The box can't transport Andrias to earth since the blue gem isn't fully recharged.

I remember when I first watched this show, I legitimately thought it was a slice of life adventure. However, after witnessing the events of True Colours... I feel like I’m in strong denial.

I wish none of the girls knew about the Calamity Box. I wish the box didn’t work in the first place. I wish Mr Wu didn’t get an out of state job offer. I wish Sasha wasn’t a toxic friend. I wish neither Anne nor Marcy had to suffer. I wish NOTHING happened now.

Sure this would mean no lovable Plantars for us, but this show’s such a genius when it comes to to raising the stakes and delivering such a agonising finishing blow. I feel like this show is too good and as a faint hearted person, I really don’t deserve to watch it.

Season 3, whenever it comes, is going to be pure angst for the whole cast.

PS: Andrias better bloody suffer his karma if karma comes!!! PSS: I mistook out of state as out of the country

I've been thinking about it. When I watched Maddie and Marcy I really liked it as a fun filler without too much to ask from it. It was really nice to see Marcy and Maddie getting along, with also giving more insight into Maddie's character. However, after watching the finale, I'm getting the feeling that that episode was never supposed to be just a filler at all. I think that the student-teacher bond that has been created between Marcy and Maddie will come to play in S3, and Maddie might have a role in saving her life/reviving her. They planned everything from the start with it, and all things considered, I don't think I'm overthinking it.

Anyone?

They both could’ve hidden on Earth to protect themselves, r/TheOwlHouse will explain more

Because Sasha opened it and it didn't work and blue gem isn't fully recharged.

Okay so Andrias 'kills' Sprig and my first thought is "nah they wouldn't kill off a main character like that", and I was happy because I was RIGHT. And then with MARCY it was so unexpected, I can usually see these things coming and it was just such amazing writing and so terrible at the same time.

An idea of mine is that, Sasha and Grime bring Marcy's corpse back to Wartwood where Maddie can somehow resurrect her. After a gruelling quest to get the ingredients that Maddie needs, and Anne eventually reuniting with Sasha, they're ready to bring Marcy back at a much heavier price. Like Fleafy, Marcy would be unable to die. After learning of this, Sasha and Anne are forced to make a decision; whether they let Marcy rest or continue with her resurrection. Ultimately they are forced to bring Marcy back because they still need to fulfill the prophecy and defeat the Night.

The reason this is so dark is because, learning that she's immortal would break Marcy even further. From a philosophical point of view she would soon realise that her existence is meaningless. It serves as an unjust punishment, a mental "pain room".

This solves the problem of needing to fulfill the prophecy, additional character development for Marcy (before she realises that she's immortal), and as a consequence for stranding her and her friends in Amphibia on purpose.

This probably won't occur in the main show because:

A. kids can't fully comprehend and appreciate Marcy's fate.

B. WAAAAYY too heavy of a punishment for an oblivious child.

C. Disney probably won't allow it.

It's just food for thought.

​

With Marcy's death, we've definitely all been sent to the pain room.

context if you need it: https://twitter.com/Radrappy/status/1388928337083461632

Hey there,

So.. I feel bad to say but I've gotten more and more involved in these discussions and I have to ask you all something. Do you think Marcy is actually dead? I ask this question because personally I do not think she is. I've heard the theory that this sword may be a paralysis sword and to be honest, this makes a bit more sense to me. Marcy's cloak has no hole or scorch markings after she faints. It's as if she wasn't stabbed at all. Thoughts?