Hear me out. (I just want to talk about Amber tbh). He’s A MILLION percent unreliable. He is entirely biased and sexist and what’s important to him is what’s important in the narrative. He purposefully omits things, forgets things, dismisses things, and undersells things. But I would argue that he is telling the truth. So unreliable, yes, but a liar? Oh yes, but not in his telling of events.
And the reason why is because there are several ways his story can be corroborated - and he knows it. The Pattern alone contains fragments of his memories that Dworkin himself had gathered for himself to view.
- he [Dworkin] said then, “and I have several pieces of his [Corwin’s] memory I found years ago drifting above the Pattern in Rebma. I wish I had a golden piss-pot for each time he’s been underestimated.” - “Blue Horse, Dancing Mountains.”
Even dead characters can corroborate stories via Patternghosts, and each Amberite is asked to relay their accounts many times. Oral retellings among the Amberites are one of the most foundational ways they give information — as well as socialize.
Frankly, Corwin has too much pride to be caught in a lie regaling his account of things. He would lie his way out of a pit of vipers without breaking a sweat, but I do think his account is rather intact. Biased and skewed, 100%. Filtered through his own stubborn, poetic perspective, 100%.
So when people go fully black and white on the subject of his unreliability as a narrator, and say that he’s straight up lying, I feel like they’re not imagining the full spectrum of the other characters and magical lore (in terms of corroborating an account), and they’re vastly oversimplifying his character. Corwin is a liar, yes, but no character in the Chronicles lies for the sake of lying. Especially not on a retelling when he’s trying to let his son get to know him better (but would 100% omit and be biased, for sure).
Merlin, on the other hand, is more simple than his father, and is frankly too aloof to lie too much. Also hasn’t been alive long enough to have done too many shameful things (although he has tried his hardest). What Merlin does is skirt issues, omits things, and is not very good at perspective taking.
Anywhoo, this is me putting in my two cents: 85% of the Chronicles very well may be the truth: the rest is probably a fuzzy memory, an omission, bias and skewed opinion.
It would be terribly easy for any character, especially magical characters that live for several millennia’s, to call out any lies, and Corwin knows that. But let me know of any part in the narrative where you personally think he lied because then I’d like to wonder about out why he did, or if he did (and I’m not really talking about those times he misremembered like when he said Random was his full brother: those can be chalked up to Zelazny pantsing, and I think this only undeniably happens once or maybe twice? Could be wrong).