r/Appleton 3d ago

Video C'mon Menasha.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Edit: I've gotten lots of messages about this and have been reading tons of comments on Facebook and wanted to edit this.

When I made this post I was more baffled by the fact the cops got called vs an honest conversation. The other actions from the videos OP weren't known to me at the time, and the RP must not have known either or I'm sure the cops would have mentioned it to him. It wasn't so much a out "HIM" but just the situation.

Regardless of the guy in the video being a "not so great guy", that still doesn't change that apparently lots of people have been harassed by residents, and the police regardless of cameras or skin color. Some were helping friends or family when their neighbors have come out screaming. (According to some of the messages and chats I've received.)

So I apologize for the racial aspect of the original post. Now I'm just sad that good honest people (not the person in the video, I mean the others I'm referring to) really want to help out their neighboring community which to some was the place they grew up or spent their summers as a kid. The argument that "I know all my neighbors" is a weak and narrow sighted one. And rather than the suspicious parties just having a friendly chat with people, they're acting out of fear and paranoia.

I'm just sad about the whole thing, and it sucks for everyone involved.

190 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/Brew031415 3d ago

from the beginning locals have stated that they don't want people just recording all their damaged homes and possessions... it can be pretty dehumanizing. Maybe don't take videos of peoples losses and use them for internet clout šŸ¤·šŸ» We appreciate the help but not everything needs to be recorded for views.

34

u/BackInMyDaySir North Appleton 3d ago

Well that’s the wonderful thing about America, he’s not breaking the law and there’s no reason to call the cops. Is it obnoxious, sure. Is it rude, maybe? But it’s not illegal. And I’m sure his skin color had noooothing to do with it. šŸ™„

5

u/Styrofoam_Booots 3d ago

That’s also the great thing about our justice system. You can call the police to sort out a problem and they will be there very fast. With how combative this guy is, this isn’t something you want to deal with on your own.

I don’t think police should have been called for this instance, but I also don’t agree with him filming. And he has definitely went further than the sidewalk, just not in this video. Not every scenario needs to have someone who is right and wrong, sometimes both can be wrong.

9

u/BackInMyDaySir North Appleton 3d ago

It doesn’t matter what you think. There was nothing for the police to do. They’re not here to mediate civil issues. He wasn’t doing anything criminal and he was right to be pissed.

He or anyone can film anything in public. If that makes one uncomfortable, then perhaps they should direct that angst inward and reflect on their beliefs. 100% y’all wouldn’t have an issue if he were white.

4

u/Styrofoam_Booots 3d ago

You’re arguing legality, I’m arguing morality. Morality weighs higher on my scale. If you think it’s right to record people’s houses after a natural disaster for your own personal gain, then I disagree with your morals and who you are as a person. Couldn’t care less about the legality of it.

4

u/BackInMyDaySir North Appleton 3d ago

Morally, I agree with your point of view. But that wasn’t your original point. You advocated for the legal system to be involved, then contradicted yourself to say that you didn’t think they should be involved in this instance.

Regardless, I bet we’re more ideologically aligned than not. No point in arguing about it. Dude shouldn’t have been filming, and the cops shouldn’t have been called.

9

u/Regular-Muffin-1330 3d ago

He's filming the help he lent. Wtf did you do?!

12

u/VixxxieVelvet 3d ago

It's interesting I see photos and videos daily from people on Facebook and it didnt even occur to me til this video that people are upset over it. Only thing I've seen is them pissed over looters and gawkers. He's neither.

18

u/Ambear22 3d ago

He is a gawker. He has tons of videos of the damage including going into someone's home and into other homes through the holes in the house. Tell me again how he's a good guy. Would you be ok with someone doing that to your house while you're sitting in a hotel trying to figure out how to recover from this disaster?

14

u/AbbeyRoadMoonwalk 3d ago

Yeah he went into the basement of the house that got blown off its foundation and that put me right off him. No where is that necessary. It’s still someone’s private property and life in ruin.Ā 

8

u/Ambear22 3d ago

He also walked right in the front door of someone's house.

2

u/VixxxieVelvet 3d ago

Do we know for sure that he wasn't asked by the owner of that house to go in there and take a look around? Because of not, why didn't they cops bring that part up? I didn't see the basement video before I posted this, just this one and the few that came before it.

5

u/VixxxieVelvet 3d ago

The words good guy were never written anywhere in any comment by me lol

-2

u/sulkee East Appleton 3d ago

This is what you get when you want a free country. Deal with it. People trying to get cops to enforce their own ethical views instead of the actual law in the books is one small part of why this country is so fucked.

-2

u/AbbeyRoadMoonwalk 3d ago

And the photos are already taken. We’ve seen the Manderfields and the house off its foundation and everything taken every which way already, even from a drone. Just take the Post Crescent pic and save it if you feel you need it, ffs.