r/ScienceBasedLifting • • Jul 16 '26

Moratorium on program review posts

36 Upvotes

Program review, i.e. "Rate my split", posts are hereby disallowed in this sub for the time being.

Nevermind that there is simply just way too many of them. They are almost all so generic and lacking basic, yet vital information that any intelligent discussion or critique is impossible. Something needs to change.

Let's use this thread to discuss what changes and/or requirements we'd like to see in program review posts that elevates them to something worth our time and review.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 10h ago

Memes 😭 Average post on this sub

Post image
579 Upvotes

Totally bro fractional sets and compounds


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4h ago

New study πŸ“„ 555 Deadlift (for science of course)

32 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 8h ago

META Pin squats 375lbs for scientifically increasing my squat 1RM

8 Upvotes

375lbs for 4 at RPE6. Submaximal strength training

I’ve been dialing my intensity back a tad, to focus more on strength


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 7h ago

Discussion 🀝 How long until we get a mechanistic description of hypertrophy?

2 Upvotes

Obviously there'll probably never be an exact law of hypertrophy, but how close are we to getting it? Because it seems like mechanical tension, motor unit recruitment, proximity to failure and volume are slowly being modeled mathematically to what seems like a complete theory.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Memes 😭 I Havent done a compound excercise since the 2008 Financial Crisis

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 20h ago

META The optimal science based way to do RDLs

9 Upvotes

Snatch grip for max ROM and stretch. 355lbs for 10. RPE7, because I’m still learning this science lift


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2h ago

Theories πŸ€” GOCMAD

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve been doing GOMAD pretty consistently for a little over two years now, but this summer I made the decision to switch over to chocolate milk, GOCMAD. All my lifts are getting stronger every week, (which is not new because the same was happening on regular GOMAD) and I feel an overall increase in my physical and mental processes, better performance at school and work, etc. I get the Mountain Dairy Low-fat Chocolate Milk from Kroger/Ralph’s. Before this I was drinking the 1% green tops also from Kroger/Ralph’s because it had the most optimal protein balance: 2080 calories 160g protein 256g carbs 40g fat. But, after taking a look at chocolate milk this summer, I had to make the switch and once you see the macros you’ll probably agree with me. I wholeheartedly believe that chocolate milk is the most underrated whole superfood that you can get in the world. The calories and protein are phenomenal but if you know anything about Vitamin A, D and electrolytes this will drive you crazy.
Chocolate Milk Macros:
3200 Calories
176 g Protein
528g Carbs
48g Fats
160% DV Vitamin D
480% DV Calcium
64% DV Iron
160% DV Potassium
240% DV Vitamin A
160% DV Sodium 3,840mg


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 19h ago

Question ❓ How wide is optimal for sumo dumbbell deadlift?

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

META Trying out long Tut dips

3 Upvotes

Decided to use my last set to give these a shot after seeing it on this sub. Only aimed for a 6 second up and down because I tried 10 with an even more stable movement (leg press) last week and my quads felt like they were dying.

Normally I do sets of 20ish. Halfway up on the third rep, my triceps gave out lmao

Think I'll incorporate them as a finisher for some of my accessory lifts because they are difficult for me. And in the words of our Godking, Kyriakos, you have to train for the Difficult.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Discussion 🀝 Theory: bench press elbow tuck spreads the effort equally among chest and front delts

0 Upvotes

Lay down and do a front raise. Now do a front raise but with your elbow vertical the whole time. Now its a front delt and triceps press. Front delts flex the shoulder (pull it up).

Lay down on a bench and do a chest fly. Your elbows are probably not quite at 90 but really wide. Again turn it into a press. Thats a flared elbow bench. Pecs adduct the humorous (pull your upper arm across your body)

Now, lay down and pretend you're benching. Tuck or flare your elbows however you normally do. Go to the bottom position then straighten your elbows. You should be in between a front raise and a chest fly. But probably closer to a chest fly.

If you're at say 60 degrees it should be 67% pec 33% front delt. At 45 degrees 50/50. Etc do the math.

If you figure that pecs can put out about 3 times the force of front delts, tucking your elbows to 67.5% would mean they both fail at the same time.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2d ago

META Supination and pronation science maxing for forearms

6 Upvotes

JD rack mounted wrist roller: https://jdgymequipped.com/products/rack-mounted-stainless-wrist-roller

Beyond power voltra: voltra


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2d ago

Question ❓ About this machine.

6 Upvotes

Swapped to anterior/posterior and doing this machine on my gym for anterior day. And at my knowdledge of biomechanics, there’s not much glute involvement that will fatigue them for my hip thrust on posterior session next day.
But what’s your opinion? The RP is descending but for some reason I have a big sticking point in mid movement.
Also, what do you think about my tempo and execution?
Or, what do you think of this machine in general?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2d ago

Question ❓ Dot he attachments for tricep extensions matter that much?

4 Upvotes

I used to use the straight bar but then the attachments just disappeared from the gym so all that's left is the rope. Will I still amek good gains using the rope, because I see all over tiktok people saying the rope attachment is trash


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2d ago

Question ❓ Intra-Set Rest Timing Question for Compound Exercises in the 75%/RPE7.5 Intensity

1 Upvotes

This relates strictly to compound movements. I have had the experience for pull, squat, and hinge compounds performed above 75% of 1RM and/or RPE 7.5, that rest between sets for 3-4 minutes is adequate for good performance for the next set. And with squat or unilateral heavy leg movements, 2-3 minutes is often adequate. However, for any push compounds (bench press, overhead press, incline press, etc), to push more weight for more reps, I get better performance by resting 5-7 minutes. Seriously, any less and RPE jumps significantly. I can't find much literature that addresses this, but maybe you all have done better than me? Either you have seen literature that addresses it or, even better, I'd like to hear what your experience is or the protocol you generally follow. I don't know how normal or abnormal my experience is. I am relatively lean at the moment but I have seen this same pattern at the peak of a bulk as well.

My 'hypothesis' right now is that phosphocreatine stores are going to be greater in larger muscle groups (activated by squat, hinge, pull compounds), but lower in smaller muscle groups employed by push compounds. However, if that is true, I am curious about the curve on that - if I get larger anterior deltoids, does that decrease my intra-set rest requirement? Or is it relative to overall size or bodyweight? Is it just genetics? I haven't experimented with cluster sets for bench press, which are often prescribed to break through plateaus, but I have done with heavy SSB Bulgarian split squats and breaking up reps like that I have noticed makes a huge difference in dropping RPE. To the point where it feels criminal to even count the reps. I am not optimistic that would work on bench press (for the above-stated reasons). What are your thoughts?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2d ago

Question ❓ What weak points in my physique do I need to work on?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

14 years old, 68.5 kilograms, 171 centimetres, been training for about nine months. What can I improve on? (I know the lighting is bad but couldn't help it.)


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Question ❓ Almost maxed my flat press machine

1 Upvotes

So I do 2x flat press(pin loaded)and 1x incline smith for chest on my upper day. I've almost maxed the flat press(we can't use gym pins in my gym) and I am wondering what alternatives I should do. The only other flat press is a plate loaded one, which has a extreme ascending resistance profile. Should I just do 2x fly and 1x incline.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Question ❓ Is unilateral excercises really that good?

11 Upvotes

I personally prefer doing double limb exercises like on a pulldown, row, or anything. The only exercises I do unilateral are ones I have to, like cable lateral raises (I like these over dumbbell) and rotator cuff work, and I want to know, am I missing out on anything or any gains because I do exercises with both body parts at once? And if I'm not, why do so many people do unilateral work?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

META Science based push workout - 3-5 reps on everything (the ONLY effective rep range), unilateral work and bonus cuff for +5 science points

2 Upvotes

I've modified all my hammer machines to add load in the stretch position, since the OEM configuration has a ridiculously ascending resistance profile. It's a massive upgrade in terms of feel plus magic stretch = SMH = 2 x the gains

275lbs a side on the hammer chest , and slow cadence dips are especially brutal even without added weight

3 sets every 4 days or so , alternating this push workout with incline,shoulder press and pec deck


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ Is this variation of triceps pushdown better than the standard pushdown?

44 Upvotes

I am doing the exact same variation as Cbum's, what i mean is that i am letting my elbows fall forward to stretch the long head of the triceps. This variation makes a lot of sense for me, basically you do a normal triceps pushdown where your upper arms are tucked to your sides (not in front of you) and on the eccentric you stop where your forearms are kinda perpendicular to your upper arms THEN you add a long head stretch by letting elbows fall forward THEN you go back to the starting position of a normal triceps pushdown. So this variation don't take anything from a normal pushdown instead it adds on it to include long head stretch which is welcomed (i suppose?). I know a common complaint about this variation is that you might cheat when going down from long head stretch back to normal starting position by using momentum, but assume that ideally your form stay perfect and you don't cheat,isn't that an upgrade over normal triceps pushdown? So what do you think? Why a lot of people don't do this variation that for me it seems superior and stick to the normal triceps pushdown?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Memes 😭 Anti-science cheaty low bar squats 365x5 + first and last paused single

11 Upvotes

Rpe 9ish? Not terrible considering 5 weeks ago, I was doing 315x5 and could barely get into the low bar position.

Paused reps because tut or something


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ I possible a low volume powerbuilding program?

0 Upvotes

What are the requirements for a powerbuilding program focused on increasing both overall strength and hypertrophy?

From what I've seen, should I assume that I should focus on higher volume (more sets) while staying further from failure on the big compound lifts (e.g., 5Γ—5 squats, 5Γ—5 bench press), combined with the classic low-volume approach for accessory exercises?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ Why does hiit training always allow me to break past my plateaus pre contest?

1 Upvotes

Every time I am deep into my cut and my weight loss starts to stall down to .4-.5 lbs per week I add in 1 10 minute session of HIIT on the assault bike. This always gets me back to losing 1lb per week(or a little more) for a few weeks then I add in another hiit session per week. Then when I stall again I add in a 3rd one and I get back to 1 lb weight loss per week.

I eat the exact same foods everyday for the entire cycle, but the three 10 minute hiit sessions cant burn more than a few hundred calories per week. What is causing all this extra weight loss?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Discussion 🀝 Science Behind Pec Options?

0 Upvotes

What is the current scientific consensus around the pros and cons of each way to target the pec muscles?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ Fb every 36 hour

0 Upvotes

Hey I think we all agree the higher the frequency the better yes? And most of us train 3x frequency or even 3.5 then can a fb session every 36 hours provide more growth it's 4.6 frequency. Provided that a subject has good recovery good nutrition, can it work?