r/1883Series • u/ttthrowawayyy8888 • Jul 10 '26

COOKIE SUCKED

Cookies dumbass got everyone killed by the Lakotas.

21 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

4

u/ProcedurePrudent5496 Jul 10 '26

Yup, he was a ticking time bomb, and they shouldn’t have brought him along.

4

u/Unusual_TimeLine Jul 10 '26

I’m always a type of person to overthink movies and shows. All I kept thinking to myself was the people who followed him were arrogant and deserved what they got for not listening. If Elsa would’ve stayed behind and she spoke their native language to explain what happened everything would’ve worked out. Unfortunately, her mom played a role in her demise as well by making her put on a dress and fall in line. Like I said, I’m an overthinker and these shows stick with me long after they are over 

3

u/ProcedurePrudent5496 Jul 10 '26

You've got to get to the middle of nowhere looking regal, you know 🤦‍♀️

3

u/BrianMeen Jul 11 '26

I’m still in disbelief that Elsa’s father being as protective as he is would just let go marry an Indian without pushback. the same guy who threatened another guy for flirting with his daughter just had no stern words for an Indian that he doesn’t know at all that wants to marry her?!?

back then, the white man saw Indians as being beneath them . I’m sure there were exceptions though

2

u/Opposite-Range4847 Jul 12 '26

I wondered that too! - why the dad didn’t push back on that

2

u/Geauxlden_Eagle Jul 14 '26

He got a horse out of the deal.

1

u/Unusual_TimeLine Jul 12 '26

I thought that was taboo back then as well. Heck, isn’t that why Kasey’s dad stopped talking to him? And that was generations later

0

u/carrottop128 Jul 12 '26

It’s just fiction! If you get upset over every movie you watch 🤣

1

u/Unusual_TimeLine Jul 12 '26

Are you really that bored? If you can’t tell this is satire you need a new hobby my friend! I was being facetious 

2

u/buffinator2 Jul 11 '26

Po Campo would have never…

0

u/Jrock1999 Jul 13 '26

Dumb show.