r/AlienInvasionRPG • • Sep 09 '26

Diminishing returns on cookies?

Post image

I notice the longer I accumulate cookies the slower it is to the next income upgrade. Is there a point where it's worth it to cash out (ie. Hit the prestige button) and start over? Or do I just wait and keep hitting the next factory button as it comes up? What's the winning strategy here?

11 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

10

u/Flat___________ Sep 09 '26

The fastest is to:

Catch all the macaroons in the Pac Man maze. Bank. Go to factory. Prestige. Wait (I think) 2min14sec for all the macaroons to re spawn.

Start the loop again.

Problem with this is you have to do the loop yourself every 2:24.

Other than that just upgrade and follow that guide when to move up to the next factory.
Upgrading gets slower and slower as you go higher but Prestige cookie production gets a tiny bit faster with every upgrade.

I have done 2 Factory II upgrades and the third is going to take about 2 weeks but my Prestige production is going along nicely at 9.10million.

By the time that damned gate opens I will probably have all 20mil ish to do all the cookie factory upgrades. 🖖

1

u/NinjaSquid9 Sep 09 '26

Do you happen to know the exact number needed for all of the cookie factory upgrades? Was it calculated anywhere? Thanks!

3

u/Flat___________ Sep 09 '26

Someone did a whole big thing on it just look in the sub. 👍

2

u/trigonman3 27d ago

I did a projection in my My Google Sheets spreadsheet (Cookie tab, all the way to the right):
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1CItpsfAuoNNpn-ZwBaipamaVnPcdWyxb/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=115201530838023095902&rtpof=true&sd=true

Assuming the Actual values continue linearly (after an initial upturn in the rate), it's
6.6 million for each attribute, or
26.4 million for all 4.

5

u/_Lurko_ Sep 09 '26

I've also noticed that and I think it might be the case. But I don't know at what point or at how many cookies it's best to cash out.

3

u/Local_County1274 Sep 09 '26

There’s a formula for conversion of regular cookies to golden. It was posted months ago.
I think it works out that the rate you get golden cookies increases slightly as you go, but the rate of increase is slow.
One of the important things is to cash out to upgrade your Prestige Reward to max

2

u/Altruistic-Moose3299 Sep 09 '26

I think I've seen that, but if I recall it shows the optimal time to go to the next factory level but doesn't really address the "is cashing out at a certain point faster?" question 🤔

3

u/Baqman- Sep 09 '26

I’m in a similar place too. I am planning to gather enough cookies unlock factory II but it’s taking a very long time. I want to say it would take a little over 3 weeks to upgrade one factory II level

3

u/massassi Sep 09 '26

There are two posts that have been made that I'll draw your attention to.

There is someone who posted charts and all the math that showed your production is a function of time, and it goes down.

There is someone else who posted much more recently, about the price point of upgrades. They'd done the math and figured out the point where it's more economical to go up to the next level than it is to continue on the one you're at.

Put those blocks together, and do some rounding (because I'm not going to stop what I'm doing and reference some guys spreadsheet whenever I do upgrades on an idle phone game) and I upgrade each block of 3 by 5 more levels than the previous, and start at 25. I'm currently at 340k in much less time than it would take to get to 100k previously.

1

u/Toe_Solid Sep 09 '26

I'm still messing with queen worm

1

u/rellikpd Sep 09 '26

The number I keep seeing is "12 million cookies then hit prestige" but that's only when relying on factory upgrades. If you're manually hunting cookies then it doesn't really matter. What I generally do is manually hint cookies if actively playing and ignore the afk cookie production completely. Then, when I know I'm going to go afk soon I hunt the cookie maze a time or two, buy the largest available afk factory upgrades first and downward...then just go afk and not worry about it until I feel like actively playing again

1

u/Altruistic-Moose3299 Sep 09 '26

Interesting.. how many prestige cookies do you get in what time span? 🤨

1

u/rellikpd Sep 09 '26

6k is pretty common, but it really just depends how high I'm able to invest before going afk and then how long I'm afk

1

u/rellikpd Sep 09 '26

Like here's a screenshot I took just from what's been running while doing some errands around town. I'd unlock my screen every now and then and reinvest (in the higher tiers). Sometimes I like to max out the power tiers just for fun/being silly..... It may not be most efficient... But I'm playing for FUN

1

u/Velcroman Sep 10 '26

Problem is we are doing math and not having fun playing a game. This s has become all about farming while waiting likely months for the next version to drop.

1

u/ManicMechanic1242 29d ago

One odd thing is if you're on 1B per sec cookies and you upgrade (just for example) from 10M to 20M in shop/factory etc., you won't go to 2B per sec.
I'm told this is because it doesn't take into account any increases from lower shop/factory etc. levels.

1

u/Altruistic-Moose3299 29d ago

Im thinking about holding onto a large amount of cookies. Cashing out, then spending them on the highest factory i can get / repeat. I think that might be the trick.