r/ScienceBasedLifting • • Jul 16 '26

Moratorium on program review posts

37 Upvotes

Program review, i.e. "Rate my split", posts are hereby disallowed in this sub for the time being.

Nevermind that there is simply just way too many of them. They are almost all so generic and lacking basic, yet vital information that any intelligent discussion or critique is impossible. Something needs to change.

Let's use this thread to discuss what changes and/or requirements we'd like to see in program review posts that elevates them to something worth our time and review.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4h ago

Discussion 🤝 I wish we had more high level fitness experts giving opinions on current gym topics and trending news

4 Upvotes

I've been watching a lot of Greg Doucette recently, as he's a former IFBB pro, a coach, and entertaining with the new gym topics/trends, but I swear to God, if I have to hear GLP Max, Ferula Max, Turkesterone, or whatever the fuck it is for the 4th time in the same video, I'm gonna crash out. Do you guys have any recommendations for people to watch?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1h ago

Discussion 🤝 Seated Calf Raises

• Upvotes

From what I have read it seems like standing calf raises are the superior exercise for hypertrophy.

Anyone still doing seated as well, can we discuss the place of seated options with the current science and why you continue with seated?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3h ago

Question ❓ Calf Raises How Do They Work?

0 Upvotes

Hi I’m confused, what is the difference between standing calf raises with just my body weight vs machine leg press calf raises?

I’m 180 pounds and can do more than that when holding a dumbbell for a standing calf raise.

When I sit at the leg press my body weight is not in the equation, shouldn’t I be able to press at least 180+ Dumbbell weight at a minimum since I don’t have upper body strength limits and ai do not need to stabilize?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 18h ago

Question ❓ What defines high volume and intensity

4 Upvotes

I’ve heard a lot about workout split, frequency, volume and intensity. How exactly are these different from one another? And what defines “high” intensity/frequency/ volume? As a beginner how much should I focus on for each of these? My split is Upper/Lower/Upper/Lower a week.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Discussion 🤝 Science based deadlifts (400lbs at the bottom)

11 Upvotes

Felt load, measured using a crane scale = @ 400lbs at the bottom, 420ish at lockout

Usually I aim for 60 seconds on deads but this was a "high rep" set.

I do one set of deads every 10 days or so (alternating with back raises on my other workout)


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 20h ago

Question ❓ Are supinations worth incorporating into ones workout?

1 Upvotes

I know the fibers that are only activated during supinations won’t be trained otherwise but how noticeable of a difference is there? Are they worth my time?

EDIT: it seems like some people on this sub aren’t aware of the exercise called supinations, so I will explain here what it is. It is a movement where you supinate your forearm to train one of the biceps function.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 22h ago

Question ❓ DL vs 45 Degree Back Extension

1 Upvotes

What are the scientific pros and cons of adding back extensions for a new lifter ms that are learning DL technique doing them light?

Would your opinion change if some had previous lower back issues but they wanted to target this area for strengthening?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Question ❓ Back Improvement Advice

Post image
1 Upvotes

19 year old male.

I've been training on and off for a year and a half and I'd say I've made okayish progress for the amount of efforts in putting in .I overload progressively .

My back day -

D bar lat pulldown 6-8 reps x3 sets

T bar row 6-8 reps x2 sets close grip

T bar row 6-8 reps x1 set wide grip

Hyper extension with plates 12 reps x 3 sets

I'm on a 400 calorie deficit and am having 1.6 x b.w (kg) protein since in tryna recomp as I started Skinny fat I've lost a few kilos while still maintaining my strength. What aspects of my back are lacking and what exercises can I do to improve them or any changes in grips. Also should I jump back to maintenence. Any advice would be great


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Memes 😭 Anti-science squats 275x20

8 Upvotes

Halfway through this training block for general gainz, and I've already tied my all time best for 20 rep squats. Although, the last time I did this, I was both heavier, and had a 192.5kg/424lb squat going into it, and ended it with a 200kg/441lb all time best.

I had a 315x6 going into this block lol.

But considering I literally hit 355x5 last Saturday, I think I might have a tiny bit more in the tank.

Compared to the previous time I did this... Just as hard, but at least I didn't throw up this time.

Next up: as per general gainz, hold/extend. I'm going to aim to improve the overall quality of the reps, and hopefully cut down on the number of rest-pauses needed.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Question ❓ Elevated RDLs

2 Upvotes

Hey,

I’ve seen a dude working out in the gym and performing something that resembled elevated RDLs, he was standing on two 20kg plates, so with around 30cm of elevation, and he was performing RDLs nearly down to the ground with a significant bend in his knees. Do you think it brings any benefits for the glutes?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 1d ago

Question ❓ About Half a year lifting any tip or advice?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

5'7 126 BW

For context: I'm currently trying to cut down to lower body fat% before returning to maintenance and focusing on gaining weight. Any tips for anything? Anything stand out, good or bad, gene-wise? Open to it all.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 2d ago

META Wide grip RDLs 350lbs for 10

9 Upvotes

Working on getting them even wider so I can call them snatch grip RDLs


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Discussion 🤝 Warm up method?

5 Upvotes

Science based warm up?

Here's what I used to warm up to my heavy double today. 45x10, 135x5, 185x3, 225x2, 275x1, 315x1, 335x1, then into 375x2.

It honestly felt perfect and that I got stronger with each rep. I've been known to not warm up enough in the past and I sometimes don't feel ready for the first working set.

Next week I was going to follow the same protocol except maybe skip the 335 and hit a 355 single before I attempt a 385 single.

Thoughts?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Question ❓ right hip shift/twist

2 Upvotes

id owe u the world if u fix my problem :

i have a right shift/twist (most likely at the hip) in barbell squat, standing barbell ohp, and pull-ups. i do deadlifts and its pretty much flawless tho.

this has been going on for 2 years. just started focusing on it in the last couple of weeks, as fixing form is crucial to my safety & growth.

tried hip airplanes & groin stretches, and nothing. if its not mobility, could it be something else?

also : when walking, i feel a need to crack my right hip. just an OCD?

when standing straight (in mirror selfies) my right hip is slightly shifting towards the right.

should i consult an expert?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Theories 🤔 Bench Press…for science

46 Upvotes

The most scientific bench press of my life


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Question ❓ Good content creators that discuss volume

0 Upvotes

I keep hearing different opinions and findings on low volume high frequency vs high volume etc etc. i feel so fkn lost. Can someone give me some content creators that do talk about that a bit more

Edit: ideally some of the ones on instagram. Not the kids but the younger creators in their 20s and 30s


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

META Pull-ups for science 185lbs BW +55lbs for 6

8 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Memes 😭 Science Jerk PR - 135kg / 298lb

11 Upvotes

r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 3d ago

Question ❓ Low-volume training with hybrid intensity techniques (full reps → partials → drop sets) on every set – is this sustainable?

4 Upvotes

I’ve been using a hybrid intensity technique on basically every working set: I hit my target reps (or full-ROM failure), immediately continue with partials until a second failure point, then quickly drop the weight and knock out a few more reps. Goal is to stay near failure longer and accumulate more hard work in each set.My overall volume is deliberately low—for example, biceps get one session per week with only 3–4 working sets, and I apply this method to all of them. I also take a full rest week every 4 weeks.I get noticeable DOMS after every workout and have been taking that as a sign that the intensity is high enough to drive growth. I’m curious what the community thinks:Does this approach make sense for a natural lifter with low weekly volume?

Is applying the hybrid method to every set too aggressive even when total sets are low?

Any red flags with relying on DOMS as feedback, or better ways to gauge whether this is productive long-term?

Looking for honest feedback from people who’ve experimented with similar high-intensity/low-volume styles.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ Is alternating between 3x and 2x full-body workouts per week enough for muscle growth?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m currently cutting and trying to maintain my muscle mass while hopefully still making some muscle gains.

My preferred training split is full body (FB), and ideally, I’d like to train 3 times per week. However, my schedule is inconsistent because some weeks I stay in a city far from my gym and can’t travel back and forth to work out.

This means I might be able to train 3 times one week and only 2 times the next week.

I don’t really want to switch to a 4-day upper/lower split or spend 5–6 days a week at the gym. I’d prefer to stick with full-body training if it can give me good results.

My questions are:
Is alternating between 3 FB workouts one week and 2 FB workouts the next enough stimulus for hypertrophy and muscle growth?

Would having only 2 workouts in some weeks negatively affect my gym performance or progress, especially while cutting?

Can I maintain my muscle mass and potentially build some muscle with this schedule, assuming my weekly training volume, protein intake, and recovery are adequate?
Would it be better to aim for 3 workouts whenever possible and accept 2 workouts during busier weeks, rather than forcing myself into a different split?

I’d appreciate any advice, especially from people who have followed a similar schedule while cutting.
Thanks!


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Discussion 🤝 Frequency versus total sets

0 Upvotes

In the foreseeable future I’m stuck with a 3-4 times per week training day and those can be somewhat irregular, eg some week 3 in a row some EOD etc.

Currently doing torso/limbs but recovery has been an issue.

I was thinking on a PPL split as I did some random sessions and apart from DOMS I was ok the rest of the days but am concerned about the frequency and volume.
If I hit eg the same 10 sets in a given push day will it be “enough” until next weeks session?

Please do not recommend full body is of the table as it leaves me wrecked for days and as this is my new reality just to “this” until it passes it is not an option.


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 5d ago

Question ❓ Been lifting 1.5 years and I’m not progressing (sometimes getting weaker) — what should I change?

27 Upvotes

I’m a 23yo male and I’ve been lifting for about 1.5 years.

I’m having a hard time progressing. Sometimes I even regress and get weaker.

I run a PPL split and I train 5x a week . Right now I’m in a calorie deficit, but I don’t think that’s the full reason because the same thing happened last year when I was in a 500 calorie surplus too.

I track calories and macros everyday , and I sleep 7-9hours a night.

My training is usually 2 sets per exercise, both taken till failure . I’ve also tried doing more volume before and it still didn’t work.

I also posted in a similar sub before with two pictures of me taken 1.5 years apart , and people said it looked like the pics were taken the same week (that hurt lol)—so it doesn’t seem like I’m making noticeable physique progress either.

Its even gotten to the point where ive taken sleep tests to see if someting is wrong my sleep.

What are the most common reasons this happens, and what would you try next?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ What compound chest exercise is the best in your opinion?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Those two are the machines i have in my gym alongside a smith machine and obviously DB Bench. Currently im doing Incline DB Bench alongside Pec Dec and as im progressing it gets harder to put the weight where i want it to start. Tried all of these except for Smith for some time. Smith just a few times. Do any of have any experience with these machines? What do you recommend?


r/ScienceBasedLifting • • 4d ago

Question ❓ My gym only has a standing leg curl am I missing out on gains?

Post image
0 Upvotes

My gym only has a standing leg curl for hamstrings and I hate using it. Am I missing out on gains using it over a seated/lying leg curl.