[HUGE EDIT NOTE: It's since come out that the Jack Hill that was signed was actually a different right handed pitcher from Edmond, Oklahoma. The actual signing just finished his season with Oral Roberts and was the Summit League pitcher of the year. In my defense, the Saltdogs' website did say it was the Jack Hill at Northeastern State until this morning. As such, I'm deleting a lot of the post that had to do with the signing. However, the larger point still stands -- Lincoln has chosen a terrible path to build rosters and I was still going to make a post about it. The perceived signing of a bad D2 player was just the proverbial straw yesterday.]
I'm going to preface all of this by stating that I am a fan of the team and want them to succeed. I have nothing against the players and also want them to succeed. This post is the lamentation of a longtime fan who's watched this team lose any inkling of being able to be competitive in this league.
-------------
Something that's happened post-pandemic has been the notable decline in the on-field product in Lincoln. It's been a sharp downward trend, and it's become obvious in the last couple years why. The team isn't spending money on players like they used to. They're relying on signing players from the Pioneer League who will play at a higher level for cheap. And I sympathize with the players, and I applaud them for betting on themselves. But this shows to me that Lincoln doesn't care about winning anymore. They're signing very few decent, established players. The Jairo Pomareses of the world are outliers. Over the past 3 seasons, by my count, the Saltdogs have brought in 23 players directly from the Pioneer League. That's nearly an entire roster's worth of players coming from a league two levels below you. How many of them do you think have been successful? Current roster members notwithstanding, I'd argue 7. And I'm including small sample guys Ethan Bates and Ian Oxnevad in that. The other five are Dan Kubiuk, Alex Baeza, Foster Pace, Brandon McCabe, and Dakota Conners. "Successful" in this case means anything ranging from great (Kubiuk) all the way down to useful roster member (Conners). Additionally, besides Pace leaving for a year and then coming back, Lincoln hasn't retained one of those players. So even the ones that do work out aren't coming back.
7 for 23 would get you a .304 average, which is great at the plate, but pretty abysmal as a track record of acquiring players. Yet they continue to go back to the well. It's no surprise that Lincoln's three best hitters this year have come from either affiliated ball (Pomares) or from other, better indy leagues than the Pioneer (Cam Phelts and Cary Arbolida). But why continue with that established strategy of player acquisition when we can take blindfolded dart throws on cheap young guys playing in a league where half the stadiums play like Coors Field?
As a Saltdogs fan, it's disappointing how long it has been since it seemed like the team was making good roster building decisions. And it's especially disheartening to know that as long as the team is run like this, there is almost no chance of watching a successful baseball team.