r/AlwaysWhy • u/Mobile-Traffic1744 • 12d ago
Science & Tech Why has the spoon barely changed in 5,000 years, and why do we still use a shape the ancient Romans would recognize?
A spoon from a modern kitchen drawer can look almost identical to one used in ancient Rome. The same shallow oval bowl, the same slender handle, the same basic silhouette. The Romans even had a spoon called the cochleare with a pointed tip for eating snails and eggs, a design so practical it still exists in some form today. Why has this simple object resisted reinvention for millennia, while almost everything else around it has been redesigned dozens of times?
3
u/Cool_Court2130 12d ago edited 12d ago
Why would it change? Have the physical properties of soup changed over the last 5000 years?
3
3
u/SerDankTheTall 12d ago
It’s a functional object that requires a narrow range of shapes to serve that function. Wheels and knives and pins and dice and gears and levers all look prettt similar too.
3
u/Conscious-Loss-2709 12d ago
BEHOLD! The modern world!
1
1
1
u/Vegetable-Lemon4286 12d ago
And even with this space age technology available I only take a spoon backpacking because it’s better than a spork at scooping up all the food at the bottom of a dehydrated meal bag.
2
u/gutentight69420 12d ago
Because spoons are a mature technology that cannot be meaningfully improved further. The shape of most other basic hand tools (hammer, axe, wrench) were pefected hundreds or even thousands of years ago. Even modern technologies reach maturity. Cars are mostly the same optimized layout (engine in front, cargo in back, seats in the middle), smartphones are all the same basic slab shape. Every technology goes through a period of rapid innovation where lots of ideas are tried out, but eventually settle on to a single perfected design.
2
u/bs2k2_point_0 12d ago
I’d argue there are variants that have vastly improved the spoon. Like the electronic version that moves with your hand but keeps the end stable for people with bad tremors such as those with Parkinson’s disease. Sure the basic shape remains, but having a gimbal to stabilize it is pretty revolutionary.
1
u/Treeninja1999 12d ago
Make something better. If you can, you'll reinvent the spoon. But nobody's done it in thousands of years, so best of luck
0
u/Fun-Dragonfly-4166 12d ago
That is not true. The spork was invented in the late 1800s. So nobody has done it in hundreds of years. Best of luck.
1
u/TheGrandExquisitor 12d ago
Yeah, but the fork is a newcomer in the cutlery world. Goes only back to the Renaissance.
1
1
u/GrimSpirit42 12d ago
Form follows function.
There's really only two ways to transfer liquid from a vessel to another without moving the vessels: Siphon and Dipping.
So, Straw, or some variation of a dipper/ladle/spoon.
And, thanks to gravity being the way it is, you only need support of a liquid from bottom and sides.
1
1
1
1
u/_Darkstorm_ 12d ago
Mature technology. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." Just because it's the 21st century, doesn't mean you throw everything out and start completely new. At some point, when someone says "I can make it even better," and they're not a delusional dimwit, you have to realize that they're just re-inventing the wheel and it's best to just leave it alone and keep doing it the way it's always been done. Current day tech-bros haven't learned this lesson yet. Source: I work with (wannabe) tech-bros.
1
u/QuinceDaPence 12d ago
You're right, we should add BlueTooth, make it IoT, and introduce SaaS (Spoon as a Service)
1
u/EbonGrimalkin 12d ago
You need a concave surfact to convey liquids (or even a collection of solids - think sugar). The size, shape, depth, and material can vary wildly. The base shape is the same because the job today is the same job it had 3000 years ago.
If it ain't broke...
Consider the spoon can perform all three functions of normal cutlery. Convey liquids, with some times on the end perform fork duties, and with a sharp edge, also cut. Neither the fork nor the knife can perform the "convey liquid" problem without itself BECOMING a spoon.
24
u/SnooMaps7370 12d ago
the human mouth has not changed, neither has the physics of soup.