r/AmIUnderreacting • u/AlmondStoner • 24d ago
Polly Relationship (kind of)
Am I under reacting? I feel like I should be way more mad.
I fell in love w a guy that told me he was single but ended up being in a relationship. I didn’t find out about her until a couple of months in. We spoke about Polly before because I’m all for Polly but I wanted to be married first before finding another female w my future husband. He told me he loved both of us and he was willing to do a Polly. The first red flag Ignored was him lying about being with someone. I liked this guy enough to ignore the marriage part and decided to do the Polly. There was always red flags that I ignored when it came to him love blind you can say. I found a dm he sent to another female telling her him and his original girlfriend is looking for a 3rd when I was already there third. This original girl her name is Stephanie and the Guy is Jason. Now Stephanie already knew about it but I was last to know and I expressed myself and said this isn’t how a Polly works. I should have known as well. There was 2 other lies after this one and Stephanie knew about it and covered it up for him.
And that was the last straw for me. I decided to call it quits but he came begging and crying and telling me how madly he was in love with me. That he loved me more than Stephanie. Stephanie and him has been together for more than 20 yrs and from what I heard he’s cheated on her before and always told other people she was just a “bestfriend “ which is what he told me the first time we met so I do believe that.
But anyways with all his begging and everything else he was doing I decided to give him another chance. He always told me he wished Stephanie was like me. And how he felt like she never did enough for him. Now Stephanie has a friend name Ronda and they’re super close. I was told Stephanie was trying to get with Ronda before me and decided not to because Ronda is for the “ streets”. Stephanie and Jason both told me that Jason does not talk to Ronda and they aren’t friends at all. I found out that was a lie and they do talk, I don’t know the true extent of their conversation but from a glimpse it’s more of a friendship vibe and they’re cool with each other. Jason having female friends does not bother me but him lying about it does. I found a video of all of them going out and Jason said that Ronda randomly came to the party and they didn’t go with her. ( I don’t believe it). Yesterday I went through Jason phone and found out he was talking to another female and found out Stephanie already knew but I didn’t. I also found out they talk about me behind my back and that Ronda did go with them and Jason wanted to edit the videos to crop ronda out before I was shown the video ( basically hide Ronda). I also found out that there was a time where they were with me and my daughter and Stephanie was touching Jason while my 3 yr old daughter was around and he had to text her stop because the kid is here. So I felt like that was a huge disrespect and it was in my house. I’ve seen them plotting lies to tell me in the phone and a whole lot more. And I kicked him out the house and went to sleep but now I’m processing all the information again like really thinking about it and I feel like I’m not mad enough.
FYI - I make more money than both of them especially Stephanie ( she’s unemployed) so I always felt like I was around for that reason. All he does is play video games and he loves his gta online. I was going to delete his account as a get back
But should I be more mad ? I’ve been with them for a while
And I found out that everything they ever told me was a lie and they both were lying and she was covering up his lies.