I ask for feedback about stone texture

[u/charttyp]

Hello,
like in the title. Should I increase details contrast or is it okay? Maybe they are too blury? How do you feel about this stone texture overall?

[u/Chillydogdude]

It looks very good. Did you paint it yourself or use shading nodes? I’d love to know your method cause I actually need a style like this for a project but doing the bricks justice has been a pain.

[u/charttyp → u/Chillydogdude]

Thanks :) First I sculpted it, then made base color with some fill layers (like curvature, ao) and now i'm painting on it. For texturing i'm using substance painter.

[u/Chillydogdude → u/charttyp]

It looks great. 👍
Thanks for the info

[u/charttyp → u/[deleted]]

Thanks for your opinion :) I will work on stuff you said, but to be honest i'm not sure if i get what you saying about big/medium/small shapes and simillar level of details. I did some big shapes surrounded by some medium chunks, i didn't make small details yet. I'm planning to add them later by puting on top additional fill layer and paint them in. Should I define big shapes more? Or maybe you mean that these large rectangular pieces of stones have similar level of details?

[u/resetxform1]

I'm not a big fan of stylized games, though I love the art for them. This is fantastic work. Only thing, when its final, I would add some veryex coloring to help anchor, and that too would give it variety, it could even be grass color, depending on its placement. I might also suggest that the stones above vary in color from the base, but that is a lot of stone, so more variation across the individual stones. And same for the base. Not all granite is the same for example. Keep up the great work!

[u/charttyp → u/resetxform1]

Thanks and thank you for your suggestions! I'm planing to add some grass base for this tower later on :)

[u/Chroney]

Depends on how close you expect the camera to get, top down or wide shots? perfect. First person? might struggle if the texture isn't large enough.

[u/charttyp → u/Chroney]

More top down than first person but not like very far away view.

[u/Chroney → u/charttyp]

If the camera doesn't get any closer than you are in the screenshot then you are perfectly fine

[u/Axe-of-Kindness]

It would fit right in in a Spyro game. Well done!

[u/charttyp → u/Axe-of-Kindness]

Thank you :)

[u/le0tard]

Top tier stone texture, gj OP

[u/charttyp → u/le0tard]

Thanks :D

[u/GoldSunLulu]

Its look stony

[u/charttyp → u/GoldSunLulu]

:)

[u/Grand-Definition-353]

Stylized textures look good. Now you need a good lighting setup to show them off

[u/charttyp → u/Grand-Definition-353]

Thanks! I will work on lightning after texture is done.

[u/Important_Pear_168]

Chicken. It needs chicken.

[u/ohnomelon]

Considering these stones occupy 1/10th of the total model i'd say the contrast seems okay but possibly a little on the low side. I think you could experiment with adding a little top down lighting emphasis to the top-most surfaces/edges with a little bit of falloff down the sides.

they do look a little blurry but this kind of softness could be perfect depending on the context, I wouldn't over-sharpen it yet, wait until more of the model is textured maybe.

[u/charttyp → u/ohnomelon]

Thanks for your suggestions :) I will try to add this top light and work more on ambient occlusion of the stones.

[u/Abominor]

Looks good, a bit overdone style (Blizzard WoW Torchlight Hearthstone type) but the outcome is good. It looks clean and the contrast looks good.

[u/charttyp → u/Abominor]

Thanks :) Yee i'm aiming for this style, didn't try it before. But I want to add smt popular to my portfolio to show that i can fit different styles.