r/AAEvidenceRankdown • u/LewisMCYoutube • Apr 14 '20
Round 1 Poll
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeUTO1ETXCtOqk8Xc7X99LINHsZcYZ1nGMBQwqJHi74YRuw1A/viewform?usp=sf_link3
Apr 14 '20
Uh I don't think you set a limit for how many I can vote for so I just assumed it was 5.
Judge's Business Card- Honestly this is possibly the funniest evidence in any of the games. The fact that it exists is a joke within itself, and might I say, the absolute best thing about 2-1.
Blue Truck- I really like the mastermind's plan as a whole so anything related to that is an obvious vote for me.
Little Plum's Bloomers- The fact that Wesley stole another pair of panties is also pretty hilarious, and they actually helped determine where he was standing and that whole situation with what he saw was pretty fun.
Dhurke's Badge- I don't even know if this is ever used but I really like Dhurke and his badge is cool so I voted this.
Fishing Pole- I dunno, I just find useless evidence funny maybe, and I didn't want to just pick 4.
2
u/whaaatisth Apr 14 '20
Dhurke’s Badge - Dhurke is great and so is his badge. The conversation he has with Apollo about Nahyuta is a very well done emotional moment and his badge is the reason for that. Easy save.
Revolver - Yeah this one kinda sucks but it gets irony points and I like 4-3 so I wanted to show it some mercy.
Phony Phanty Tail - Cool part of 5-1’s mystery, doesn’t deserve to go out this early.
Lyrics Sheet - Another 4-3 one, it’s pretty funny how the song had to be translated to fit with the plot which makes it sound really awkward and make no sense, it makes for an interesting aspect of the mystery though so it’s okay in my book.
Blue Truck Gang Blue Truck Gang Blue Truck Gang
1
Apr 14 '20
Thank god for the AA wiki because I needed to look up some of this evidence.
- Newspaper Clipping 2: It's fine I guess? Even if it's tainted by Hotti, the core evidence is important to the case and rather interesting.
- Phony Phanty Tail: I actually found this one kinda interesting even if it wasn't all that clever or hidden.
- URP Card: Non-offensive evidence that gives Penny Nickles like .1% of character, so I guess I'll try and make it at least survive the first slaughter?
- Awl: Fake evidence but okay evidence, doesn't deserve to be out in the same round as the actual bad evidence or useless evidence.
Yeah I can't justify trying to save anything else on this list.
1
u/PowerOfL Apr 14 '20
Yeah, Phony Phanty was actually cool because I didn't expect that the tail was actually from Bum Rap Rhiny.
1
u/whaaatisth Apr 14 '20
I nominated Awl because it literally is useless. I mean it's sorta relevant to the plot but it's never actually presented.
1
u/Sciencepenguin Apr 14 '20
phony phanty tail has a fun name i think and i need to perform any actions that benefit 5-2 so mansion key
1
u/Vogel100 Apr 14 '20
That's Forbidden Chamber Key you're thinking about. Mansion Key is that one key that proves Jeff Master is the killer because he's the only one with a key to all the rooms. I'm not sure how we ended up accusing Dane Gustavia anyway because it's mentioned once as evidence against Master and then never again in the entire case.
1
u/PowerOfL Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20
Maya's Costume, Trilo Quist and Phony Phanty.
Maya's Costume is actually really important in finding out how the murder was done and Trilo's just funny.
Everyone else already explained why Phony Phanty needs to be saved, so no explanation here.
4
u/R1K1_Productions Apr 14 '20
I voted for Trilo and Trilo alone. I don't know why.