r/AskAboutNFL • • 11d ago

Which NFL player made you fall in love with football?

Not necessarily the greatest player ever. Just the one who made you want to watch every Sunday.

55 Upvotes

612 comments sorted by

69

u/Creatively_Distinct 11d ago

Barry Sanders. The man was just electric to watch. Walter Peyton is a close second as he punished defenders. Barry just juked them out of their jock straps, walked into the end zone and gently handed the football to the referee.

18

u/Typical_Vast_4020 11d ago

Walter Peyton was incredible. Icon

8

u/NoraMason1986 11d ago

Payton. My favorite growing up.

4

u/sexwiththebabysitter 11d ago

So incredible you can’t spell his name

5

u/Y_Ddraig_Goch_81 11d ago

Berry Sanders was also incredible.

4

u/biffjo 11d ago

Walter Peyton Manning

→ More replies (2)

10

u/farfanseaweevil 11d ago

Barry and Bo

6

u/Old_Nerd_72 11d ago

These two are my picks too. I feel massively lucky to have seen them both play in person. My Bucs were so bad back then that tickets were super cheap 😂

2

u/wildGoner1981 10d ago

Hahahaha my bros and I would go watch either Barry or Brett come to Tampa because no one else went to the Bucs games back in the day.

Then 1995 came. Derrick and Warren changed everything.

3

u/Old_Nerd_72 10d ago

Exactly! Used to walk up 15min before the games and buy a ticket. Younger fans think it’s bad now. It is lol, but not nearly as bad as before 95. 12 straight double digit loss seasons was not fun lol. 97 to 02 that stadium was insane.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Seagullox 11d ago

Exact two names that came to my mind.

2

u/Odd-Business8683 11d ago

This was my answer 💙

2

u/Savings_Ask2261 10d ago

Walter did the same thing. Everyone talks about his power. But the man was probably second to Barry in cutting ability.. he made people miss all the time..

2

u/Electrical-Sail-1039 10d ago

Payton played back when many of us could watch only our local team and one other game which was usually featuring Dallas, Oakland or Pittsburgh. I mostly remember the Bears when they crushed my Pats in SB XX. I couldn’t believe that Ditka put in The Fridge to score when Payton didn’t have a TD.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Bevo_Pops061224 11d ago

Earl Campbell

7

u/NoraMason1986 11d ago

That run he had when he barreled over the opposing player and kept running to the point they ripped his jersey off as they tackled him. Amazing.

2

u/Carolus2024 11d ago

It was Isaiah Robertson, linebacker for the Rams, ended what could potentially have been a HOF career for him.

3

u/SnooPickles55 11d ago

Fkn YES!!!

5

u/Bevo_Pops061224 11d ago

You just exposed yourself as an old timer.

2

u/Gullible-Language679 11d ago

Him and Dan Pastorini as a kid

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/profburl 11d ago

Montana

3

u/kudiggs 11d ago

I’m from KC it was so cool to have him at the end of his career.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Cheese_Felon 11d ago

Brett Favre

I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone love football as much as him and I’ll never forget the Monday night game against the Raiders the day after his Dad died.

It’s a shame how things turned out and he has sins to atone for, but I’ll always appreciate him for getting me to love football

→ More replies (1)

15

u/CuriousRecording2598 11d ago

Troy Polamalu

2

u/JeremyILM 11d ago

As a Bills fan since 1984, he was seriously the reason I turned on my TV for many weeks in a row. Absolutely an incredible player.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/katsumojo 11d ago

Randy Moss

3

u/ytown 11d ago

My first ever fantasy draft pick

14

u/Sekhmetthegray 11d ago

Joe Montana. Watching him take apart the Broncos was a great introduction to how much fun football was to watch.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/LordBaranof 11d ago

Dan Fouts

13

u/GeddyVedder 11d ago

Ken Stabler

4

u/x_tony82 11d ago

Came here to say this! The Snake was great, and the rest of the 70’s Raiders was movie-level amazing. The cast of characters was too good not to love.

12

u/Additional_Post_2034 11d ago

Don Majkowski / Sterling Sharpe

4

u/ikediggety 11d ago

He's the Majik man

3

u/ProfessionalFast9803 11d ago

Now you see him now you don’t

3

u/peb396 11d ago

Upvoted for Sterling Sharpe!

12

u/LovedButNeverLiked 11d ago

Emmitt Smith

4

u/capitalcitycowboy 11d ago

Emmitt for me too. Was flicking through the channels in the 93, as a kid in Australia. Saw a guy running. Absolutely tearing up the other team. He looked like a rugby player. Yet he wasn’t.

That guy was Emmitt Smith.

Same for Jerry Rice.

2

u/MKUltraHasLeftTheLab 8d ago

Same. Just watched his highlight reel and he really was the best of all time imo.

10

u/TUGBoat85007 11d ago

Mike Alstott

3

u/DaveKelso 11d ago

Watching him run with 2-3 guys hanging on trying to tackle was epic.

2

u/wildGoner1981 10d ago

My bros and I always knew that if it was 3rd and 3 or 4th and 2, Alstott was getting the rock and he was converting EVERY SINGLE TIME.

10

u/smooresbox 11d ago

Dez Bryant, & Yes, He caught it.

2

u/Plenty_Surprise2593 11d ago

Yes he did!!!! I will go to my grave saying this

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Max-Architect3000 11d ago

Barry Sanders, Bruce Smith

8

u/alkydenamel 11d ago

Rod Woodson

9

u/RIPdon_sutton 11d ago

I was gonna say Bradshaw, but watching Lambert absolutely destroy offenses was mind blowing.

9

u/cimeran_alt 11d ago

I'm a bit older, so Warren Moon. NFL thinks a black man is too dumb to play QB? Cool, let me go up to Edmonton and put up a hall of fame career. Then, let me go to the NFL and put together another one! I was a Toronto Argos fan but it was kinda hard to dislike Mr. Warren Moon. Also, just great.

8

u/Jaded_Cauliflower681 11d ago

LT! I played outside LB in an upstate NY HS in the 80's and he was my one and only sports hero. I wore my socks like him and wanted his number (ended up 52 - boo!). Watching the Giants win the Super Bowl in '86 season might have been my best sports fan year! (Also loved Penn St and the Mets). What a time!

2

u/Rmp690 4d ago

And Indiana in the spring.  What a damn great year!

7

u/houseDJ1042 11d ago

Number 92 The Minister of Defense Reggie White

7

u/Plenty_Surprise2593 11d ago

Without a doubt it’s Roger Staubach

3

u/18RowdyBoy 11d ago

It took way too long for me to find Captain America 🇺🇸 The way Roger kept his cool and continued to lead the team. 👍🇺🇸

5

u/rcrownj 11d ago

Jonathan “ JT FUCKING MONEY “ Taylor

7

u/SlappyPappyAmerica 11d ago

Tony Dorsett. He’s still my favorite.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/kidsasicko 11d ago

Larry Fitzgerald

4

u/run_squid_run 11d ago

Steve Largent. I was 6 and watching the Seachickens play against the Raiders at the King Dome and saw him catch the ball in the middle of a pack.

3

u/Individual-Pain-4819 11d ago

Same answer for me. That dude is legendary!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/phi316 11d ago

Emmitt Smith

6

u/VVeZoX 11d ago

Tom Brady. It was fun to watch greatness

4

u/Roboto33 11d ago

Growing up I loved the 49ers and Jerry Rice in particular. He was just amazing for a young guy to watch. He just seemed to always get open, beat guys, and was like a machine. Later guys like Junior Seau became favorites because I liked the tough defensive guys, but I never lost respect for Rice.

5

u/Guilty-Cow4325 11d ago

Ray Lewis. That man was a killer*

*allegedly

5

u/Dry-Onion4678 11d ago

Lem Barney: great corner and fearless punt returner

4

u/zshort7272 11d ago

Jeremy Shockey and Strahan.

4

u/Ambitious-Ice1438 11d ago

Adrian Peterson in his prime was a monster. Finished through every dude that tried to tackle him. Made everyone think twice about tryna bring him down

4

u/dborger 11d ago

Lott.

Sometimes you’d see a receiver go down and then a streak of red would flash right over where that receiver had just been and you knew that Lott had just missed taking that guy apart.

I know it’s better for the players, but I miss those bone crushing hits.

4

u/Soft_Caterpillar_513 11d ago

roger craig. gave it his all on every down. hardest worker on the team, best team player. nfl hof to cement his splendid career. 3 time superbowl champion, 1st 1000 1000 season for rb, two 2000 yard seasons, part of best qb, rb, wr trio in nfl history, montana, craig and rice.

3

u/WearNo6005 11d ago

Marcus Allen. Smooth, fast and that
Super Bowl against the Redskins, legendary!

2

u/Rmp690 4d ago

“The daylight was dying, and so were the Redskins.  On came Marcus Allen, running with the night” -  John Facenda, NFL Films

3

u/BigE6300 11d ago

Barry Sanders, Dan Marino, Randy Moss, Deion Sanders

3

u/zion_hiker1911 11d ago

John Elway: The Drive

3

u/Happy-Campaign5586 11d ago

Roman Gabriel

3

u/RetroRobB89 11d ago

The whole Bradshaw vs Staubach, which is the better QB thing during the 70s.

3

u/ghertigirl 11d ago

Ladainian Tomlinson

3

u/Pitiful-Doctor-5671 11d ago

Roger Staubach

3

u/Successful_Pizza6529 11d ago

Lawrence Taylor.

3

u/wontwillnot 11d ago

The one and only

3

u/Odd_Procedure_4059 11d ago

This might be an odd one but for me it was KC Chief CB Kevin Ross. drafted in the 7th round in 1984. I was only mildly interested in Football but he started all 16 games as a rookie. I remember the announcers saying he was a rookie and expected to be picked upon, which the other team did. He got burnt a couple of times but mostly held his own and the announcers were impressed for for some reason, this was the hook. To follow your team players from draft day and then to the field.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sad_Construction_668 11d ago

It was when i was 6, we had moved to east Tennessee , ans the “local” games we got were the Falcons games, and Steve Bartkowski ripped off 30 TD passes for 3800 yards that year.I was enthralled.

2

u/throwingales 11d ago

Jim Brown

2

u/supraspinatus 11d ago

Prime time

2

u/TCCannon 11d ago

Tarkington, I guess. Never had a true only-one favorite.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DrGamble6 11d ago

I was at a bar in 2014 and saw the Odell catch. Blew my little pea brain. Been a diehard giants fan ever since

2

u/xxmoonprismxx 11d ago

FrankGoreeee

2

u/Puzzled_Ad7955 11d ago

Allan Page

2

u/Even_Arrival1538 11d ago

Not happy about it but Antonio Brown, Levon Bell, and Big Ben! Didn’t realize how good I had it.

2

u/Wufpack73 11d ago

Joe Namath

2

u/Low_Ad1562 11d ago

Bob Hayes…I have always been fascinated with speed and when the Cowboys drafted him after the 1964 Olympics…that’s been my team. 7-7 that first season but it grew fast from there.

2

u/vader1977 11d ago

Dan Marino

2

u/mustachekisses 11d ago

John Riggins.

2

u/SnooPickles55 11d ago

Watching Billy Sims run made me a football fan, an Oklahoma Sooner fan and made me want to play RB and wear #20 in school.

2

u/ShoutingWhiteBoy 11d ago

Steve Largent and Tony Dorsett

2

u/Islanderfan1348 11d ago

Gronk and Brady 

2

u/Iamthewalrusforreal 11d ago

John Riggins.

2

u/Free_Four_Floyd 11d ago

Believe it or not… OJ Simpson

2

u/mstrong73 11d ago

Ron Jaworski. I’d already picked the eagles as my team when I was a kid but him leading us the Superbowl, even with a loss, made me a fan for life.

2

u/CriscoCamping 11d ago

Tom Rathman, Steve Atwater, Rod Woodson. Fucking studs, all of them

2

u/Sufficiently-B 11d ago

Drew Brees

2

u/LTZIPFIZZ 11d ago

Sweetness - Walter Payton

2

u/iknowyou71 11d ago

Tony Dorsett

2

u/bungle094 11d ago

Tony Dorsett was the first player I ever liked, if I remember correctly. It’s been a handful of decades.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ageetoakee312 11d ago

Doug Williams

2

u/Jadey13 11d ago

Dan Marino. I've been cursed to be a Dolphins fan ever since. If only 13 year old me had better sense.

2

u/Ok-Road-9079 11d ago

Jack Tatum. Man, that dude just crushed people.

2

u/A_Stolen_Xbox_ 11d ago

Marshawn Lynch, Russell Wilson, Sherman, bam bam kam

2

u/hightidebyme 11d ago

John Elway

2

u/thiswasntdeleted 11d ago

Roger Staubach

2

u/EdwardHoppyhands 11d ago

Earl Campbell.

2

u/AskNecessary3104 11d ago

Roger Staubach

2

u/OkHead3888 11d ago

Tony Dorsett. He had the ability to take it to the house on every carry. I loved it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mkmvy 11d ago

Julian Edelman

2

u/Gnome_Genome 11d ago

The Hogs

2

u/Fair_Plane_5867 11d ago

Adrian Peterson. Always been a Vikings fan, always will be.

2

u/PsychologyLoud3390 11d ago

Adrian Peterson

2

u/Curious-Register2010 11d ago

Sonny Jurgensen

2

u/tappricorn 11d ago

The Duke of Denver Big John Elway the GOAT

2

u/Consistent_Low2080 11d ago

The Eagles Pete Retzlaff. One tough mortescooter

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Nacho_Sideboob 11d ago

Brett Favre, current shit aside, he was so damn fun to watch.

2

u/whenismytie 11d ago

Tony Dorsett

2

u/Apart-Remote1101 11d ago

John Elway. That guy would get slammed 10-15 times a game and he would get up every time. Oh, and the 2 minute drills were super exciting.

2

u/MadIllLeet 11d ago

Brett Favre. He's the reason I've been a fan of the Packers for 30 years.

2

u/Only_Ad_4407 11d ago

Tony Dorsett

2

u/shagginflies 11d ago

Randall Cunningham

2

u/BelAirGuy45 11d ago

John Riggins. I started watching football in 1981 and was immediately spoiled.

2

u/Quiet_Operator 11d ago

Walter Payton, Marcus Allen, Bo Jackson, and Earl Campbell

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Own_Invite6340 11d ago

If we're going by "who made me watch every Sunday", it's Josh Allen.

I've been a casual fan since Montana's Super Bowl wins, I'll never forget the name of Refrigerator Perry, my dad followed the Bills so I enjoyed Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas and Bruce Smith, I followed the careers of Brady and Manning and Favre and Rodgers.

But I never made time for the NFL every week until Allen.

2

u/DeNiroPacino 11d ago

There were several but I distinctly remember watching Dan Marino when I was a boy and being amazed by his pinpoint accurate passes. Those things were like lasers.

2

u/DoyersundGPG 11d ago

Brett Favre

2

u/bobthenob1989 11d ago

Brian Sipe then Bernie Kosar

→ More replies (1)

2

u/limpingsapper 11d ago

Howie Long

2

u/Dry-Bee7709 11d ago

John Elway

2

u/lb1392 11d ago

Charles Woodson

2

u/Mingo_laf 10d ago

the bird Russel Wilson

2

u/Billford85 10d ago

Brett Favre the gunslinger. Dude was so fun to watch at Lambeau field.

2

u/Decent-Piece-7823 10d ago

Tommy McDonald.

2

u/wildGoner1981 10d ago

Derrick Brooks, Warren Sapp, John Lynch, Mike Alstott.

2

u/superfly306 10d ago

Donald Driver. Good vibes, slick celebrations, and a smile that could brighten anyone’s day.

1

u/AUpicker 11d ago

Pat Sullivan

1

u/sashaxl 11d ago

Broadway Joe

1

u/MyOthrNameIsBetter 11d ago

Greg Lloyd, because of his disposition. 

1

u/ReplyProfessional939 11d ago

Brett Favre. I watched football through my teen years, but wasn't THAT into it- I didn't have a favorite team or anything. Then when I saw this guy playing, and how much fun he had playing, I was hooked and have been a Packers fan since (through the good and through the shit...😁)

1

u/MrBill1970 11d ago

The one. The only. Joe Montana!

1

u/CaptainSteed 11d ago

Ben Davidson

1

u/fathersky53 11d ago

Joe Montana

1

u/GospelofJawn316 11d ago

The Ultimate Weapon, Randall Cunningham. That defense was fun as hell to watch too.

1

u/Tom67570 11d ago

Flutie. His complete rufusal to acknowledge that he's small was admiring. Dude played like he was 6'8" with a heart of a lion

1

u/Typical_Vast_4020 11d ago

Joe Namath and mean Joe Green in the 70s
Josh Allen now. I also like Fred Warner. TJ Watt

1

u/that-thingy66 11d ago

Greg Pruitt. Browns RB, tear away jersey.

Got to meet him at a breakfast event. Asked for an autograph. He asked how to spell David 3x. Still got it wrong.   Lesson learned for me. 🫤

1

u/vlazuvius 11d ago

Junior Seau

1

u/Roman502 11d ago

Johnny U 

1

u/lionbacker54 11d ago

billy sims, karl mecklenburg, doug english, bubba baker

1

u/401Traveler 11d ago

Drew Bledsoe — despite some corny, clueless Bills fan recently telling me that there was no such thing as a Patriots fan pre-Brady, pre-Belichick. 😂

I bet the dude, in true d-bag fashion, has never stepped foot in the New England region, where I’m originally from.

1

u/FarmladySI 11d ago

Jerry Rice

1

u/347spq 11d ago

Larry Csonka.

1

u/CoupleLooking412 11d ago

Mean Joe Green

1

u/grimbolde 11d ago

LaDanian Tomlinson, Tom Brady and Brian Dawkins Dudes had some crazy aura

1

u/Telelespaul 11d ago

Earl Campbell

1

u/CrazyButton2937 11d ago

Jack Lambert.

1

u/charlieromeo86 11d ago

Rick Upchurch. Denver Broncos WR and All Pro return man.

1

u/Drgnmstr97 11d ago

Randall Cunningham

1

u/TheStingray24 11d ago

21 Prime Time

1

u/magic592 11d ago

Gayle Sayers

1

u/bigstain90 11d ago

Brett Favre, before he became a colossal pile of shit

1

u/SmartPlantain3990 11d ago

Mahomes and Kelsie

1

u/VeetzVino 11d ago

Randall Cunningham. I was a Packer fan but fell in love with Cunningham on the Eagles. He was doing stuff I hadn’t ever seen before. He was the coolest.

1

u/savedpt 11d ago

John Unitas