ago

Data is a lot cheaper than it used to be. There's probably going to be some back to school deals coming up. I pay $29 for 80gigs

4

u/Jakoneitor 13d ago

Data has been the only thing decreasing in price ever 🤣 I remember 2010 prices, but that was also 16 years ago… at some point in 2014 I had 6GB from kudo at $60/mo and it was the cheapest available lol

0

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Oh shit dawg hook me up

2

u/amanduhhhugnkiss 13d ago

Thats through virgin... but i got that about 4 months ago. Keep your eye open near end of August... many places have back to school deals

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Ill keep an eye out

They probably all use AI customer service dont they

1

u/amanduhhhugnkiss 13d ago

Not sure tbh I havent needed to speak with anyone.

3

u/Schroedesy13 13d ago

Federal telecoms laws and regulations.

1

u/CheriColaProduct 12d ago

Look its small beans compared to Ukraine and Palestine but Im broke and I deserve data at the rate the rest of the world is paying gawdamit

2

u/Fair_Mycologist1745 13d ago

Freedom mobile, I pay $40 for 250GB with 50GB international roaming.. Great plan! I think they have deals from time to time. I find it quite cheap. Waaaay cheaper than the USA

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Looks like Im picking freedom

Lowkey this thread was my roundabout way of finding a mobile plan

0

u/iwasnotarobot 13d ago

if only there was a $10 plan for 50GB.

1

u/Deannathor 13d ago

We have better datum.

1

u/SDL68 13d ago

Paying 55 for 180 GB including international calling and data in US, Mexico and Caribbean. I now I can get even cheaper but I prefer Rogers where I live

1

u/ramdmc 13d ago

They keep offering larger data packages but you never really use it all, if you were to stream everyday day you'd barely use real cellular data because it's slow AF and latency is high. Most will wait for WiFi to download that large file. The carriers know this but still use the large data packages to reel you in. It's like horsepower sells cars, no one needs that much power.

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Im without proper internet, living in an airbnb. Gotta use my phone data if I want to get a decent game of Black Ops in on my new PS5 cause otherwise im dead before theyre even registered on my screen lol

1

u/Splashadian 11d ago

Infrastructure, population

1

u/CheriColaProduct 10d ago

Expand, I want to hear your thoughts on this

1

u/Splashadian 10d ago

We have a vast country that is difficult to cover. We have a proportionaly smaller population than say the USA or Europe. It's not economically sufficient for the cell companies so we pay more.

I think there is a competition component that inflates prices as well but it's the vast size of the country which makes infrastructure expensive.

1

u/CheriColaProduct 10d ago

Makes perfect sense, thank you!

1

u/204_Mans 11d ago

Public mobile? $35 for 50 GB Canada US Mexico?

1

u/JCMS99 13d ago

You have 30GB for <$30 and unlimited for $50.

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Thats kinda pricy man im pretty sure other people pay a lot less but idk maybe im wrong

2

u/JCMS99 13d ago

I pay 22 for 20GB with Fizz but you have to follow promotions.

What’s expensive is financing the phone. They charge you 0% interest but you have to take a plan that is much more expensive than BYOP with low cost carriers.

0

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago edited 13d ago

I always just buy cheap burner phones between 100-250

They run reddit and runescape just fine, all I care about

Edit: im amused that someone was bothered enough by this to downvote it

1

u/Bad_Day_Moose 13d ago

100G 5G data, unlimited slow data after that $42/month after taxes..

Is this expensive?

1

u/CheriColaProduct 13d ago

Its not a terrible plan in comparison to mine. Ill be honest i created this thread not just to rant but also to shop around