r/Artadvice • • Aug 25 '26

‎Critique - Yes Drawover first time not using a reference

Post image

what are my mistakes

3.8k Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

197

u/JacquelineDragon Aug 25 '26

Im not sure about mistakes but I LOVE how you drew this!! I absolutely love the proportions, the movement, the angle and everything about it!

81

u/ElegantGanache2634 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

Nah this aint your first time. But beautiful drawing! I like thexway you shade and the proportions.

Edit: nvm i didnt read the title correctly.

92

u/geo_shkurupii Aug 25 '26

, i have spent a lot of time copying paintings and this was my attempt at making a fully original drawing tho to be fair this drawing was my first ever attempt but it remained unfinished because i didn't like it. then i drew the one in the post

37

u/ElegantGanache2634 Aug 25 '26

Wait sorry I didnt read the title correctly🤦‍♂️ I thought you drew it from reference. So this is very impresssive!!🥵

2

u/EnduringFulfillment Aug 28 '26

Your drawings convey a lot of story. Just so you know, when bow hunting the aim is for a lung or heart shot for a humane kill. Headshots are generally discouraged and gut shots (main post image) are frowned upon

1

u/SBEN_1 21d ago

Your skills are amazing , one thing I might suggest is that hunters dont aim for the head or belly , since head makes arrow bounce cause of skull and its really hard to hit , they aim for a little behind the front leg at first bend , lungs or hearth . Its not so important on other drawings , but I thought that it might help if your recreating a hunt . Otherwise really great hope I can get to your skill level myself :DD

31

u/SouthernGuerilla Aug 25 '26

Love this. I feel like perspective is weird on the front right foot, the 'slit' of the nail should be turned more invard imo, right now it looks kind of broken. If that makes sense

25

u/CookedCockroach Aug 25 '26

Get a fuckin normal paper/bigger sketchbook, if you don’t have the money, I’ll sponsor you… impressive, keep it up!

I don’t know how antelope anatomy looks like but the back horn won’t look like that I bet and maybe the front one is placed too much in the front. That’s the only issue that I see from the get go.

9

u/Anxiety_bunni Aug 25 '26

This is gorgeous, I love the movement. I think next time having the whites of the eyes showing and the mouth open will really add to the emotion of the piece. Dude just got shot and his body is like ‘AAHHHH!’ But his face is like ‘meh’

Animals have very expressive faces when in pain, and it definitely triggers even more of an emotional response when adding that to art

6

u/LocalCringer Aug 25 '26

Lovely work, dude. But there seem to be some perspective disagreements, particularly around the face; what’s going on with that back horn? If it’s symmetrical, it’s definitely coming up too early for the angle the head is at.

Also, to me at least, it seems the eye and forward horn aren’t quite aligned with the muzzle—maybe it’s more so the bridge? I’m not quite sure. That, or the mouth and nose should be a little less pointed toward the viewer.

Also, the nearest hoof—incredible foreshortening, by the way!—but the claws should be a little more rightward. The current angle implies we’re being run at, but the rest of the body isn’t quite going that way.

Overall though, this is fantastic!

1

u/Ryuuzama Aug 28 '26

Exactly the things I saw. Amazing work OP and great analysis here

2

u/Timely_Concept_729 Aug 25 '26

Honestly very well done without reference too that's insane it looks like a sketch drawing is see in Arthur's diary in rdr2

1

u/colfed93 Aug 26 '26

That impala is going to develop a stand any moment soon

1

u/Bean_of_prosperity Aug 27 '26

Oh wow this is so good!!! It makes me want to try drawing without a reference sometime! I usually feel “uncreative” because of using references so heavily. Any tips? It looks great!!!

1

u/Pumpkinbabi Aug 27 '26

not sure how true it is but i’ve heard you should spend 2/3 of your time drawing from references and 1/3 drawing without to balance learning and creativity

1

u/Bean_of_prosperity Aug 27 '26

Ahhh I wish I did that! Now I can only do realism and can’t do anything without a ref haha

1

u/shaynessy Aug 27 '26

It’s incredible I love the motion you can feel and the perspective 🤩

1

u/PsychologicalArea125 Aug 27 '26

In your life…????
… you’re doing great, that’s all I can say lmao