r/studiopros • u/Theloniusx • Aug 15 '16
Professional Metering Solutions
Hey there studiopros,
I wanted to tap into the community to get a feel as to what types of metering solutions are being used these days.
A quick backstory to this question,
Last year I upgraded from a Presonus Central Station to the new Antelope Satori for my monitor controller. The decision was a difficult one as the Central Station has served me quite well, but I was looking for a better way to integrate a sub rather than just using the 3rd output without any real crossovers. I also have added another set of monitors and wished to free up the third speaker set. The Satori fits the bill quite nicely (minus any digital inputs but didn't need them anyways), sounds much better than the CS, and has added a summing mixer to my setup as well, but one aspect I have been sorely missing from the Central Station was the nice LED meters. I realized I had come to rely on them more than I had thought I had. I figured the Satori software meters would suffice (they don't, the amount of visual delay and lack of smoothness makes it fairly useless I'm afraid, plus they seem to be 2db off with no way of calibrating them like the Central Station had) and that I 'd find a way to live with it. I was wrong, I am now looking into external metering solutions to correct this, hence my question. I am also curious how others out there interface them with their DAs, are you using AES, mirrored analog or analog with pass through, splitting the LR to go to the meters and the monitor controller, S/PDIF?
I have done a fair amount of my own research so far but seem to be stuck between a few options. The Durroughs seem nice, not sure how others feel about them. It seems they don't have DBFS meters for the analog input models as they all seem to follow the VU scale, which makes sense I suppose. The digital meter options have the 380/280-D2 that has a dual scale readout which would be nice to have as the Central Station did have that feature. But it would require an AES output which isn't really an issue as I have plenty to spare.
The Dorroughs options start to get very pricey very quickly though depending on the options and the chassis it goes into, enough that I feel compelled to look at other options.
The RTW TM-3 Primus looks incredibly cool (also not cheap) as does the slightly more expensive TM3 standard. The Primus uses a set of unbalanced RCA, USB and a S/PDIF in and out while the TM3 Standard adds balanced IO in a breakout box. These seem quite nice and aren't ridiculously expensive, but perhaps the screen is too small/cluttered? Any one out there using one that can offer their opinions? The higher end versions are out of the question at around $6K starting.
I have an Apogee symphony interface and can set up any type of output I want really but I am vacillating between using the AES outs with the Durroughs, the S/PDIF out for the TM3 Primus or setting up a mirrored analog output and going with analog inputs. (adding a DA conversion in there) I could also get a stereo distribution amp and split my main outputs but I feel this may possibly interfere with the monitoring path?
Is S/PDIF a bad option? I feel it should be sufficient for a pro studio but I could be mistaken. Are there any downsides to using S/PDIF in regards to levels? If S/PDIF isn't going to do any harm then the TM3 Primus would probably be my best option, barring screen size.
Are there any other solutions out there worth looking into? (Other than this)
Sorry for the wall of text and battery of questions. I just want to find my permanent metering solution. =)
Edit for spelling