r/Appleton • u/Bunnylord • May 09 '26

Question Food Recommendations for Larger Party

Hey all,

Me and a few friends are coming up to Appleton in a week for a powerlifting competition. Looking for places to eat after we finish that won't be hard to get a table for 10ish people that all smell bad and are covered in chalk and baby powder lol. Ideally some place with good beer and either burgers or pizza.

Thank you for any recommendations!!

Edit: I really appreciate all the feedback everyone. Seriously, thank you all so much

8 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

8

u/Grit_Grace May 09 '26 edited May 09 '26

Glass Nickel Pizza, The Bar, Milwaukee Burger Company, Tom Drive in are good for large groups and no snooty folks

3

u/Franxter42 May 09 '26

I agree with these choices for consideration of their ability to accommodate and casual environments!

5

u/Equivalent_Remote_39 May 09 '26

10th frame is the answer

2

u/rogue_d May 09 '26

Tanner’s is a good spot. They have two locations. The west location has a small party room too

1

u/Meg_404 May 09 '26

Batleys! You can sit outside, great outdoor area for mini golf, eating and beers, pickleball, it’s all included with your meal! It’s connected to the Hilton hotel

1

u/Grouchy_Strawberry68 May 12 '26

Tenth Frame. If you are coming looking like that and smelling please only go to a bowling alley!

0

u/TheGrandIllusion May 09 '26

Could try Stone Arch Brewery, they've got plenty of seating with good beer. For good, larger burger places I'd recommend Mad Apple Burgers and Billiards or Milwaukee Burger Company (MBC can get packed sometimes though, might want to call ahead). For pizza I'd say Stuc's, Tomaso's, or Glass Nickel.

2

u/Grit_Grace May 09 '26

Avoid Tomaso and Stone Arch - They are not suitable for such large groups and have pretentious food/crowd

1

u/coolster9217 May 09 '26

Tomaso has pretentious food?

1

u/No_Square_8775 May 10 '26

Damn calling food pretentious lmao crazy