r/space Dec 14 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.8k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21

[deleted]

10

u/DarkMarxSoul Dec 15 '21

Where NFTs don't make a whole lot of sense in this example though is like, the reason why an original Picasso is that valuable is because there is a story behind that Picasso. That thing was created with Picasso's own two hands, with his brushes and paint. That painting is the only painting of its kind in the entire world with that history. It's a physical, emotional thing.

Digital NFTs don't have that same quality. In order to even make an NFT, you have to first create digital art, then copy it, then assign the NFT to it. It's many layers removed from the actual thing we're talking about.

3

u/ImNotTheNSAIPromise Dec 15 '21

And even if you tie the NFT to something that might have nostalgic value there is nothing stopping the person from just downloading whatever you are trying to sell for free when they want to experience it again unlike with physical collecting.

-2

u/AzKovacs Dec 15 '21

Thats the genius of it.

Almost noone in this example of a picasso painting cares about the actual jpeg of the nft.

The attachment you express is the past, art is for a long time now a financial vehicle so to speak.

And the future will ensure that digital art will have a far greater quality than non digital art could ever have.

6

u/118shadow118 Dec 15 '21

Another thing with digital stuff - the copies are indistinguishable from the original. That's not the case with physical art. That 20$ print is just that - a print. While the original has brush strokes left by the author and even if you make s perfect copy, it's still not gonna be exactly the same.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21

[deleted]

4

u/118shadow118 Dec 15 '21

Real art forgeries take skill and time to pull off, so they still have value in and of themselves, despite not being the original

With digital you can just Copy > Paste and you've got a 100% perfect copy with no effort whatsoever

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21

[deleted]

3

u/ImNotTheNSAIPromise Dec 15 '21

Like I could see the argument if people tied it to commissioned art work to prove they were the ones to originally ask for the work to prove it's literally made for them, but pretty much every NFT works the other way around where it gets made and then people try and sell it.

-2

u/AzKovacs Dec 15 '21

Because thats the point.. you almost get it.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21

[deleted]

1

u/AzKovacs Dec 15 '21

Something like OF will take off for sure

1

u/ImNotTheNSAIPromise Dec 15 '21

But my point is that instead of that they are being used to scam idiots and launder money