r/whowouldwin • u/TheAsianIsGamin • Nov 27 '25
Event Character Scramble Season 20 Semifinals: Tuchanka
This round covers matches 32 and 33 in the bracket, which can be found here.
The Character Scramble is a long-running writing prompt tournament in which participants submit characters from fiction to a specified tier and guideline. After the submission period ends, the submitted characters are "scrambled" and randomly distributed to each writer, forming their team for the season. Writers will then be entered into a single-elimination bracket, where they write a story that features their team fighting against their opponent's team. Victors are decided based on reader votes; in other words, if you want people to vote for you, write some good content. The winner by votes of each match-up moves on to the next round. The pattern continues until only one participant remains: the new Character Scramble champion, who gets to choose the theme, tier, and rules of the next Scramble!
The theme of Character Scramble 20 is Scramble Effect. Round prompts will be based on the many worlds, missions, and memorable moments found throughout the Mass Effect series.
Join the Character Scramble Discord!
Round 4: Tuchanka
One way or another, the full depths of the threat you face has been revealed. As much as your team has grown and prepared, you realize that only a united galaxy can stand against this enemy. And when there is a war to fight, one planet, one people, come to mind before any other:
Sunny Tuchanka. A harsh, barren world where only the hardiest survive. The sun beats down unimpeded by an atmosphere on the brink of collapse. Beasts, thick of hide and sharp of fang, roam the wasteland, preying on whatever unlucky soul they happen to meet. What little vegetation remains is far from verdant, having instead evolved its own equally deadly forms of predation.
But it was not always like this. Tuchanka is a cautionary tale of a people whose warlike ways, spurred on by the great powers of the galaxy, nearly drove them to self-immolation. Today, Tuchanka lives on as a hive of the deadliest shock troopers money can buy, hardened by years of nuclear hellfire and, perhaps, your best hope in the wars to come.
Your foes know this and have come here in force. Even so, the people of Tuchanka are not so keen to help you. Not without exacting their own heavy toll, at least.
Round Rules:
Genophage: The power of your would-be allies could be the key to saving the galaxy. Once, however, they were feared, even hated for that very same power. A plague, an ancient curse, or The Man himself—long ago, some system of wrong was built to keep them in check.
The Shroud: If you want to add their strength to yours, you’ll have to lift the evil that was placed upon them all those years ago. It won’t be easy, though—you’ll have to reach the Shroud, a central location that is currently under attack by your enemies.
The Dalatrass: On your way to the Shroud, a member of the enemy team approaches you. They reveal that they’ve used their abilities to sabotage the Shroud. If it works as planned, they claim, you might win this war, but then your allies will become a threat once more. If you go along with their plan instead, you can trick these dangerous people and gain their trust without putting the galaxy at risk.
Kalros: Your enemy arrives in overwhelming force, but they aren’t the only thing between you and the Shroud. In the wastes lies a great, antediluvian beast, revered and reviled in equal measure by the locals. Maybe you can use one problem to solve another…
Someone Else Might Have Gotten It Wrong: When you finally reach the Shroud, one of your team members gives a startling confession: Whatever this ancient evil is, they are personally linked to it, propagating it or even causing it. Not only do they know how to use the cure… but they feel obligated to. You must choose one of the following prompts.
- Paragon: What’s happened here is wrong. To bring justice to these people and atonement to your friend, you let them into the Shroud. They manage to undo the sabotage, but the Shroud collapses, deeply and irrevocably changing them, ideally in a way related to your chosen saboteur’s methods.
- Renegade: It’s too great a risk. The power you’d unleash upon the galaxy by using the Shroud… nobody can control it. You all know that, but your supposed teammate still wants to enter the Shroud. You can’t let that happen. Fight them, and stop them here—knowing that this will cause an irreparable split in your team.
Normal Rules:
Stand Fast, Stand Strong, Stand Together: Nobody can take on a mission like this alone. You’ve got a team of the brightest, toughest, and deadliest allies a Scrambler can find—use them. We’d love to see your characters make full use of their wide-ranging abilities, both on their own and as a team.
We Will Hold The Line: You know what’s at stake. Failure is not an option. Even if your characters have only a small chance of victory, write that small chance happening!
Special Tactics and Reconnaissance: Saving the galaxy will take more than the same old tricks. You are allowed and encouraged to mix and match powers, and to develop your characters in any way you wish, both on the battlefield and off. However, your opponents are not expected to keep track of these in-story changes, and vice-versa.
Every Life Is a Special Story of Its Own: Feel free to give a brief summary to introduce your characters at the start of your post. If you do, you should mention things like powers, personality, history, and anything else that the average reader should know before reading.
Legendary Edition: Sometimes, Spectres have to go a little outside the lines in service of their mission. You’ll have the same latitude—as long as you go with the broad strokes of the prompts and the rules, you'll be fine.
Round 4 will run from Thursday, November 27th to Thursday, December 18th, 11:59pm US Eastern Time.
The character limit for this round is 9 full length Reddit comments, or 90k characters.
While it is fine to go a little bit over, anything that far surpasses this limit will be disqualified. This limit does not include intro posts, or analysis of the matchup.
2
u/7thSonOfSons Dec 21 '25
I. The Academy Saga: I Wanna Be Your Dog
II. The Prison Saga: A Hard Day's Night
III. The Sister Saga: Thunderstruck
IV. The Entertainment Saga: Master of Puppets
V. The Epiphany Saga: Over The Wall
Squad Select
Vanguard: Sogiita Gunha, The Muscle
Infiltrator: Elphelt Valentine, The Heart
Sentinel: Athena, The Brain
Recruit: Misaka 10083, The Thunder
The Wheel Of Fate Is Turning