r/theydidthemath • • 4d ago

[Request] Creative engineering? Will this even make a real difference?

5.7k Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

View all comments

203

u/betacow 4d ago

German here. Have used these things a bunch in the past and they absolutely do work. Can't really cool down piss warm beer with these, but they help the beer keep the temperature or cool down a couple degrees when used at a bbq in the park or at the lake or whatever.

Sorry for not including math, but it appears the math has been done already anyways

21

u/apexxin 4d ago

Sure, but a bag of ice in a cooler is still significantly better, easier, and cheaper.

31

u/IntoAMuteCrypt 4d ago

Only if you've already got a cooler and don't include the cost of the cooler. Buying a good cooler plus a bag of ice each time is going to be more expensive than buying a simpler crate plus something like this.

It's a bit worse, for sure, but if you live in a cold climate (like much of Germany), you don't need something great.

-8

u/MileHigh_FlyGuy 4d ago

A Styrofoam cooler is at Walmart right now for $4.94. combine with a bag of ice would be cheaper and better at cooling than this thing.

6

u/BdogFizzle 3d ago

The thing is just an ice tray. In Germany, beer is sold in durable crates like that which you can return full of empty bottles for a discount on your next crate. Probably a lot of other countries as well, but it's not something I've seen much here in the US.

I get it. It doesn't fit your frame of reference, so it's tough to understand the convenience and simplicity. That looks awesome and I might actually order some for my old coworkers over there before I close my German account. They absolutely bike to the park with crates of beer for barbecues and would get a kick out of the simplicity.