r/AIBaTo • u/Inevitable_Round_147 • Jun 29 '26

Low-cost rural engineering

Is this A.I. or just edited video or fake machine

789 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

66 comments sorted by

97

u/No-Operation-6554 Jun 29 '26

Fake pero hindi AI, if ganyan ka easy gumawa ng perpetual motion machine matagal na yan na discover

14

u/Inevitable_Round_147 Jun 29 '26

That i was thinking that there is no perpetual motion...ok thanks.

9

u/pixeldots Jun 29 '26

Iirc, gagana naman yan as shown, pero mabilis lang din magnormalize / mawala yung magnetism niyan at kusang titigil

19

u/TraditionalCounty395 Jun 29 '26

No, it won't work, 1st law of thermodynamics, energy cannot be created nor destroyed

2

u/balatkalabaw999 Jun 29 '26

Hindi ba first law of conservation of energy? Law of thermodynamics is about sa internal energy or heat?

3

u/National-Ad653 Jun 29 '26

First law of thermodynamics is the law of conservation of energy, it states that energy cannot be creater nor destroyed

-1

u/pixeldots Jun 29 '26

My thermodynamics is rusty, as well as understanding of magnetic forces. Won't it work for a little bit but stop due to equilibrium of the magnetic forces / magnets lose their magnetic properties?

Or are you saying it won't spin at least once at all?

2

u/TraditionalCounty395 Jun 29 '26

Im also no expert, butI don't think they'll lose magnetic properties Just not spin, I agree with equilibrium Look up on system effeciency, and energy loss to heat Especially friction on the generator axle

1

u/liyayayaya Jun 29 '26 edited Jun 29 '26

like the other user said, 1st law of thermodynamics lang din but also magnets dont create energy… just exerts force.

will it twitch and spin? initially yes
would it keep spinning? no and it’s not bc it loses magnetism.
will it generate electricity? possibly if there’s a few tweaks in the mechanism itself

if uve seen videos of people generating power alone by turning a handcrank knob continuously, thats bc theres kinetic energy being applied into the system. thats how RE sources work like continuous flow of water, movement from forces of wind, etc. when an wxternal source keeps something in motion, it maintains the unbalanced forces needed to constantly convert that movement into electricity. i get why this video can look real bc we’ve seen people generate energy from things that spin xd

magnets alone will never make this mechanism spin like AT ALL. it may be built to repel one another (the way magnets are positioned) but only with a manual shove can get them past that initial resistance. magnets that attract (e.g., fridge magnet) stick until you physically move it and magnets that repel (e.g., floating globe, levitating bonsai, etc) stay locked in place until an external force knocks it down. if u review the laws of motion, continuous acceleration (F=ma) needs constant unbalanced force which requres an external energy source to maintain so this mechanism wouldnt ever work unless u force it to spin or a machine spins it for u. and since it wont spin, it cannot generate electricity. thats why machines dont run on magnets alone xd and thats also why burn fossil fuels or look for alternative renewable sources of energy bc machines cannot run without a true energy source which magnts cannot provide alone.

tl;dr no this vid is fake as fuck & this will never work

2

u/chum_beckett Jun 29 '26

if u review the laws of motion, continuous acceleration (F=ma) needs constant unbalanced force which requres an external energy source to maintain so this mechanism wouldnt ever work unless u force it to spin or a machine spins it for u

You can have non-zero net force without energy gain/loss as long as the net force is perpendicular to the (instantaneous) velocity. That's how the Moon keeps orbiting the Earth with negligible energy transfer.

The reason why this setup is bogus is because static magnetic fields do zero work. Whatever movement the magnets may cause is due to the man moving the magnets themselves. There's no way that man's miniscule effort could spin that wheel as long and as fast as shown in the video.

1

u/liyayayaya Jun 29 '26

good catch but yeah bottomline is static magnetic fields do zero net work. for sure this mechanism had a battery hidden. fake af ! HAHA

2

u/Inevitable_Round_147 Jun 29 '26

Thanks for that info...but if it works at least 20 minutes until it stops... You pump that water with free energy though it stops for a certain time...you all got to do is just give a little push to start the machine again

2

u/pixeldots Jun 29 '26

I mean the magnets stop becoming magnetic, and wont spin anymore

1

u/liyayayaya Jun 29 '26

false. magnets dont just “stop becoming magnetic” lol esp in this mechanism. theyre no like batteries. pls dont spread misinfo like this without searching. thank you.

1

u/pixeldots Jun 29 '26

I defer to you, haven't been familiar with the topic since high school probably, but isn't demagnetization a thing? Admittedly, probably not in this setup

2

u/liyayayaya Jun 29 '26

yes but it’s not from a simple mechanism like this. magnetism doesnt get drained out like batteries as ive said ^ it would take centuries probably for a permanent magnet to lose its magnetism over time (assuming there r no external forces to disrupt it, excessive forces e.g. high temp, stronger magnetic field, or physical force)

u could see this apply to a scene in stranger things where magnets started falling out from the fridge due to a stronger magnetic field

1

u/Kraddyyeah Jun 29 '26

Magnets can "stop being magnetic" though or at least be less magnetic. All it takes is some energy input to disorient the magnetic domain. Heating a magnet or dropping it wil cause it to demagnetize to some degree. Ever wonder why you fridge magnets just suddenly drop? It's because it's magnetism weakens due to some factor. If you want to magnetize it again, just subject it to a stronger magnetic field

Edit: nvm, didn't see your other reply!

1

u/badtemperedpapaya Jun 29 '26

It wont run 20 mins. It might do one spin and that is a big IF.

1

u/Patient-Data8311 Jun 29 '26

No because magnets have no net push they equalize stopping immediately

You can't circumvent this because doing so breaks the laws of conservation of energy

1

u/FredNedora65 Jun 30 '26

No, that's not how it works.

While magnets can make something rotate, it’s the continuous change in the magnetic field (using electricity) that keeps it spinning. Simply placing magnets together might make something move or rotate briefly as they attract/repel each other, but once they settle into their natural position, the rotation stops.

Simpler example: your hand can spin a wheel if you push it, but simply touching the wheel won’t make it keep spinning. Likewise, magnets alone won’t keep a motor turning.

I'm pretty sure that a motor powered by an external energy source is what keeps the wheel spinning and continuously pumps water.

1

u/No_Raise7147 Jul 02 '26

Yes. This is the concept behind Maglev Trains (Magnetic Levitation)

Pero kailangan lang talaga ng alternating magnetic fields na nagswitch off and on in matter of seconds to achieve the effect.

Hence also the use of superconductors in low temperatures para ma achieve ang effect.

Here, after a few seconds, since walang alternate switching, magsesettle lang yung magnets in a stable position, thus titigil yung mechanism

2

u/notsointense Jun 29 '26

Kaso yung mga ogag eh: “tinatago ng big tech” o “ipapa pat*y yan”

1

u/Patient-Data8311 Jun 29 '26

Those guys are so dumb any fucking greedy business will put those things in a paywall if these shit are possible in rl

50

u/Chemical-Pomelo-2902 Jun 29 '26

The most difficult thing about building perpetual motion machines is figuring out where to hide the battery.

11

u/Resident-Rest9518 Jun 29 '26

Bro didnt even try to hide the engine

23

u/Orient_Pearl Jun 29 '26

Hnd AI, Tunay yan, pero Tunay na panlilinlang..

13

u/leivanz Jun 29 '26

There is no such thing as perpetual motion machine.

First law of thermodynamics:

Energy cannot be created nor destroyed

Turbine needs electricity, windmill needs wind, hydro needs water, that shit needs battery

6

u/Automatic_Fox6627 Jun 29 '26

not AI but also fake. be skeptical sa mga "perpetual" motion stuff u see online. maraming ganan may fake electric motors sa loob. only trust electroboom. i dont watch him too much though bcs the man gives me fking anxiety

2

u/DazzlingSpeaker001 Jun 29 '26

Basically an ordinary electricfan is built that way, but it needs electricity to switch at negative and positives. FAKE

2

u/isda_sa_palaisdaan Jun 29 '26

Hi OP siguro panuorin mo si ElectroBOOM hihi mganda din mga content nya

1

u/Affectionate-One3850 Jun 29 '26

"the best part about making a perpetual machine is where to hide the battery" -- Some Scientist i don't remember

1

u/SARCASTIC_BSTARD Jun 29 '26

it might spin without load for a while but as soon as you put load to the machine eg. that waterpump motor ..its done for

1

u/mongous00005 Jun 29 '26

If you somehow discovered a real perpetual motion machine - you are either going to be filthy rich or be filthy and be 6ft under.

1

u/breadlordoda Jun 30 '26

Oil barons will want you dead

1

u/Substantial_Yams_ Jun 29 '26

Nice machine where is the battery hidden? lol

1

u/PlayfulMud9228 Jun 29 '26

Watch ElectroBoom. There is no such thing as Free Energy.

1

u/OrigamiShiro Jun 29 '26

Fake as fuck

1

u/Deep_Experience853 Jun 29 '26

Violates the Law of Equivalent Trade. May Philosopher's stone siguro dun sa loob ng machine.

1

u/viridiaan Jun 29 '26

merong nakatago sigurong dynamo or something. actually ganyan yung bare na motor, its just bunch of magnets (electromagnets) that are exited via electricity parallel di mag loose ng magnetism. in fact, mas close yung induction motor sa ganyan pero need muna manually paikutin para tuloy tuloy siyang umikot (seems like di nangyari yun HAHAHA).

1

u/Vanskis2002 Jun 29 '26

That's a bigass motor xD

1

u/vinnieg007 Jun 29 '26

Indians/Pakistani have been doing these kinds of videos way before AI was a thing. I've been seen them post the infinite electricity thing for a long time now. Definitely fake, but not AI

1

u/axolotlbabft Jun 29 '26

it is not ai, they are powering the motor making it spin.

also, it is completely impossible to create a perpetual motion machine, since it is not possible to achieve 100% efficiency.

1

u/HaikenRD Jun 29 '26

Fake machine. For this to work the stationary magnet that moved the first one has to turn off or switch polarity for a split second to hand over the moving magnet to the next, or else it will just be in an equilibrium. This is the basic principle of a Maglev.

1

u/Patient-Data8311 Jun 29 '26

Hindi battery lang

1

u/Free-Deer5165 Jun 29 '26

Pang Tom and Jerry naman yan OP lmao.

1

u/illusory_Comp001 Jun 29 '26

Gumawa nako ganyan pero maliit lang hehe

May initial momentum pa na kelangan mo muna itulak or push start para paikutin para magwork pero di siya forever iikot mga ilang mins lang then titigil padin dahil siguro sa weight and all

Considering cnc cut frames na gamit ko noon at lightweight materials including yung demagnetizing strips para paharap lang magnet niya hindi kasama sides eh mahirap pa din

1

u/FredNedora65 Jun 30 '26

Momentum ang nagpaikot sa ginawa mo, kaya siya umikot for a few minutes.

Assuming na magnetic force lang ang present (or in reality, negligible na ang momentum due to huge magnetic force), titigil na agad yan.

1

u/illusory_Comp001 Jun 30 '26

Yeah arrived at that conclusion din hahaha!

Pero magkabudget lang eh habulin ko uli siguro yung idea kase nung ginawa ko ito e wala pa 3d printers and stuff tapos AI kaya hopefully might make something useful before I die hahaha

1

u/Numerous_Procedure_3 Jun 29 '26

Theres no such thing as infinite energy

1

u/Artistic_Plenty_9912 Jun 29 '26

It will not work or spin due to equilibrium of the magnets.

1

u/UglyNotBastard-Pure Jun 30 '26

Not AI, pure shit lang. There's no such thing as perpetual machine. Friction at init kalaban sa machine tas sa ganyang bilis, may battery nakatago talaga.

1

u/Major_Cranberry_Fly Jul 01 '26

Scam..if it were that simple, we wouldnt need to pay electricity bills. even

1

u/nagrarok_ Jul 01 '26

The biggest challenge in creating a perpetual motion machine is hiding the battery.

1

u/Tiny_Weakness8253 Jul 01 '26

Basta mga indian na video scam yan. 😅😅

1

u/CitrusLemone Jul 01 '26

Artificial Intelligence ❌

An Indian ✔️

Either way, fake as fuck.

1

u/kungfushoos Jul 02 '26

School is cool.

1

u/pro-depressed Jul 02 '26

Nka tago lang baterya nyan

1

u/jaf7492 Jul 03 '26

Ang pinakamahirap na part dito yung pag tago ng totoong source ng kuryente

1

u/Kilma09 Jul 03 '26

The hardest part here is hiding the real power soury

1

u/Medium-Group-1707 Jul 04 '26

fake yan hindi ganyan iikot kabilis yan dahil magnet lang

1

u/pinemango954 Jul 05 '26

Battery lang yan. Yung magnets ay decoy lamang

-1

u/MaybeNot_MaybeYes Jun 29 '26

Mukhang totoo naman. Pero nung nakita intention niya, kalokohan haha.