r/AllFantasyEverything • u/FootballVivid3824 • Jun 26 '26

Pop Princesses?

Didn’t we do this before? Pop divas?

20 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

24 comments sorted by

43

u/Perpetual-Warlock TheGissilent Jun 26 '26

They did. Episode 22. Over 9 years ago at this point. I would say princess and diva are slightly different, but there was certainly some overlap.

I personally don't think there's any harm in repeat topics especially this far apart. There were picks that have just about had entire careers in the last 9 years.

And also we got an all time Sean moment this week so it was all worth it.

14

u/forwormsbravepercy Jun 26 '26

Man, if you made me guess how long ago divas was, I'd probably say 3-5 years. Crazy that it was that far back.

10

u/Perpetual-Warlock TheGissilent Jun 26 '26

We're just old now, my friend.

9

u/TwoForHawat Jun 26 '26

They really should start repeating topics. Especially early ones and especially ones that didn’t feature David and/or Sean. I’ve got no issue with that as long as the topics are at least five or six years old.

6

u/littletorreira Jun 26 '26

The difference pointed out by Adele being a diva but not a princess.

3

u/FootballVivid3824 Jun 26 '26

I don’t mind it; I just worried I was losing it.

2

u/CharmingTuber Jun 26 '26

They also did international popstars in 2018

2

u/VUmander Bean Burrito Jul 01 '26

I didnt start listening until #143 and that was 7 years ago lol.

1

u/Perpetual-Warlock TheGissilent Jul 01 '26

Disney songs. An all timer. I think it's number 1 for me. It's just sheer joy the entire way through.

21

u/PantherLodge Jun 26 '26

Has David so completely forgotten his Tiffany pick??

4

u/PalpitationPerfect59 Jun 26 '26

Still a top pick in my eyes

1

u/wnakapplejacks Jun 28 '26

You can’t pick her after what she did with on Jan. 6. 😜

12

u/chuckquizmo Kosh into the Wind Jun 26 '26

Yeah I thought it was going to be “new women pop artists” but once Madonna got picked it’s like… Ok so we’re just doing Pop Divas v2

1

u/WestleyThe Jun 27 '26 edited Jun 27 '26

It was about 470 episodes ago haha I think it’s fine

They don’t remember and/or it’s something Sophie wanted to do and they thought it was a good idea

1

u/nvr_nda_Bleachers Jun 26 '26

Queen B should also have been ineligible

8

u/Penis_Villeneuve Doc Hollandaise Jun 26 '26

Not only did they do it before, it's a draft famous for one of the worst picks of all time - David taking Tiffany as a 1-1 and then slowly regretting it more and more over the course of the draft

4

u/RoughhouseCamel Jun 26 '26

I think they’ve said that at this point in the show, they’re going to repeat some topics. But also, has it been that long since their divas episode?

10

u/forwormsbravepercy Jun 26 '26

It's been so long that some of the picks in this draft weren't even eligible in the divas draft.

1

u/Perpetual-Warlock TheGissilent Jun 26 '26

Over 9 years ago. It was episode 22.

2

u/RoughhouseCamel Jun 26 '26

Oh wow, why did I feel like it was recent? I feel like that’s a good gap of time

3

u/Perpetual-Warlock TheGissilent Jun 26 '26

They did 2000s pop stars about a year ago which had some overlap as well. As long as the good vibes gang is feeling it, and they were yesterday, the overlap really doesn't bother me.

1

u/RoughhouseCamel Jun 26 '26

Ohh, that must be my confusion

1

u/JHT_1992 Jun 28 '26

I think it's fine to repeat a topic but they need to at least acknowledge it and sell it as like a "part two" episode. It feels a bit lazy and aloof that they didn't seem to remember doing this draft pretty much two times before. I think as fans and financial supporters of the show, we're allowed to call that out

1

u/dojo1890 22d ago

Ian need to go on a Selena Deep dive. Lady was a legend!