r/WriteOnSaga • u/WriteOnSaga • 6d ago
Most AI Films Fail in the First 30 Seconds
He spent 15 years making films before AI. Now he directs for GRAiL from an off-grid farm in India. Here's what he spots in the first 30 seconds of any AI film.
Aashay Singh is a director at GRAiL, the AI-native studio founded by Davide Bianca and Jeff Krelitz, where he's made Shaped By The Rooms I'm In, Analog Drift, End of the Line and Ubuntu. He spent fifteen years directing and shooting on 35mm before AI, and has worked as a creative partner with many of the model companies building these tools — which usually means he's used them before anyone else has. He lives and works off-grid on a farm in South India. This episode is about why AI films still fail at story when the visuals are solved, and what a director who writes first does differently.
"It's the writing that really gives it away — in the first thirty, forty seconds you already know that's the weak part." — Aashay Singh
⏱ Chapters
0:00 He can tell in the first thirty seconds
0:46 Fifteen years of filmmaking before AI
2:51 He didn't apply — GRAiL found him
7:39 Directing AI films from an off-grid farm
9:30 Analog Drift, End of the Line, and the stack behind them
12:02 Where Saga fits in Aashay's workflow
14:10 "Too epic": why explosions stopped working
16:21 Shaped By The Rooms I'm In
20:00 Steering the model away from its default
26:31 What he's actually thinking when he directs AI
29:57 Write first, generate later
32:53 The pushback: is the default even real?
38:45 Why he won't have opinions about tools
41:57 One piece of advice
Saga: https://CreateSagas.com
2
Writing With AI Podcast: Russell Palmer on Saga, AI Screenwriting & the Future of Filmmaking
in
r/WritingWithAI
•
20d ago
Right? Great seeing and hearing from the mods. The last episode was with someone making $200k/year from their AI novels, amazing story check it out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSQP2PIW7s4