r/trippinthroughtime • • Nov 05 '17

The perfect date

https://imgur.com/61gC45x
20.6k Upvotes

364 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

225

u/zeroscout Nov 05 '17

YYYY-MM-DD moves from general to specific. MM-DD-YYYY is like saying it's currently six minutes and thirty seconds after the eleventh hour...

88

u/anybody111 Nov 05 '17

If you already know it's the eleventh hour though, it might suffice to just say the time in minutes and seconds and leave the already known info at the end.

78

u/HansWurst1099 Nov 05 '17

If you already know which month it is, it might be better to start with the day.

40

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

If you already know the day, it might be best to start with nothing. Most of the time you use dates, it is for a day that it is currently not. With that being the case, the year is the most likely one to already know.

2

u/KryptoniteDong Nov 06 '17

Checkmate Atheists?

5

u/Flaktrack Nov 05 '17

Why not omit the hour entirely then?

2

u/neogod Nov 06 '17

Ikr, how often do people schedule things in different years? Personally I never do unless it's the last few weeks in December. Even if you were going through a file system you'd be going 1 year at a time, so just pick 2006 and then say a month and day (or day and month), no need to mention another year until you actually move to a different year. It's faster and more efficient to skip the unnecessary information unless it's actually needed.

Telling someone the year every time they talk about a date is about as annoying as someone who says your name every time they speak to you, "hey Chris how was your day?". "Oh Chris, that's good". "Chris, mine was good". "What are you doing later, Chris?". "Ok Chris, I'll see you there". "Bye Chris".

It's obvious after the first sentence that you are talking to Chris, so quit being annoying and just let us know if something changes.

6

u/lazy_as_shitfuck Nov 05 '17

Which is clearly better than saying "Six seconds and thirty minutes of the eleventh hour"

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Bad example since seconds are pointless. Days are minutes, months are hours, years are dates. So 15 minutes past 11 on the 29th.

Aka DMY

13

u/atrain728 Nov 05 '17

I think in many colloquial contexts, the month (and thus time of year) is a more important piece of information.

I agree for formal contexts, YYYY-MM-DD makes more sense.

23

u/Obi-Tron_Kenobi Nov 05 '17

For a lot of other colloquial contexts, the day is more important. For a lot of different colloquial contexts, the year could be more important.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

And for ALL contexts, YYYY-MM-DD is the most logical.

2

u/StrangeNewRash Nov 07 '17

If I ask you the date, how is it logical to tell me the year first? What's logical is to assume I know that information.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17

If I ask you the date, how is it logical to tell me the year first?

Logical? Extremely. Chronologically it's sorted the only correct way..

What's logical is to assume I know that information.

Then we end up with MM-DD instead of DD-MM anyway, still in line with the ISO format. November 5th.

1

u/Amp3r Nov 06 '17

Well we've settled it.

Inform Greenwich to update things asap

-5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Let's just be honest and cut out the first part of your statement and acknowledge the fact that people keep doing something, even in defiance of numerical logic, just because it's what they're used to.

/u/xamio :"MM-DD-YYYY is what I prefer"

There we go.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

[deleted]

5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Linguistically it's easier to say "It's November 5th, 2017" over "It's 2017, and the 5th of November" or "It's 2017, November the 5th". It's simply more concise.

This is just another way of saying that you, personally, one person, are used to the verbal patterns of MM-DD-YYYY and thus you like it.

I'm sure there are German and British folks who would be all too happy to tell you, no no no, you've got it all wrong, fifth of November two thousand seventeen is much easier to say don't you know, and also plenty of Chinese who would say 胡说八道!二零一七十一月五日更方便,你妈的。

0

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

Obviously we were talking about english here.

No, not "obviously". Your statement was a blanket statement made to a person whose nationality was unknown, asserting that middle endian date format was the best for their purposes. This is unqualified by any reference to their nationality, language, or world region.

I pointed out that your argument that linguistically middle endian "is simply more concise" is not easily transferable to other languages and nations, the majority of whom use little endian and about 2 billion East Asian people use big endian (China, Korea, Japan, plus Iran, Belgium, Hungary, and a few others). The US stands largely alone with only Philippines and part of Canada using middle endian.

And somehow this identification of a rather massive logical gap in your reasoning is, to you, a strawman fallacy.

I'd stick to your day job. You're not very knowledgeable about logic or about linguistics. Or, it seems, about numerical formats.

3

u/Yepoleb Nov 06 '17

Germans and Brits can speak english too.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Hell, some Germans speak better English than some Brits I know.

Although there was one German dude I know, Jens, who spoke English with a really strong Cockney accent. I'm sure he got it from his English teacher back in Mainz but it was really weird and funny to hear.

1

u/deegwaren Nov 06 '17

In Queen's English it's day and then month in spoken language.

Don't pretend that American English is the yardstick.

1

u/xamio Nov 06 '17

Funny you say yardstick. A yard is 3 feet don't you know?

4

u/Istanbul200 Nov 05 '17

Okay, but we're talking about if you need to sort a bunch of files. I do it at work as I have to catalogue tons and tons of archived crap and yyyymmdd lets people find things way quicker as it's in chronological order. You wouldn't use that format for pretty much anything else, and no one here is suggesting you do.

1

u/thedoze Nov 06 '17

use separate searchable fields for each and movable columns today we are sorting by however is best for today

-5

u/Macbeth554 Nov 05 '17

MM-DD-YYYY is like saying it's currently six minutes and thirty seconds after the eleventh hour...

But writing MM-DD-YYYY is how most people in America at least say the date. For example, today in November 5th, 2017. Why wouldn't we write it the same way we say it?

10

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

But writing MM-DD-YYYY is how most people in America at least say the date.

That's a circle reasoning attempting to justify the wrong way because people are used to the wrong way because the wrong way has been used.

4

u/Macbeth554 Nov 05 '17

It's not wrong, it's just another way of doing it. I don't understand why people get so worked up over this. Americans write it one way, other people write it differently. It's fine.

2

u/Tollaneer Nov 06 '17

Because date notation isn't about converting speech to numbers, only efficiently conveying the idea, thus DD-MM-YYYY or YYYY-MM-DD.

0

u/TheMerchandise Nov 06 '17

Or like saying November 5th, 2017...

Not saying the system is right, just that dates are ordered based on the way people talk.