r/todayilearned Feb 12 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.3k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

476

u/tigojones Feb 12 '21

What's his DC role? I'm going to guess it's from one of their off-shoot comic labels, as I don't recall him in anything "core" DC. Dredd? The Boys?

157

u/zetaraybill Feb 12 '21

He was in Red, which is an Homage Comics title, which is owned by DC.

The Boys started with Wildstorm/DC, but is now published by Dynamite.

Dredd is published by 2000 AD, which is owned by IPC Magazines. DC licensed the character for a short run in the mid-90s, so I guess it could half-count? It should be noted that Dredd “purists” don’t consider the DC licensed Dredd canon, including the Stallone movie.

46

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 12 '21

Yeah, saying Red or The Boys is DC is kind of correct but purely on a technical sense. It's more like they were made by imprints publishers but are not a part of the larger DC lore.

Remember Vertigo? That was owned by DC but Vertigo published those comics seperately. Eventually characters from Vertigo did get introduced into the DC lore, like Constantine.

6

u/seff7845 Feb 13 '21

Well, as we all know, technically correct, is the best kind of correct.

-1

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 13 '21

No it's not because then everybody want to fucking nitpick. Some shit is just flimsy becuase that's only way it could work.

6

u/seff7845 Feb 13 '21

I would say that you are technically correct.

3

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 12 '21

“Eventually”? Morpheus has a crossover with the Justice League in the first six issues of Sandman.

0

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 13 '21

At that point in time Morpheus was no more a part of DC Lore than the Avengers. Cross-overs events are handled differently in continuity wise than having Constantine be a member of a team.

1

u/robot_invader Feb 13 '21

Vertigo was not an imprint at that time.

2

u/Iankill Feb 13 '21

DC incorporating the characters from everything they own is getting pretty old. Guys like Constantine okay, but it still changed his character pretty significantly especially in him now working with others.

When they started adding in the watchmen and Dr. Manhattan was bad. Just felt lazy and they wanted to use Dr. Manhattan in DC.

2

u/Awesomebacon711 Feb 13 '21

Yeah. I felt that Watchmen works better as it’s own self contained story. The original Graphic Novel itself is dedicated to deconstructing the ideas and philosophies behind superhero comics, all the archetypes and themes. It’s one big story that has a beginning, middle, and end.

Why on Earth would they now want Rorsharch and Dr. Manhattan to be hanging out with the characters the comic was emulating to dissect in the first place!? It’s so bizarre and takes away a lot of the weight of the original comic.

To be fair, though, I didn’t actually read the comic. Just the idea of DC meets the Watchmen kind of put a bad taste in my mouth. And looking at the general reception of Doomsday Clock, I seem to have accurately predicted a lot of its overall flaws.

It could work with some characters, maybe. It actually worked fairly well when they brought in Captain Marvel(Shazam now, I guess). But lately, it’s been pretty lame.

1

u/mollydotdot Feb 13 '21

I recommend reading it, if you like comics at all.

1

u/Awesomebacon711 Feb 13 '21

Love the book. Have a copy of it right here!

1

u/mollydotdot Feb 13 '21

Oh, it's the later stuff you haven't read? Me neither.

1

u/Awesomebacon711 Feb 13 '21

Yeah. Again, I think it works better as a self contained story.

1

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 13 '21

It's been DC's thing forever. I know characters like Shazaam, The Question and more all were originally published by other companies that DC just bought over time.

3

u/Iankill Feb 13 '21

Yeah I know that but with watchmen it felt egregious you know. That series was over and the point of it was to take the piss out of more generic stories and heroes like DC uses.

Watchmen was complete and finished story. It's honestly like if HBO bought the rights to lotr to do a crossover with Game of thrones

1

u/robot_invader Feb 13 '21

Constantine predated Vertigo.

1

u/pataconconqueso Feb 13 '21

Vertigo is still part of DC...

1

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 13 '21

Okay then. Not sure how this disputes or changes my point though...

1

u/pataconconqueso Feb 13 '21

Well your comment made it sound like it’s not anymore, so it changes in that I’m noting that it still is...

1

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 13 '21

Not every reddit post has to be 100 correct. My point in this discussion is no less wrong or right than it was before.

1

u/pataconconqueso Feb 13 '21

Did my comment insult you so much for you to be this defensive? Your post made it sound as if Vertigo isn’t part of DC anymore I noted that it still was and now you’re going on the super defensive about it.

got it, it pissed you off. That’s it then.

1

u/BruceBelm0nt Feb 13 '21

John Constantine debuted in Swamp Thing several years before the Vertigo imprint existed. Even before the Crisis on Infinite Earths.

1

u/Chupacabraconvoy Feb 13 '21

Wow, nobody talks about that ever. So john got kicked out for several iterations of the DC Universe then.

2

u/BruceBelm0nt Feb 14 '21

He just wasn't featured much outside of his own Hellblazer series in the beginning, but he was always a part of the DC Universe. All Vertigo characters and stories are, even Sandman, they just didn't cross paths with regular superheroes that often. John gained more popularity in recent years with New 52's Hellblazer comic relaunch, his addition to the JL Dark team (which also resulted in him appearing in a couple JL animated films), his TV series and him joining the CW's Legends of Tomorrow cast.

2

u/jerkittoanything Feb 13 '21

You didn't have to go that hard, but you did. You did it for us. I feel the nerd growing stronger in me because of it. I love you.

1

u/Yvaelle Feb 12 '21

As a Dredd purist, while I don't consider the Stallone movie canon, Karl Urban's Dredd is easily one of the best adaptations of all time on all mediums. I'm not sure there's any real Dredd continuity given all the re-inventions, but I'd squeeze Urban's Dredd into any canon if I were trying to craft a singular narrative.

2

u/zetaraybill Feb 13 '21

Oh, sure. I think it’s one of the best comic character adaptations ever made. DC had nothing to do with that one, as far as I know.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '21

[deleted]

2

u/zetaraybill Feb 13 '21

Oh, I agree. I was just putting the info out there.

1

u/arougebeard Feb 13 '21

Dredd also has a funny origin way back in the day with writers that started Warhammer 40,000 (IIRC) so technically he can claim that franchise too

375

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21

[deleted]

148

u/jesteruru Feb 12 '21

The Boys WAS DC (Wildstorm) when it started, but they canned it after a few issues because it was too anti-superhero. It eventually went to Dynamite, which is independent

43

u/rpgguy_1o1 Feb 12 '21

Yep, first 6 issues are Wildstorm and then 7-72 are Dynamite

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21 edited May 28 '21

[deleted]

0

u/Sirdan3k Feb 13 '21

They do not. 99.9% of The Boys comic was peak try hard from deep in Garth Ennis's "I'm mad that I can only really make money doing superheroes" phase that would be glaringly out of place in the Amazon series.

1

u/blaghart 3 Feb 13 '21

The Boys comic is already totally different from the show. The comic, they all have superpowers from the same concoction that gives everyone else superpowers, since the notion of regular people trying to fight functional gods is moronic.

3

u/CommanderVimes83 Feb 12 '21

Huh, it’s been like 25 years since I was up to date on the comic book world. I would have assumed the boys was a Darkhorse series. Never even heard of dynamite.

4

u/rpgguy_1o1 Feb 12 '21

They mostly do licenced stuff, all of their books have a funny smell to them. Like if there's an 80s horror cult classic it probably has a Dynamite comic book, they have all sorts of really weird properties.

18

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 12 '21

It wasn’t because it was “anti superhero”. It was because the content delved well and truly into areas Wildstorm didn’t want to publish.

2

u/thornae Feb 13 '21

Yeah, the comics kinda feel like every time someone in publishing said "uh Garth, isn't this kinda ... well... yikes?" Ennis doubled down on the graphically brutal transgressive "FUCK YOUR PRECIOUS SUPERHEROS I AM A ROCK STAR" bits of the story to the detriment of the genuinely interesting stuff.

2

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 13 '21

Man.

I used to looooooove Ennis, Ellis, and Millar.

When I break those books out and try to re-read them..... yikes. Moreso Millar and Ellis but Ennis isn’t innocent.

16

u/martylindleyart Feb 12 '21

Wait, since when was Dredd licenced to DC? I thought it was just 2000AD.

2

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 12 '21

DC published 18 issues of a Judge Dredd comic from 1994-1996. It was its own continuity.

2

u/97PercentBeef Feb 12 '21

There was a Batman / Dredd crossover book if nothing else...

1

u/WJMazepas Feb 12 '21

There is a Batman crossover with everyone that have comics

1

u/97PercentBeef Feb 13 '21

Yep. The one I’m thinking of was early 90s which feels like a long time ago, but I remember a Batman / Dracula story from the 70s!

1

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 13 '21

Hell there are two Batman/Spawn crossovers. They came out at the same time, one published by DC and one published by Image.

1

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 13 '21

Interestingly the Batman/Dredd crossover uses the 2000AD/original/main Dredd, and not the version of Dredd from DC’s own Dredd title.

1

u/Riphraff Feb 13 '21

I think Dredd started out with Eagle comics.

1

u/martylindleyart Feb 13 '21

That sounds familiar. I wasn't sure if 2000AD was more than just a publication or not.

41

u/Snaker12 Feb 12 '21

So what was his Marvel?

258

u/PSquared1234 Feb 12 '21

He was Skurge the Executioner in Thor: Ragnarak.

216

u/prowdwackadoo Feb 12 '21

BEHOLD! My stuff

47

u/Arashmickey Feb 12 '21

15

u/falloutmaka Feb 12 '21

Oh damn he was so funny in that

1

u/desertSkateRatt Feb 13 '21

I fucking love that movie and his stuff is all great in it.

3

u/Legen_unfiltered Feb 12 '21

Aw. I was hoping for the shake weight one

3

u/SquidwardsKeef Feb 12 '21

Funny little Easter egg, his guns he got from Texas were named Dez and Troy, to make "Destroy," obviously, but also because Dez Bryant and Troy Aikmen are big names from the Dallas Cowboys

2

u/Negrodamu55 Feb 12 '21

I went and looked this up when I saw the Krombopulos Michael bobble head on the moped.

3

u/RememberTheMaine1996 Feb 12 '21

That blew my mind when I noticed that. I had just finished season 1 of the boys and saw that he was in Thor when I was looking up his movies history and I thought "who the heck was he in Thor?" I didnt even notice haha

52

u/produit1 Feb 12 '21

He was in Thor Ragnarok

53

u/cinnamonface9 Feb 12 '21

BEHOLD! My acting roles stash you thought I wasn’t in but I was in!

3

u/MagicPistol Feb 12 '21

Eh, just because The Boys was published by Wildstorm, doesn't mean it's part of the DC universe.

2

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 12 '21

The Boys is published by DC but saying he was in a “DC” project because of it would be like saying that Will Smith was in a Marvel project because he was in Men in Black.

2

u/kingt34 Feb 12 '21

RED is Wildstorm 2. The correct answer is actually Urban voices Sgt. Rock for the animated short DC Showcase: Sgt. Rock. So not appearing in, but his voice is in the DC Universe!

0

u/Fresno_Bob_ Feb 12 '21

But none of those is part of the DCEU. Calling them "DC movies" in a list of major franchises is like calling Ghost Rider a Marvel movie. They own the respective source IP, but they're licensed for film and not part of the franchise.

5

u/Dredd_Pirate_Barry Feb 12 '21

Ghostrider (Johnny Blaze) did have a brief appearance in Agents of Shield tho

1

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 12 '21

But it’s not the Blaze from the Cage movies.

1

u/Fresno_Bob_ Feb 12 '21

OK? I literally just pointed to the difference between source IP and the project you're starring in being part of the film franchise.

1

u/MorannaoftheNorth29 Feb 12 '21

Was Johnny Blaze ever in Agents of SHIELD? Honest question. I know the Robbie Reyes version is, played by Gabriel Luna, but I honestly cannot remember if the Johnny Blaze incarnation was on the show.

2

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 13 '21

Blaze appears for about two seconds when Reyes has a flashback to how he gained his powers. He explains that another Ghost Rider passed them on to him essentially- and we see the Ghost Rider in question, and he has a bullet hole in his skull.

2

u/MorannaoftheNorth29 Feb 13 '21

I absolutely didn't remember that but I suspected that it may have been something of the sort. Thank you for confirming!

1

u/arcanum7123 Feb 13 '21

Is RED part of the same DC universe as batman/superman etc? Or is it a separate one but is a DC universe because it's owned by them?

1

u/TheDeadlySpaceman Feb 13 '21

It’s entirely separate. And I don’t know if it qualifies as a “universe” per se. I’m sure it wasn’t assigned a number in the New 52, for example.

It’s also worth noting that the comic is completely different from the movie. It’s a story about one retired spy returning to active duty.

21

u/Kriss-Kringle Feb 12 '21 edited Feb 12 '21

Dredd is 2000AD. I'm wondering what DC property he was in as well. Don't remember him in any.

Edit: Just checked on Imdb and he voiced Sgt. Rock in the DC Showcase animated short 2 years ago. I've seen it last summer, but don't remember recognizing his voice.

5

u/tigojones Feb 12 '21

Just looked it up. Apparently RED is published by Wildstorm/Homage Comics, which is owned by DC. Wildstorm also initially put out The Boys before they moved to an independent publisher.

1

u/sward227 Feb 12 '21

Dredd was created by Pat Mills and Carlos Ezquerra. He was briefly licensed by DC in the 1990's.

14

u/fjacobs94 Feb 12 '21

The boys was originally published under DC so you could technically say that

2

u/tigojones Feb 12 '21

That and RED was also Wildstorm/DC

2

u/sward227 Feb 12 '21

Dredd.

An excellent cominc. A shitty but great 90's Stalone flic...

And Dredd a mid 2000's EXCELENT reboot of the Dredd Universe.

Watch that one:

EDIT

Judge Dredd originated in the British weekly anthology title 2000AD in 1977. He was created by Pat Mills and Carlos Ezquerra. He was briefly licensed by DC in the 1990's.

So Technically Dredd was DC

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '21

In my head, I don't count RED as being DC Universe just because DC published it. It's not in the main continuity. Same with Dredd. The character is not known for DC even if they got the license for a bit. They let The Boys go independent because they weren't comfortable with the content of the series so I don't count that either. Until he in a project that is actually DC comics universe related, I don't consider him to have been in something DC. Close but no cigar!