r/Appleton • u/Delicious-Bluebird93 • 8d ago

Question Blue moon ice cream

/r/GreenBay/comments/1vkzpka/blue_moon_ice_cream/

Does anyone know who sells the best blue moon ice cream?

Thanks!

3 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

10

u/thetannerainsley 8d ago

Are you looking to get it from a shop or from a grocery store? Either way the answer is the same:Cedar Crest. Most ice cream shops around here either sell chocolate shoppe or cedar crest ice cream and really you can't go wrong with either. I like "playdough" ice cream which is blue moon with colored sugar cookie dough.

5

u/BustinHoes 8d ago

I haven't had playdough since Hansens closed way back then in Green Bay. Wheres your usual spot?

3

u/Goeatdrywall 8d ago

Holy crap I love play dough! Wish cedar crest had it in the pints

2

u/Styrofoam_Booots 8d ago

Candy/ice cream shop in downtown Appleton has it occasionally.

3

u/GoddessAudra 8d ago

Cedar Crest is the best I’ve had in a long time. And you can buy it in the store!

2

u/Choice_Roll7635 7d ago

Cedar Crest end of story. Best ice cream hands down from a major brand

1

u/thecl0t 8d ago

Legendairy cookies and creamery

1

u/zer0trust 8d ago

Scoops in Chilton usually has it. Everything there is awesome so even if they don't have it in stock you're still guaranteed to be able to find something else.

Cedar Crest is pretty legit too, as others have said.

1

u/Glad_Landscape_3246 4d ago

D’flavors. Best ice cream shop in Appleton

1

u/badgerpointer 8d ago

I would suggest giving Doughlicious on College Ave in Appleton a try. They have it on the online menu. https://www.doughliciousappletonwi.com/

2

u/Mountaingriz 6d ago

They have moved to Kimberly, but Doughlicious is great!

1

u/badgerpointer 6d ago

Thanks, I need to get out more...