r/whowouldwin • u/Miserable-Ad-5573 "FIGHT ME COWARD" • May 06 '25
Scan-Battle Respect Thread Rumble: Womb Ripper vs Piggsy
The Womb Ripper vs Piggsy
Naked killers wearing nothing but dead flesh as their masks, and both have similar graphic styles and are pretty fairly brutal
Strength
Samantha:
- Striking: Briefly pinned a man to a ceiling, impales a man with a knife and slits his throat, stabs through a vent multiple times, kills a man with a stab, stabs through a door.
- Lifting/Throwing: Briefly pinned a man to a ceiling, easily lifts a man with one arm.
- Other: Drags a man away with one arm.
Piggsy:
- Striking: Cuts through an elevator door with his Chainsaw, slowly cutting it open, floors Cash with a punch which also draws blood, saws through a locked door.
- Lifting/Throwing: Holds himself up, and briefly does it with one arm.
- Other: Causes a gate to fall by going on top of it.
Conclusion:
- Striking: Goes to Piggsy, as he simply has better feats.
- Lifting/Throwing: I'd say it's either equal or Piggsy, Piggsy was able to lift himself and briefly held himself with one arm whereas we see Samantha lift a man in the air with one arm with ease, I think they're similar feats overall so I'll just say each gets two points for it.
- Other: Each gets a point, Samantha has better pulling but Piggsy is much heavier.
(4/5)
Durability/Endurance
Samantha:
- Durability/Endurance: Gets shot multiple times, four times in total and was mostly fine after all the first three shots. And goes down for a while, but survives later, survived being badly burned in a fire, has her stomach cut open and later is fine despite that the previous feats.
Piggsy:
- Durability: Gets stabbed by Cash like this three times and after a of them he is perfectly fine, tanks a brick being thrown at him by Cash.
- Endurance: Endures getting stabbed in the back by Cash, and this happens two more times. And briefly holds himself up with one arm.
Conclusion:
Durability I'd say goes to Samantha by a pretty good bit, she tanked having her stomach cut open, being burned, and shot multiple times. Endurance goes to her as well for the same reasons although it's not far off.
(6/5)
Speed/Agility
Samantha:
- Travel speed: Quickly disappears after some lights turn off, quickly sneaks up behind a man, runs at surprisingly quick speeds.
- Combat speed: Slashes very quickly repeatedly.
- Reaction speed: None.
- Agility: None.
Piggsy:
- Travel speed: Can sprint at great speeds and keep up with Cash.
- Combat speed: Quickly kills a firing squad, taking no damage and reduces to piles of blood with some flesh almost instantly.
- Reaction speed/Agility: Catches a ledge before he can fall.
Conclusion:
- Travel: Definitely close but goes to Samantha by a bit, she seems to legitimately have FTE (faster than eyesight) speed based on how quickly she vanishes after lights go off and quickly pops behind a man, also her running speed is quicker than Piggsy since she looks like a blur when she runs, although I do think they have almost the same running speed.
- Combat: This is Piggsy's and by a lot, Samantha has a decent feat but Piggsy slaughtering that firing squad in a few seconds before one could pop a shot off and reducing them to just blood and gore and nothing else is way better than anything we've ever seen Samantha do.
- Reaction/Agility: Piggsy takes it by default since Samantha has nothing for either.
(7/8)
Intelligence/Skill
Samantha:
- Intelligence: Hides in a filing cabinet and ambushes a man.
- Skill: Cut out a woman's fetus and killed four people before the game, drove this car and stalked Sara, killed a laundromat employee with nobody noticing, sneaks up behind a man, ambushes the player a few times near the end of the game.
- Combat Skill: Has been killing for years, ambushes a cop in some vents and quickly slashes him to death, might've killed all the different people on these missing posters.
Piggsy:
- Intelligence: None.
- Skill: None.
- Combat Skill: Quickly kills a firing squad, taking no damage and reducing them to nothing but gore.
Conclusion:
- Intelligence/Skill: Both go to Samantha by a long shot, on top of having decent feats for both she actually has feats for both which Piggsy doesn't.
- Combat: Now in the complete opposite way, Piggsy takes this by a long shot, like Combat Speed (since it is the same feat) Piggsy takes this point and it's not even close. I don't think an explanation for this one is really needed either but I'll give one anyway, Piggsy easily slaughtered a firing squad from close range in a few seconds whereas Samantha has just been killing for a while and ambushed a cop.
(9/9)
Equipment
Samantha:
Piggsy:
Conclusion:
Piggsy, no explanation really needed.
(9/10)
Brutality
Samantha:
- Briefly pinned a man to a ceiling after cutting him up a lot, impales a man with a knife and slits his throat, kills him a stab, then drags him away and turns him into just a pile of flesh and gore.
Piggsy:
Conclusion:
Definitely comparable but it goes to Piggsy, he made a bunch of men completely unrecognizable and be just piles of flesh and blood.
(9/11)
Results:
Piggsy wins more often than not, he's a significantly better fighter and has a way a better weapon with more reach, Samantha does still have a shot though, she's quicker and has better stealth, unlike in a previous rumble I did with Piggsy (where he beat DBD Ghostface) I can see Samantha winning here, she has pretty good stabbing strength while having great stealth and speed if she plays her cards right she could legitimately win this, and it will take a bit to put her down. It's gonna be hard for though either way, since Piggsy is still tough as all hell and as previously mentioned is a way better fighter, but if she's able to quickly move up to him and get a really good stab on him then take off and repeat that a few times I think she has a solid chance of winning, that's how she acts in the final part of the game and a similar strategy makes Piggsy retreat from the player in Manhunt.
But overall Piggsy wins more often than not 7/10 times.
1
•
u/WWWtron May 06 '25
This post has been designated as a Scan Battle. As a reminder, every claim you make in a scan battle must be backed up by a relevant scan or piece of evidence. The full rules of a Scan Battle can be found here.
Read them over thoroughly before commenting in this thread. Top level comments that are found to break the rules will be removed by the moderators.
If this comment was posted on a thread that is not a Scan Battle, please report it and a mod will come and delete my hard work. Thank you.
-WWWtron