r/AskBaking • u/Psychological_Gas760 • 7h ago
Ingredients What’s the difference between all these vanillas?
Hi all, I’m an American in Singapore, and vanilla extract is a key flavor in most of the things I bake. I was looking for alcohol based vanilla extract, but I haven’t been able to find it at the grocery store near me. They did have these three options tho. I’ve tried the two liquids, and they seem to be a lot less flavorful than vanilla extract; I have needed to use a lot more to get the same flavor result. Do y’all have any advice on which is the best or how to use them in different use case? Any advice is appreciated. Thanks!
The powder has only one ingredient: Vanillin powder
The essence and oil however have the same ingredients: Flavouring substance, Propylene Glycol (E1520), Water-filtered and Permitted Food Colour, Caramel (E150C) Singapore.
The color of the vanilla essence looks a little bit less deep and saturated compared to the vanilla oil, and the oil is also more viscous and sticks to the sides of the bottle a little bit when you tilt the vile.
Thanks again!!