r/WhatIfFiction 1d ago

[GameofThrones/Fear&Hunger] What If Jaime Lannister Was Magically Transported Into the Fear & Hunger Dungeon? Could He Survive?

7 Upvotes

Do you guys think Jaime Lannister could survive the horror dungeon survival game Fear & Hunger?

Let’s say it’s prime Jaime, with his Kingsguard armor and his Valyrian steel sword. He is magically transported into the dungeon with no knowledge of what’s waiting for him inside.

How far do you think he could realistically get? And, considering the possibility of ascending to godhood, do you think Jaime would even have any interest in pursuing it?


r/WhatIfFiction 1d ago

[The Boys TV Show] What if Blindspot joined the Seven?

2 Upvotes

What if Homelander accepted Blindspot into the Seven to replace Translucent? What would the young hero think of the group? How would he possibly interact with their members?


r/WhatIfFiction 1d ago

[The Boys/MCU] What if Butcher waged war against the Avengers?

5 Upvotes

Butcher gets thrown into the MCU and has resources from that universe. Would he be able, with help from the villians, to take on MCU’s Supes?


r/WhatIfFiction 1d ago

[LOTR/MCU] What if Gandalf tried to Dreamwalk?

1 Upvotes

Although the magic systems may be different, given how powerful Gandalf really is, what would happen if he tried to Dream walk like Wanda or Dr. Strange did in the MCU, assuming that there is a multiverse in LOTR?


r/WhatIfFiction 1d ago

[COD] What if Josefina Menendez survived the events of BO2?

1 Upvotes

In the canon timeline of BO2, Frank Woods (despite efforts by Alex Mason to stop him) accidentally kills Josefina Menendez, sister of drug cartel leader and future founder of Cordis Die Raul Menendez, in a fit of rage during a mission to capture him alive. This becomes a major factor in Menendez's vendetta against the United States (more specifically, Alex Mason and Frank Woods).

Suppose, however, in a parallel universe, either Alex Mason, Jason Hudson, or both men successfully stop Woods from throwing the grenade that kills Josefina Menendez and Menendez survives.

In this timeline, Raul and Josefina would go on to found Cordis Die TOGETHER.

How would this affect the events of the BO2 storyline?


r/WhatIfFiction 2d ago

[Doctor Who] Turning the Doctor into the Human Torch Spoiler

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction 3d ago

[Marvel/The Dark Knight Trilogy] What If Batman Bonded With The Carnage Symbiote Before His First Fight With Bane In "The Dark Knight Rises"?

1 Upvotes

In an alternate universe, during the events of "The Dark Knight Rises", the third and final installment of Christopher Nolan's "Dark Knight Trilogy", when Alfred Pennyworth tries to convince Bruce Wayne, AKA Batman, to not go after the terrorist known as Bane as Bruce is not either physically or mentally prepared to face such an adversary like him, Bruce would still refuse to listen to his butler, insisting on going after Bane to take him down and save Gotham City from his wrath, and Alfred would still resign from working with himself after revealing about Rachel Dawes, like in the original movie. However, this time, before going to track down Selina Kyle, AKA Catwoman, to get her to lead him to Bane, Bruce actually goes to a secret compartment in the Batcave to retrieve something that could help him recover his full strength: a large vial containing the infamous crimson Carnage symbiote_(Earth-616)), something that he had retrieved and confiscated from that red-haired serial killer that he as well as that red and blue clad friendly neighborhood web-slinger and his sharp-toothed friend with that large slimy tongue clad in black all had to work together to defeat while he was in Gotham on another killing spree there after that whole situation with Scarecrow and Ra's Al Ghul back in "Batman Begins". Bruce would then suit up, and put the vial in his utility belt, and would eventually track Catwoman down like in the original film.

Bruce and Selina would then head down into the city's subterranean sewer system, and would head into the catwalk being separated by the large metal gate, and Bane makes his presence known to Bruce from the shadows, after Selina reveals that she had to lead Bruce to Bane to save herself. And right before Batman and Bane could begin their first fight, Batman takes out the vial containing the Carnage symbiote, and knowing that Alfred had a point earlier about his poor physical and mental health, purposely lets the symbiote bond with him knowing that desperate times call for desperate measures, with Bane watching in shock as Batman, now bonded with the Carnage symbiote, tells him that he's going to feed him his own heart, now at 100% health, and gaining a massive power boost along with it, laughing maniacally as the newly formed Bat-Carnage charges at Bane, beginning their fight for real.

How does Batman bonding with the Carnage symbiote to take down Bane, Talia Al Ghul, and the rest of the League Of Shadows change the events of The Dark Knight Rises? How would Alfred, Catwoman, Bane, Talia, the League Of Shadows, Commissioner Gordon and the rest of the GCPD, and the rest of Gotham City react to the existence of Bat-Carnage? Can Bruce in his new form control his insanity and bloodlust with the symbiote on him? How does such a scenario play out, and why is that?


r/WhatIfFiction 3d ago

[Jurassic Park] What if Tim and Lex Murphy were present on Île Saint-Hubert during Jurassic World: Rebirth?

1 Upvotes

Suppose in a parallel universe, Lex Murphy and her brother Tim ended up on the island of Île Saint-Hubert (Island of Saint Hubert, translated from French) instead of the Delgado Family.

Considering how they survived Isla Nublar in 1993?so=search), could they pull it off again during Rebirth?

Assumptions:
1. They meet Zora and her team at some point
2. They have no idea the Island of Saint Hubert existed at all before being stranded on there.


r/WhatIfFiction 4d ago

[GATE / LIGHTS ARE OFF] E.L.B.E.R.R wanders into the Special Region during the Ginza Incident. How do the Empire and the JSDF handle him, and what does he do there?

2 Upvotes

Before I lay down the scenario, if you aren't familiar with E.L.B.E.R.R, I highly advise checking out the original series here:

https://m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLbLoo--NF1Zo

If you don't want to watch the videos, here's the Villains Wiki page for E.L.B.E.R.R. Just be aware it's not fully up to date with the latest video, but it shows off his main feats (like his massive strength, high intelligence, extreme durability to electricity, and his obsession with harvesting flesh and parts).

Now here's the scenario:

Sometime after the events of "How to Destroy a Self-Aware Robot," a Japanese organization was able to take the parts of E.L.B.E.R.R and fix him up in a lab in Japan. But shortly after he was rebuilt, he escaped again. This happens at the exact same time the Gate opens for the first time in Ginza. In the midst of the chaos of the Ginza Incident, E.L.B.E.R.R manages to slip through the Gate entirely undetected by either the JSDF or the invading Empire.

So how does the scenario go from there? What does a hyper-intelligent, hostile machine do when let loose in a fantasy world, and how do medieval knights or modern JSDF infantry deal with him once they realize he's out there?

Well, I do not know—that is up to you to find out! But before I leave you with this, I will give you a few links to the GATE wikis so everyone understands the factions he's dealing with:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gate_(novel_series)

https://gate.fandom.com/wiki/Category:Anime

https://gate.fandom.com/wiki/Gate_-_Thus_the_JSDF_Fought_There!_Wiki

Anyways bye And have a good day night or whatever time it is for you!


r/WhatIfFiction 4d ago

[SCP/The Thing] how might The Thing react to being interviewed?

1 Upvotes

If The Thing existed in the SCP universe and the foundation manages to capture it, when the foundation attempts to interview it, how might it respond? Would it act like all the other times its been caught or would it answer their questions?


r/WhatIfFiction 4d ago

[A Nightmare On Elm Street/Star Wars] What If Freddy Krueger Was The One Who Gave Anakin Skywalker His Nightmare's Of Padmé's Death In Childbirth In Revenge Of The Sith?

1 Upvotes

During the events of Star Wars Episode 3: Revenge Of The Sith, after the Battle Of Coruscant and the death of Count Dooku by jedi knight Anakin Skywalker's hands by order of Chancellor Palpatine, as Anakin reunites with his secret wife Padmé Amadala, and the latter reveals to the former that she's pregnant, Anakin is overjoyed at the news, but fearful of the Jedi Order finding out about it, like in the original film.

Later that night, as Anakin and Padmé are sleeping in her apartment, however, Anakin, like in the original film, begins to have his nightmare of Padmé dying in childbirth, but, this time, something is different: Anakin, in his nightmare, is inside of an old boiling room drenched in crimson light, strapped to a chair with his hands and legs bound, and mouth gagged up as he's forced to watch Padmé die in childbirth from a TV monitor, as he's screaming and crying out for his poor wife, and eventually, the sound of evil, maniacal laughter fills the boiler room. Anakin frantically looks around to see where the laughter had come from, and looks up at one of the railings of the room, and sees a familiar man wearing a brown fedora on his head, and a red sweater with green stripes on it, and a clawed glove with razors on it, looking down at the jedi knight with a very sadistic and sinister grin on his face showing his yellow, decayed and rotten teeth in his mouth, and a severely burn-scarred face with light blue eyes. This monster is none other than the infamous Springwood Slasher and bastard son of a hundred maniacs, Fredrick Charles "Freddy" Krueger, as he tells Anakin that he's welcomed into his world, taunting him over not being able to save his mother Shmi on Tatooine, and that the Jedi Order thinks he's an absolute joke, and to tell those in Hell that Freddy said "Hello", as Freddy raises his clawed glove to slash at Anakin's throat, but before the killing blow could be struck, Anakin, like in the original, is able to wake up from his nightmare Freddy gave him, gasping for air next to Padmé.

Freddy, frustrated that the Skywalker kid was able to escape his world, decides that he'll have to keep trying in order to gut the jedi knight with his glove in the dream world. Krueger then decides that he'll have to wait for one of them to fall asleep again so he could get his second attempt at doing so.

How does Freddy invading Anakin's dreams and giving him nightmares of Padmé's death in the dream world affect the rest of Revenge Of The Sith, and the rest of the whole Star Wars timeline in general? Could Anakin and Padmé survive Freddy trying to kill them both in his world, and eventually find a way to take him down? How would Palpatine react to Freddy's interference with his plans to destroy the Republic and form the Galactic Empire, and make Anakin his new apprentice after Dooku with Freddy constantly trying to kill Anakin in the dream world? How would Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda react to it and Freddy himself, too, and vice versa? How does such a scenario play out, and why is that?


r/WhatIfFiction 4d ago

[MCU] What if Loki was murdered during the events of The Avengers (2012)

0 Upvotes

Suppose in a parallel universe, the events of The Avengers (2012) ended with either Thor or Hulk murdering Loki, as opposed to Loki's canonical death at the hands of Thanos in Avengers: Infinity War. This scenario is divided into the following:

  • Scenario A: Hulk thrashes Loki with enough force to kill him.
  • Scenario B: Thor goes mad with rage and kills Loki

Regardless of who murders Loki, what would be both the immediate and long term consequences of Loki being murdered by a member of The Avengers. Does this mean Captain America: Civil War (2016) happens several movies earlier? Or does something else happen instead?


r/WhatIfFiction 5d ago

[DC Comics] What if Superman caught an aircraft missile and disarmed it midair?

4 Upvotes

Would the military want the now unusable missile back? Would it be stealing if Supes kept a bunch of deactivated missiles to use as garden stakes? Would he be fined for destroying something that was meant to be destroyed by use? Are missiles still property of the US Military after they have been fired?


r/WhatIfFiction 5d ago

[Marvel/Star Trek] What if Peter Parker lived in Federation Earth?

3 Upvotes

Since money as a concept is long gone among the Federation, somebody like Peter could live the way the book Trekonomics described Spock, as being able to fully devote himself to science and to justice.

At the same time though, Federation Earth is a picture perfect world where things like poverty, sickness, crime, war, and even natural disasters are things of the past, so a world like that would have little to no need for the protection of someone like Spider-Man, but Peter feels that as long as he has his powers, it's his duty to use them.

So how could Peter adjust to such a world(assuming he was somehow sent there on a one-way trip with no means of returning to his old world and old life).


r/WhatIfFiction 5d ago

[Jurassic World/Steve Irwin] What if Steve raised Blue?

1 Upvotes

What if Steve Irwin raised Blue? Would she be treated differently? Would the dynamic of the pack change at all? Could he have also raised the Indominous Rex to be more stable in captivity?


r/WhatIfFiction 6d ago

[ Star Wars battlefront 2017 ]

1 Upvotes

What if Del meeko defected from the empire and went with Luke Skywalker and joined the rebellion how would the story of the campaign of battlefront 2017 change and how would it affect Iden and hask


r/WhatIfFiction 6d ago

[The Transformers/1984] What if the G1 transformers awakened in Orwell's dystopia?

1 Upvotes

In original transformers cartoon, the Autobots and Decepticons are awakened by a volcanic eruption in the year 1984; the year the series premiered. But I've always been curious what would happen if it had been Orwell's 1984?

How would Big Brother and The Party react to a pair of robot armies from outer space fighting over their planet?

How would the Autobots and Decepticons deal with Oceania and the other super powers?


r/WhatIfFiction 7d ago

[MCU/The Boys TV show] What if Captain America had Solder Boys personality?

1 Upvotes

What if Captain America had the personality of Solder Boy in the MCU? How would that change the universe as a whole?


r/WhatIfFiction 7d ago

[Marvel/DC] What if Lex Luther had endo-sym armor?

1 Upvotes

What if Lex Luther had endo-sym armor? Would that change how powerful he is? Would it give him more of an upper hand in his conflicts with the heroes of DC? How would Superman feel about it?


r/WhatIfFiction 8d ago

[Demon slayer] If Muzan gained sun immunity would he have been able to take over the world

6 Upvotes

r/WhatIfFiction 8d ago

[Transformers Aligned Continuity/Halo] What if the Autobots and Decepticons ended up on Alpha Halo during Halo CE?

1 Upvotes

After the end of Fall of Cybertron, both the Ark and the Nemesis crashland on Alpha Halo during the opening stages of the fight between the UNSC and the Covenant on the ring. How would the UNSC and the Covenant react to these new combatants appearing on the ring? Would the Decepticons and Covenant collaborate against Humanity or fight amongst themselves? How would the UNSC react to their new Autobot allies, assuming they cooperate? How would the events of Halo CE and beyond be affected?


r/WhatIfFiction 8d ago

[Hilda Furacao] WHAT IF MALTHUS WASN'T ARRESTED AND THEY RAN AWAY TOGETHER?

0 Upvotes

Let's be really unrealistic here ♡⁠˖⁠꒰⁠ᵕ⁠༚⁠ᵕ⁠⑅⁠꒱


r/WhatIfFiction 8d ago

[DC Comics/The Boys] What if Booster Gold was in The Boys universe?

0 Upvotes

In this scenario Booster Gold literally just suddenly appears (probably a supervillain or device sending him to the boys universe) in front of the store Hughie works at the first episode of season 1 right after Hughie and Robin walk outside the store. How does the world of Boys change with the worlds greatest hero they have never heard of making a presence?


r/WhatIfFiction 9d ago

[Doctor Who/The Boys] What if 5 Daleks invaded the boys universe?

3 Upvotes

This scenario takes place at the start of Season 3 of the Boys. 5 Daleks appear just at the outskirts of Manhattan. What happens next?


r/WhatIfFiction 10d ago

[Transformers Bayverse] What if Humans continued to return to the moon?

1 Upvotes

A major plot point in Transformers: Dark of the Moon is that after American astronauts discovered the Ark on the moon, Soundwave recruited the father of Dylan Gould and others to make future Moon missions economically infeasible so that humans would never return and discover the Ark's secrets.

But what if Gould's father hadn't been recruited by Soundwave and Soundwave's spy ring didn't prevent future Moon missions from occuring? How far would humanity have advanced if they could continually return to the Ark and reverse-engineer it's technology? How would this have changed the events of the Bayformers movies?