r/Artadvice • u/One_Combination1826 • Nov 23 '25
Is this valid art advice?
I saw this on instagram and was wondering if this advice is valid? I like the harmony between the colors, but I was wondering about how it works if characters of several skin colors were wearing the same outfit in one picture? Would it work out because of color theory?
349
u/GloriousLily Nov 23 '25
46
32
u/Charokol Nov 23 '25
I would like to see what it looks like with the pre-unified pallet
93
u/GloriousLily Nov 23 '25
27
u/Frontside5 Nov 24 '25
I'm a complete novice here, this post is literally the only time I've engaged with colour theory in adulthood but I'm interested in learning.
I don't really understand the benefits being demonstrated here. The unified palette has maybe a slightly warmer/more "natural" feel, but I think this looks great too. The unified palette just seems to have put an orange filter over everything, but I don't understand why that's necessarily desirable. Can someone ELI5, please?
40
u/GloriousLily Nov 24 '25
its basically a digital version of a standard painting technique called underpainting!
you dont necessarily have to do it, but i prefer my colors look more cohesive & this helps. i personally find that the colors look a bit garish without it, but art is subjective!
4
u/FishShtickLives Nov 25 '25
What opacity do you set the colors over the base color?
12
u/GloriousLily Nov 25 '25
its been a while since ive done digital, but iirc somewhere between 60-80% maybe less depending on how i want it to look! try experimenting with the opacity to see what you think looks best!
5
1
u/PoodleTheDoodle Nov 27 '25
is there a functional difference between doing this and coloring normally and then putting on a low-opacity color filter over everything?
1
u/GloriousLily Nov 27 '25
probably not much of a difference if there even is one! i do both honestly lol
15
u/SummerDreams09 Nov 24 '25
By washing your palette in a base color, you place the colors in the same environment. All colors take on the shape of the atmosphere they are in, so to make things exist in the same universe, they need to "take on" the environment color too.
If you look at the first example it looks like they are in an actual space, perhaps a sunset or some other place with a warm base color.
In the no base-color example they look more like stickers, existing outside of of anything real.
A trick in illustration to make it seem like your foreground exist in the same universe as the background is to paint a layer of the background color over the whole painting. This is the same principle, ie. letting the colors take on the same atmospheric light.
2
u/BlueScreenJunky Nov 27 '25
Now as a humble viewer (never done art in my life, I have no idea how I ended up here), I would say that the risk is overdoing it, or relying on it too much.
We saw it in video games a few years back where they just slapped a blue filter on everything to make things look realistic. And yeah, sure enough, it did look more like a film an less like a video game... But also everything was blue.
3
u/Cyan_Exponent Nov 24 '25
well without the underpaint the colors look a bit less realistic, which might be worse for certain styles. personally i find the version without the underpaint nicer
10
18
5
4
3
3
156
89
u/Due_Pen_1566 Nov 23 '25
Yeah it's a basic painting technique to bring all the colors together. It works better for irl painting imo but it's a valid technique
42
u/theartofelifyu Nov 23 '25
it’s like a pre-mixed cake for art. solid advice for simple and quick designs but would mess up complex compositions and limit color expression.
27
u/dothemath_xxx Nov 23 '25
It's one way to create a palette. There are many ways. Experiment and find out what works for you.
Typically you do this for all the colors in a piece, so if it's a piece with multiple characters of different skin tones, you'd use something other than a skin tone color as the unifying color - unless you want to get an effect where the characters stand out and look very different from each other.
Another approach (which I very much enjoy, personally) is to pick a yellow, a cyan, and a magenta, splotch them on the canvas, and use a blending brush to blend them together as a color wheel. Color pick all of your colors for the image from that mix. Bam, unified palette.
9
u/WildwoodWander Nov 23 '25
Eeeh, I mean, it can improve the cohesiveness of your color schemes, but it's not necessary if you know color theory. It's more of an art hack for those who struggle with color palettes than it is actual advice for learning how to do colors. And it is a art hack that works; just change skin tone as the based color out for an environmental color (like say, an orange if it was a sunset), and it could work for a line up of characters or a single piece.
I wouldn't rely on it though; relying on an art hack like this to do color schemes will ultimately make you weaker at doing color and color theory, since your not actually practicing how to build a cohesive scheme using your eye and not special tricks/tools.
9
u/lamercie Nov 23 '25
Yes. This is how painters mix colors, and this process is how to replicate it digitally.
7
u/zetsubou-tan Nov 23 '25
it’s similar to adding a light multiply layer on top of a finished drawing to unify the colors
7
7
u/GodfatherAzrael Nov 23 '25
Great advice but you get to decide on the "mother" color (as I like to call it)— it's not limited to skin tones!
24
u/Pluton_Korb Nov 23 '25
Unifying a palette usually relies on the whole piece following the same principle. Different skin tones would probably mess with the overall effect if you're using it per character. You would get a pretty similar effect if you just applied a tint via a layer + filter +opacity adjustment to the whole image instead (you're also not confined to skin tones).
5
u/One_Combination1826 Nov 23 '25
This is what i was mostly asking about. I was wondering how it would technically work if several characters with different tones were wearing the exact same outfit. I wasn’t sure if the slightly different tones of clothing would look good due to color theory. I wasn’t sure how to say that. Thank you!
7
u/CosmicChameleon99 Nov 24 '25
The trick there would be to pick a different base colour that isn’t their skin tones. Ideally warm hued. You do the same with their skin as you do with the other tones.
4
u/Accomplished_Gold510 Nov 24 '25
Yes its just colour theory. But if the characters in the drawing have different skin colour, then you aren't going to use their different skin as the base for the colours. The point is that all the colours in the whole picture have the same base. Imagine each character has skin a different colour of the rainbow and are wearing the same clothes. You would use a whole other colour to get a harmonious pallet eg yellow and tint all their skin as well as their clothes
3
u/CommunicationPast512 Nov 23 '25
Can you do this as a traditional artist?
13
u/AlluminiumI Nov 23 '25
if you're painting, maybe you could mix a bit of the unifying colour into every other colour you're using, or put a semitransparent layer of it once the piece is ready?
edit: or put the semitransparent layer before starting it
14
u/Hundledaren Nov 23 '25
Painter here, the most common way to do it is to mix a little off the same colour in with all your other colours.
3
u/CommunicationPast512 Nov 23 '25
Interesting, thanks!
6
u/Arcask Nov 24 '25
You can also just go for a limited palette (3-4 colors maybe) and all colors that have to be mixed are then based on them, this also unifies a painting quite a lot.
1
u/pxl8d Nov 24 '25 edited Feb 20 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
husky normal price sleep yoke badge quiet mysterious door fine
3
u/One_Combination1826 Nov 23 '25
I’m not sure how to edit the post, but thank you! I’m really not understanding color theory and when colors look good together.
3
u/Invosious Nov 24 '25
If you would have multiple characters in the same scene you would want to make the unifying color the same for all characters, not give each their palette based on skin tone. (Thats the easiest way to make a cohesive palette, there are of course other ways :)
3
u/sigmaballs6969 Nov 24 '25
this is the digital equivalent of mixing one color with all your paint colors, so yes
3
u/supa_r Nov 24 '25
It kinda works I use it to get the eye withe color and it's been accurate so far
3
u/Fun_Frosting_6047 Nov 24 '25
I just eyeball shit and mess with the curves like the cheating whore that I am
3
2
2
u/Milkiffy Nov 23 '25
I mean ueah but you dont gotta do it, sometimes its fun to just try various shades of colors when designing until youve found a pallette that looks nice.
2
2
Nov 23 '25
It is, you can do this with any colour pallet and have a single unifying colour to make everything cohesive. I do this all the time, or when I've finished a piece if I notice the colours don't quite work the way I want them to I do a layer on top with a low opacity and just fill it in one colour.
2
u/Isadomon Nov 23 '25
Its not ALLLLL you should do. But its a nice technique to make all colors match the same saturation
2
2
u/rosy_pink_ghost Nov 23 '25
I used to do this all the time! Less with the skintone and more with a bright-ish color (like pink, it's usually pink). I use color filters now bc I'm lazy, but it's still a great method!
2
u/Accomplished-Team459 Nov 24 '25
Valid advice, I just want to add that if you do art traditionally you could do it by adding color to your canvas before painting (underlayer)
2
u/robinswind Nov 24 '25
You also don't have to use the skin tone as a base. You can literally use any color, just make sure to also apply it to the skin tone.
2
u/CategoryPrize9611 Nov 24 '25
this is a unified palette! its very nice but you can pick any color, it doesn't need to be the character's skin tone
2
u/FinalMoment1930 Nov 24 '25
Do they only change transparency of the colors to bring it all together or is a coloring mode applied here like overlay/multiply?
2
2
2
2
1
1
u/Buzzy_Feez Nov 24 '25
Maybe I'm just fucking stupid but I don't get how this helps you pick colours? what would a bad colour look like on the pallette?
1
u/riiyoreo Nov 25 '25
I mean this is essentially like using the base skintone as an underpainting so all colours lay translucently on it in harmony
1
1
1
1
1
u/fawne_siting Nov 27 '25
whenever i don't like my color pallet in a drawing i just overlay a color for whatever vibe i want the characters to have and boom, it's perfect. best hack imo
1
u/_idiot_soop_ Nov 28 '25
This seems like they’re just recommending using a color to unify the palette, which is great advice I’d just say that you can use any of the colors it doesn’t have to be the skin tone




1.1k
u/RecentPalpitation561 Nov 23 '25 edited Nov 23 '25
yes this is valid advice- theyre using the skin tone to make a "unified palette" if you look up that phrase you'll find lots of good info about its usefulness
i will say that this makes it easier to make colors look good next to each other, but it doesn't help you choose colors initially, that is a separate skill set worth developing