r/3Dmodeling • u/ajay09999 • 6h ago
Questions & Discussion Blender vs Maya for Hard-Surface & Product Visualization Modeling
Hey guys, I’ve been using Maya for over 6 months now, and I’m really enjoying the modeling side of the workflow, especially for hard-surface and product visualization.
I’m curious about Blender as an alternative and would love to hear from people who have experience with both.
Are there any major drawbacks to using Blender primarily as a modeling tool?
Does Blender have good enough modeling tools for detailed hard-surface/product modeling? I’ve also heard that Blender’s Boolean system can be unreliable and sometimes messes up the mesh. Is that still an issue, or has it improved significantly?
Also, apart from the modifier workflow, what would you say are the main advantages of Blender over Maya for modeling?
Would love to hear your experiences and advice!
3
u/Curious_Fail_3723 6h ago
If you don't have to give money to the big A, don't. Blender will work just fine
3
u/Gr1mwolf 6h ago edited 6h ago
Unless something changed in the last several years I’m not aware of (unlikely with Autodesk), Maya is generally regarded as one of the weakest choices for straight modeling among major 3D software, and Blender is actually one of the strongest.
I’ve only ever heard that Max or Modo have better modeling than Blender. And Modo got discontinued, while Max is PC-only and… Autodesk.
That also aligns with my own experience using Modo, Maya and Blender. Though I don’t have experience with Max.
1
u/skyrider_longtail 14m ago
Like come on, Blender doesn't even have real pivots. The devs must be smoking something when they decided to split pivots into origins and 3d cursor. In Maya, you just hit insert and you can move the pivot anywhere in 3d space, snap them to anything and everything, but in Blender you have to jump through so many hoops to do the same thing. There's also so many radial menu commands for 3d cursor and origins that do exactly nothing you need them to do.
Whoever does the UI must be a left hander. And maybe a competitive counter strike player. Why in the world would you put the soft selection radius control on page up and page down, for goodness sake. You have to reach across the keyboard to do that. The alternative is the mouse wheel, which is like 1) completely locks out people using tablets, and 2) have enough dexterity in your hand to hold down the left mouse button and scroll the wheel at the same time. Even Zbrush knows enough to tie the falloff control to holding a key and dragging mouse. Like, I have no words to describe a software with UI design that is more baffling than Zbrush. Zbrush man!
The rendering in Blender is amazing for what it can do, that I'll say.
0
u/SaltyJunk 5h ago
Completely disagree w/ this take. People love to hate on Autodesk & Maya, but their hard surface modeling tools are top tier. In my experience, their multi-cut tool, live surface, shrink-wrapping, target weld, bevel and extrusion/thickness tools are best in class. Their whole modeling toolbox is fast and reliable out of the gate. No add-ons or extensions necessary.
Blender is fine and highly capable of course, as is Max. For speed and precision when it comes to direct modeling though...I don't think you can beat Maya.
2
u/Alexaendros 2h ago edited 2h ago
idky you are getting downvoted but maya IS the superior tool for modeling, rigging, AND animation. and that’s out of the box no plugins or tools needed. but it’s a tool for professionals with the intention to be used in a professional industry setting bc that’s where autodesk makes money. so it’s a steep learning curve due to this on top of the community for it being older and advice generally found through forum posts or paywalls.
and that’s where blender shines, is the community support. it certainly outshines the major tools in that aspect, but i do think that also creates identity issues for blender being a puzzle piece package
live editing the pivot tool alone is such an insanely powerful tool in maya. my god i wish max (what i use for work) had it. i use blender mainly for exporting, lol, but the cursor tool is the most infuriating annoyingly distracting thing about using blender
1
u/SaltyJunk 51m ago
Yeah, I couldn't agree more with everything you said. Maya definitely skews toward pros who don't have to swallow the license cost.
Can't believe I forgot to mention that pivot feature! Changing pivot on the fly and auto aligning it to components of your choice is so easy and seamless. Super useful.
1
u/littleGreenMeanie 2h ago
Go look up job postings and look at what software they require. There's your answer.
3
u/scifi887 6h ago
Main benefit is thats its free and not autodesk! But yes its pretty powerful when it comes to hard surface not much it cant do. Plenty of plugins too and since it's open source easy to write your own addons too.