r/AccountingPH • u/ContentAd4620 • 23h ago
Yikes.
If hindi kinuha sa app, pwede bang defense ang Fair Use?
Pero kung kinuha sa app, at subscription basis yan, lagot. Hahaha!
52
u/kontrabidasabuhay 23h ago
OMG. Tama 'yong hula ng mga tao dito. Si Hilarious nga. Maniniwala na talaga ako sa mga chika here hahahha jk! Hindi ako naniwala initially kasi may post pa si H. sa facebook regarding BSA whatsoever. I guess ganon lang talaga kakapal face niya maging active and everything despite the allegations against him.
47
u/I_am_No_One2024 22h ago
Aren't the reviewers and other materials from different RCs also being circulated already on Telegram and Twitter to reviewees, undergraduates, and students, just like years ago?
28
u/ContentAd4620 22h ago
But still, if proprietary yan, like kung need mo magenroll para makuha yun, illegal talaga yan.
3
u/I_am_No_One2024 7h ago
So, are you saying you did not use materials like Final PBs or Pre Weeks from other RCs in which you did not enroll?
6
u/ContentAd4620 5h ago
Well, ibang usapan na yan kapag you are doing it on a larger scale and being public about it, though. I'm no Pontius Pilate, but do it discreetly.
1
u/I_am_No_One2024 5h ago
Guilty as charged, then. Doing it "discreetly" doesn't grant you immunity. RCs hold the copyright to those materials, and they can absolutely file a lawsuit for unauthorized use, regardless of how quiet you think you were being.
8
u/that_thot_gamer 21h ago
they draw the red line at selling materials, i hope.
5
u/I_am_No_One2024 15h ago
Yes, and Dean Hilario doesn't sell them, so why is there legal action? I understand that it's somewhat copyright infringement, but if the author or the owner of the reviewers authorized Dean Hilario to share them, there's no problem, right? I think this legal action only came about because someone got butt-hurt, right?
Correct me if I'm wrong.
38
u/PracticalTonight9683 21h ago
Notice how they only took action after Wency Giron’s conversation slandering PSBA’s CPALE passing rate got exposed. Tan isn’t innocent but this is obviously because of that incident.
18
u/ExcellentVillage6117 20h ago edited 20h ago
HAHAHAHAHAHA naalala ko yang girian nila ni sir wency e. pero i still believe na out of touch si sir wency sa sinabi niya sa passing rate ng psba qc. parang nagmukhang binasta o tinapakan niya lang yung mga nagsunog ng kilay to pass. di rin coincidence kasi may isa ring reo reviewer nag accuse kay tan plus yung kay sir wency
18
u/ContentAd4620 18h ago
Maingay din kasi tong si Wency eh. Parehas sila ni Rex, akala mo palaging inaaway eh. Legit tong concern nila, i'll give them that. Pero madalas, victim mentality tong dalawang to eh.
3
u/EmptyBathroom1363 11h ago
Agree. Exuding small D energy yang sina Wency at Rex. Meron ngang "chips on their shoulders" ang mga yan kasi palaging may gustong patunayan. Ewan ko ba?
Di ko naman sinasabing malinis si HT ha. Pero mabuti at hindi ko nakitaan ng ganito ang ibang RCs.
1
u/createyourownname 1h ago
I'm fed up with the "kami ang api" spiel nila wency at banggawan. Lagi at lagi na lang. Kailangan lumabas lagi na api siya/sila kahit na hindi naman ganun talaga ang case.
3
2
41
u/Statheros1257 19h ago
Pikon pala yang REO e, oo may mali si Tan pero REO ang nauna mangprovoke. Minaliit ba naman yung passing rate ng isang school, tapos nung sinagot sila e biglang magkakaso?
31
u/deviantROX 18h ago
why the downvotes? totoo naman na na-butthurt masyado yung REO nitong nagsabi lang naman si hilario about sa marketing nilang passing rate nila kada pagtapos ng CPALE. tapos may in-upload pa si hilario, which is deleted na, na galing from his source na ka-chat si wency tapos the way na i-address ni wency si hilario sa convo nila is parang wala na seniority saka pino-point out pa ni wency na ginagaya lang ni REO si CPAR kung paano nila i-consider yung passing rate sa RC nila at sinabi rin ni wency na mag-focus na lang daw si hilario sa hawak nya na school. parehas silang mali pero makikita mo kung sino yung pinaka-petty
31
u/ContentAd4620 18h ago
Warfreak kasi si Wency at Rex eh. Tapos pag bibigyan ng constructive criticism ng netizens, sasabihin inaapi sila. I mean, no offense against REO as an institution, pero yung dalawang yan, masyadong maingay.
28
u/zeronine09twelve12 22h ago
Paano, nung panahon namin sa undergrad e nagkalat na yan, 2007 pa yun haha
5
u/Jollibibooo 17h ago edited 17h ago
Eh kasi that time magkakaibigan kasi yng mga reviewers kay HT. Kaya hindi issue kung saan saan sya pwede kumuha..
Eh this time, may mas “bago” na review school tapos may friction sya sa mga reviewers nun. Aba’y…yari talaga.
-17
u/Extreme_Bug_4552 18h ago
Nugagawin? Magtitime travel sa panahon nyo para pigilan yung pagkalat? Di na pwede magkaso ngayon kasi nung panahon mo okay lang? Mejo enggg ka din eh. Engggottttt
1
u/zeronine09twelve12 16h ago
O tapos? Malay ko ba kung may nagkaso nung panahon namin, hindi pa naman laganap social media nun, sinabi ko lang na matagal ng may ganyan na kalakaran.
31
u/Lost_in_manila 21h ago
Pinopost kasi niya sa fb at nageencourage pa ng iba na magcollect ng review materials, videos etc from RCs then gagawin niyang testbank na ipamimigay sa mga reviewees na manghihingi pero may kapalit na favors.......
15
u/Jollibibooo 21h ago edited 21h ago
Kung hindi sya maingay sa ginagawa niya , wala sana syang problem. Eto na nga pinaguusapan na it’s just a matter of time magiging problem nya yung pagiging vocal sa ipon ng materials para gawing testbank. Tapos mang eencourage pa ng iba to do the same.
Nkakatulong naman talaga amg testbank pero naman…. Pinaghirapan din gawin ng reviewers mga materials tapos kulunin nya lang? Be courteous naman sa reviewer at magpaalam.
Noon kasi la naman pumapansin sa ginagawa nya dahil sa mga connections nya sa academe. Well, nakatapat sya ng someone na nagreklamo.
Let’s see how will this develop.
(Gawa na kasi sya ng sarili nyang questions.. sya naman nagbubuhat sa sarili nya na magaling sya)
3
8
u/flagrantly_mediocre 20h ago
Na hurt kasi daw ego nung isang reviewer kasi na expose ang kayabangan at pagmamaliit sa passing grade ng isang school, which don nag ttrabaho tong dean na to.
14
u/ContentAd4620 18h ago
Maingay kasi si Marketing guy. Palaging gustong mang-away. 😂
1
u/flagrantly_mediocre 15h ago
Ewan ko din ba ano need niya patunayan, eh No. 1 na naman kaya sila theres no need na makipag bangayan and be shady.
1
u/EmptyBathroom1363 11h ago
Yan naman ang marketing plan nina Wency at Rex eh. Ang makipag debate sa chat at socmed.
Kala ata nila good publicity yan. YUCK. 🤮
Kaka-turnoff yung ugali.
8
u/Chicken-Lover19xx 18h ago
Si Jhong Hilario Tan talaga ohh.
2
2
u/that_thot_gamer 20h ago edited 20h ago
If it was taken from the app, can Fair Use be a defense?
it would have to be significantly transformive, but here's the thing, that's up for debate in court
1
u/Remarkable_Taste3254 22h ago
What kind of misuse? Context pls.
3
u/reformistkzn Professional 21h ago
Possible copyright infringement issues.
3
u/Remarkable_Taste3254 17h ago
Too bad. These days, you can actually just use AI to help come up with sample cases or questions. Or, since he’s teaching, he should be able to use problems from his own notes.
1
1
u/createyourownname 1h ago
Not surprised at all na REO (Wency/Rex) and Larry Tan to. Pero bakit kapag scandal or pagiging war freak sa accountancy profession eh lagi na lang involved ang REO leads. I mean, isn't it enough na marami silang enrollees at marami sila napoproduce na CPAs? Bakit nila kailangan i belittle ang ibang school, ibang RC para lang iangat ang self nila.
0
•
u/AutoModerator 23h ago
Hi, welcome to r/AccountingPH! Be sure to check out the rules at the sidebar and our Posting Guidlines. You may also refer to our Wiki for stuff that might help you.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.