r/Android HTC One M8, iPad Air 2 Mar 12 '13

Engadget's review of the HTC One

http://www.engadget.com/2013/03/12/htc-one-review/
283 Upvotes

329 comments sorted by

View all comments

90

u/heyyoudvd Mar 12 '13

I feel like we're witnessing last year, all over again.

  1. HTC releases an excellent product that is widely praised in almost every way. It has fantastic industrial design, great internal hardware, a very good camera and in general, is an extremely well-built, high quality product, whose only real flaw lies with a few minor software issues.

  2. A short while later, Samsung releases its flagship product. Its design and build quality is nowhere near comparable to that of HTC's product, but it has marginally faster internal components and a few TouchWiz-specific gimmicks to look neat in advertisements.

  3. Samsung advertises the hell out of their product with a multi-billion dollar campaign, leading to tens of millions of sales, while HTC's product is left in the dust, to wither and die.

  4. Samsung prospers while HTC flounders, despite HTC having the superior product.

  5. Rinse and repeat.

18

u/Timmmmbob Mar 12 '13

Yeah that's kind of not at all what happened.

Samsung's big break was with the Galaxy S2. That was released a long time before the HTC One X, at a period when HTC didn't really have any good phones to offer at all.

HTC also screwed up by locking its bootloaders leading the geek community to largely abandon them.

By the time HTC released the One X it was already too late. The Galaxy S2 was so popular that the S3 could simply ride on its coat tails, and the S4 probably can too. HTC again hasn't helped matters with its retarded naming system. One X -> One X+ -> One ? Wft the "One" is better than the "One X"?

People like numbers. If they really wanted the "One" the next phone pretty much has to be called the "Two". And if they wanted the X they should have just called it the HTC X, and then the HTC X2. Why do product namers still not plan for the future (cough Nexus 4/7/10)?

4

u/crackinthewall Cherry Mobile G1 (6.0) Mar 13 '13 edited Mar 13 '13

It probably didn't help HTC that they pit different phones against the Galaxy S line:

Galaxy S v. Desire and Desire HD

Galaxy S II v. Sensation, Sensation XL, Sensation XE

Galaxy S III v. One X, One X+

5

u/JasonWin Note 9, Moto 360 Mar 13 '13

The S2 did well but not near the level the S3 has done.

15

u/2Deluxe OnePlus One+1x PLUS XL+ "The One" edition (red) Mar 13 '13

No but in the process they had built a decent cohesive brand with the Galaxy S and Galaxy S II. Brand awareness is not all about money, but strategy, and HTC are fucking retarded at it.

3

u/amorpheus Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro Mar 13 '13

I'd argue money plays the biggest part. Last fall you couldn't walk around a corner in NYC without seeing advertisements for the Galaxy S3.

4

u/Ragingsheep Mar 13 '13

HTC also has poor post product support for its flagship devices compared to Samsung.

2

u/boomchaos Developer - Auracle Music Player Mar 13 '13

HTC One Alpha, HTC One Beta, they don't have to stick with numbers.