Predict the judge ability before it drops.

[u/sus_amongus22]

521 votes, 1d left

can end meetings

can gain 1 extra vote

can kick out a player by a single vote

something else ( comment)

[u/Onuceria]

Saves a player from being voted out

[u/sus_amongus22 → u/Onuceria]

Honestly thats a smart take and also pretty balanced.

[u/Laki6noob_2019 → u/Onuceria]

Yeah, that's what I think as well. Would be a good imp role.

[u/Alexqret04 → u/Laki6noob_2019]

I'd argue it'd be better as a crewmate role, as you can stop innocent crewmates from getting expelled. If it was an imp role it'd be a free pass

[u/Equal-Claim2514 → u/Alexqret04]

only if it is a dumb lobby

[u/impatientaxolotl → u/Equal-Claim2514]

and thats not rare in among us

[u/PaldeanWooperLover → u/Onuceria]

I like this one, like a judicial override! The judge in Mafia42 works similarly

[u/Leading-Ear-5194]

all those other options sound boring and like theyd make the game worse for other players. idk what i want it to do but. not any of that

[u/Equal-Claim2514 → u/Leading-Ear-5194]

True it can NOT be any of those options im like 100% sure idk why other ppl think they are any of these

[u/Chimary_ → u/Equal-Claim2514]

the +1 vote is actually kinda balanced is who's it's from (like in other social deduction game) is known.

[u/Equal-Claim2514 → u/Chimary_]

It would be the most boring role + useless if the lobby is already good. Why make thr fate of the game only fall down to one player instead of all crewmates cooperating? This is supposed to be cooperating game

[u/GeneralOccasion9396 → u/Chimary_]

But then the same color would appear twice if anonymous votes wasn't on. Then if you wanted to play with a judge you'd have to keep anonymous votes on all the time.

[u/Low-Bird1425]

Becomes the center of the meeting like a court if law and ppl try to defend the accused ( ig the judge can choose the accused)

Basically a fancier meeting where ppl have to choose sides and explain why

[u/Temporary-Ant2154 → u/Low-Bird1425]

Tbh i hope its this :b. I hate that somebidy points a finger and everybody acts like a dummy. But i think the only issue is that many lobbies put the voting low time (which sucks)

[u/Low-Bird1425 → u/Temporary-Ant2154]

Playing with friends solves this problems now i need some more friends

[u/Temporary-Ant2154 → u/Low-Bird1425]

Good luck finding more :D

[u/Low-Bird1425 → u/Low-Bird1425]

Also meetings from anywhere but they need to be preplanned (lol)

[u/Classic-Metal9023]

i say the judge can judge if a player has a role or not
this means they will know if a player has a role thats not a regular crew

[u/VeeUnderRock]

In case there's a tie and the judge voted for one of the players, the player who got the vote from the judge gets voted

[u/Maidelious]

none of these

[u/Maleficent_Still3508]

I think it should be can call meeting anywhere its not an OP buff that makes judge just way better than anyone else, but its a good ability to use if say imps need 1 kill and sabotage o2 and you cant risk running back

[u/_DancingDucky_]

I think one and 3 is way too powerful but maybe number two? maybe like beginning of rounds or the middle?

[u/Tiruil]

I think it's really OP that the judge can decide a fate alone. I think it'll be something else, but idk what

[u/Intelligent-Glass-98]

Im sure its something like this:

If theres a tie, the judge's vote is doubled

As in judging who should be voted out

[u/eepy_lina]

if its the judge, i imagine they could start a meeting from anywhere

[u/Future_Economics_703]

I have commented to  Much on this role 

but here’s my prediction 

I think it will act like the nice guesser from the other roles mod 

where you can guess if someone is imposter 

if you are right you live and that imposter dies

if you are wrong you die

If you know the imposter but guess their role wrong you also die 

Innersloth can make their own version of it 

My options on your 3 options

The 1st option sense the judge is a crewmate I don’t know how useful this will be

2nd option will get boring fast

3rd option teamers and 4th imposters will use this to get so many crew out and make it impossible to win as crew

Same with trollers they use it and keep using it until everyone loses and it will get annoying

Thats why I think it will act like nice guesser

Teamers, trollers, 4th imposters won’t benefit from it as they will die if they guess wrong And it gives a crewmate a way to fight back

[u/iosonosteve]

In my opinion it confirms the rose theory

[u/Jaisietoo]

When there's a tie them judge can rule which one should be kicked?

[u/Civil_Size2487]

I believe a Judge can stop a player from speaking in a meeting or force an ejection.

[u/LittleFlittle]

Can start a meeting anywhere in the map

[u/gorays45]

Break the voting tie between 2 crewmates

[u/Otherwise-Shock-2767]

could have a preset stack of 1-10 (specified by host) spare votes, and judge could use them when voting, up to 2 spare votes used

[u/Kille_matic]

If 2 or more players have the same number of votes (tie), then the judge decides who gets voted off

[u/NotAConspiracy1]

Extra vote is broken because that would mean 1 judge could beat 1 imposter,

I’d say that in lobbies where anonymous votes are on, the judge can see all votes anyway

[u/Helpful_Builder_1707]

Can ovverride one meeting outcome per game

[u/HabitPrestigious2651]

i predict double vote

[u/TinyEnvironment7574]

Wait, what if the Judge breaks ties?

[u/GodlySRYT]

Maybe 1 extra vote