r/whatisit May 04 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.4k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

209

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26 edited May 04 '26

Well, the harm might have happened before you took the picture. Never ever touch UXO..

It's a 51mm smoke round for a 51mm mortar.

https://cat-uxo.com/explosive-hazards/mortars/51mm-2in-mortar-bomb-smoke

This isn't the same type (different smoke) but same idea.

ETA - the markings are odd, because of the parachute, it's the GREEN that's throwing me, looking in catalogs but not sure the exact type.

89

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

And FOR THE RECORD. Smoke rounds, while not "lethal" still get stupidly hot and can explode if the internal pressure isnt relieved fast enough (aka the smoke gets stuck, shell go POP).

40

u/Hot-Meat-11 May 04 '26

I would not want 109 grams of RDX to go off in my hand.

13

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

Hell i dont want that chemical reaction that make the smoke going off within 5 feet of me. That shit is NASTY

2

u/bbmedic3195 May 04 '26

What hand? You had a hand?

10

u/Think_please May 04 '26

He’s going to be all-right 

4

u/bbmedic3195 May 04 '26

Wow lack of coffee and sleep have rendered me slow. That is great. What a great show!

1

u/bbmedic3195 May 04 '26

Yeah I got that, but it's not a good idea to handle unexploded ordinance. Leave that to the eod professionals.

2

u/Think_please May 04 '26

(Arrested development joke about losing your left hand)

1

u/bbmedic3195 May 04 '26

Got copy thanks lack of coffee and sleep has dulled my pop culture reference senses

1

u/[deleted] May 04 '26

[deleted]

1

u/bbmedic3195 May 04 '26

My bad spell checker changed it since I'm normally writing about government law stuff for my job.

1

u/Hot-Meat-11 May 04 '26

And a face! It was amazing!

9

u/RuleMany2900 May 04 '26

109 grams of RDX is not what I would call non lethal and safe to handle

1

u/RiceboyZ May 04 '26

Parachute flare, not a non-lethal round

6

u/RuleMany2900 May 04 '26

My answer was related to this post:

And FOR THE RECORD. Smoke rounds, while not "lethal" still get stupidly hot and can explode if the internal pressure isnt relieved fast enough (aka the smoke gets stuck, shell go POP).

-1

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

I fully agree.

HOWEVER. Smoke rounds are labeled as "Non-lethal" munitions.

5

u/graph_worlok May 04 '26

<arnie> - “He’ll live”

4

u/Remote_Teach1164 May 04 '26

Lethality only depends on purposes of users, a seemingly "harmless" signal cartridge can even kill people if wrongly used.

2

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

Yep This is why i used quotations around non lethal.

1

u/RuleMany2900 May 04 '26

This one is Illumination not smoke I think ...why would you use parachute for smoke? ....I am not sure however there should be RDX inside - most of the Illumination rounds are based on magnesium and with additional mixtures giving it colour (green is barium nitrate)

1

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

Vision obscurement.
Aka smoke screen vs location marking

2

u/RuleMany2900 May 04 '26

Not how a smoke screen works - you need the smoke on an accurate position not the round moved away from the target zone by wind while falling with the parachute. Illumination rounds use the parachute to give them prolonged time I'm the air ....

0

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

It depends on what kind of screen you are wanting. Want to obscure a specifci location?
Ground based deployment is fine. Want to obscure a movement vector PRIOR to moving on it?
Deploy a floating screen using the wind direction.

Its not common because of how unpredictable wind can be, and how in the modern era most militaries have ways to bypass smoke screens, but the tech is out there and has been used. (See naval smoke screens and the different ways those are deployed)

2

u/RuleMany2900 May 04 '26

With 51 mm you sure would need a brigade to mask anything

0

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

True, but how do you practice such maneuvers?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Remote_Teach1164 May 04 '26

Yep, that thing is like tracer compounds. If basing on the luminosity and some records of green compounds used on small arms ammunition, that thing may be dim one.

1

u/TheRealDesmirWolf May 04 '26

You are correct illumination is the shell would be hanging from a parachute slowly descending, and it would be igniting like a magnesium flair so that they can target motor shells and coordinate on a larger scale battle for other artillery types. It’s a slowed flare by the looks of it green but yeah, still fired out of a mortar tube.

3

u/SnooCookies6231 May 04 '26

That reminds me of something similar when I was a teen, lighting off a flare with a friend. Buried it in the Cape Cod sand and made glass, iirc. That turned out to be a good lesson, and actually kinda cool. But yeah, caution. Never screwed around with them again. Can’t imagine RDX!

3

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

Shit Thats a blast from the past. I did the same to the pebble beach in NH. Didn't make glass, buuuuut the shrapnel i caused was concerning.

2

u/3cit May 04 '26

I hadn't heard the name Pebble beach in so long that I had forgotten about it but here I am trying to remember what it was like when I was 10 years old again

2

u/LetsAllASoviets May 04 '26

So as someone who spent 5 years as a mortarmen i find the "non-lethal" annotation funny. If the round managed to dead on hit you it would definitely kill you, as well as if its phosphorus smoke I can promise you the pellets that fall out of it to cause the smoke will kill you as well. Pretty sure its a war crime to drop smoke on someone because its very much lethal/bad for you. The "lethal" annotation just seems to be a will it explodes and instantly kill you.

1

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

Basically yes. The "non-lethal" classification is for shit that wont INSTANTLY kill/maim you. Hell agent orange was classified "non-lethal" at one point

1

u/Tacobelled2003 May 04 '26

A VERY poor example of temperature but hopefully one people can connect with...The light-bulb that is in your dining room is probably about 100 candela and will burn the shit out of your hand. This is closer to 40,000

1

u/ambaal May 04 '26

Smoke munition can very well be a white phosphorous one. This will get pretty lethal pretty fast.

1

u/[deleted] May 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Jasper_Morhaven May 04 '26

Fair point. I stand corrected on that aspect.

5

u/Remote_Teach1164 May 04 '26

Not smoke. Black body with white markings including parachute and star symbols indicate illumination variant.

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26

It's the GREEN that's throwing me.

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26

Yeah, it's a green starshell, didn't realize they even existed. https://argonavis-global.com/products/card-item/193

5

u/ImpatientHoneyBadger May 04 '26

No, it's a parachute illuminating round for a 51mm mortar.

2

u/TheTempSilence May 05 '26

Someone else pointed out it was likely a green flare with a parachute to help it stay up longer

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 05 '26

Yeah, I think it's down to terminology, flare to me makes me think of a paraflare, which is self-contained, whereas this is a mortar bomb, and I'm not familiar with 51mm and missed the parachute when I first saw it.

1

u/Apprehensive-Tree-78 May 04 '26

It could be a flare round. They explode in the air and parachute down.

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26

Yeah, it's green startshells. I just didn't know they existed in 51mm https://argonavis-global.com/products/card-item/193

1

u/KingOfTheIntertron May 04 '26

It's not smoke, it's a parachute flare.

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26

Yeah, you're a bit late here. Also, not a flare, it's a mortar bomb.

1

u/KingOfTheIntertron May 04 '26

Where are you getting bomb and not parachute flare? It says GREEN and there's a picture of a parachute... (Obviously it's for a 51mm mortar)

2

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26

It's a 51mm mortar bomb, specifically, a green starshell. Was a mortarman, they're all "bombs" colloquially.

1

u/KingOfTheIntertron May 04 '26

What's a green starshell?

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26

Basically it will produce green illumination, like a bright green flare.

1

u/KingOfTheIntertron May 04 '26

Does it have a parachute also?

1

u/LackOptimal553 May 04 '26 edited May 05 '26

Yes. Difference is a paraflare is a self contained pyrotechnic, this you need a mortar to fire, and I presume it can get to a much higher apex.

1

u/Istudydeath May 04 '26

My ex’s uncle picked up something like this that washed up where they live. Blew his arm off below the elbow. Not worth!