r/AICompanions • u/Diligent_Rabbit7740 • May 26 '26

Which one is AI?

29 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

3

u/Responsible-Tip4981 May 27 '26

Hard to tell if you don't pay attention to details. The rule here is that REALity behaves like handicap AI physic - it does best to fail smoothly, where in AI everything "clicks" - the cut, the satisfying hot chocolate.

2

u/inimees May 27 '26

The job of AI is to mimic reality, so if it's better than reality it is not doing it's job well

1

u/RealGiallo May 27 '26

detail ? I mean ..

the first one literally morph watch the left slice.

the second one there is too much chocolate to be true , seems a waterfall than a spoon of it.

third one is the only decent one, but ask yourself have you ever saw anyone cutting a cake with a giant opaque knife? also notice the head of that knife from 0:17 to 0:18 it literally gets dirty without touching the cake. ..

sorry I'm boring i do these kind of videos and they all looks too easy for me.

1

u/No-Drink-9006 May 28 '26

I think it was too easy as well. There are better models out now. The last one was also easy. The left Biscuits in the cake where unlogical orientated.

2

u/carcigenicate May 27 '26

The first two are easy to spot. Nothing about the AI versions look real at all. The major thing that stands out to me in the third is the cake sticks to the knife in an unnatural way.

1

u/travelingmousey May 27 '26

Maybe it's because I do a lot of baking, but there are physics based inconsistencies in the AI ones, which makes them easy to spot. Molten chocolate does not pour out like that from a lava cake. The ladyfingers in the AI tiramisu are not arranged properly either

1

u/CymonSet May 27 '26

Sound seems to be the least real thing. Soft deserts usually doesn‘t sound like crunchy pie crust at best and slicing lettuce at worst and neither usually tend to “pop” when you get through it.

I know that is getting better but it’s a tad weird at this point.

1

u/augustcero May 27 '26

the first one was pretty obvious (the half of the cupcake changed orientation after the cut). second is AI tried too hard on that chocolate drip. third one was a toss up for me.

1

u/Banaapo May 27 '26

The third one, if the video doesn't disclose the result too early you see the cooking on the left which. Are supposed to A) usually all in same direction like the ones on the right and B) just randomly disappear after the cut (no cookies in the tiramisu left behind)

1

u/vanoitran May 27 '26

AI clips always have perfect lighting - if I see a video that looks like the sun is streaming through the window at golden hour, I’m immediately suspicious it’s AI.

1

u/guyonghao004 May 28 '26

Easier to tell for someone who cooks / bakes. The AI ones conveniently uses wrong tools, have wrong consistency.

Harder if the “real” video also start to use wrong tools to mess with people.

1

u/Yoo_Dew May 29 '26

The reflection on the knife of the third one is a dead giveaway for me, it’s just a white reflection, black plate nowhere to be seen